4 ms·
The Taptic Engine, along with 3D Touch is probably the most useless things ever on an iPhone. Some may argue that the home button is a moving part and can fail
by Nextgrid 8y ago
The Taptic Engine, along with 3D Touch is probably the most useless things ever on an iPhone. Some may argue that the home button is a moving part and can fail but personally I've never had any issue with them. I don't think the occasional failures (that are bound to happen no matter what) warrant redesigning the entire mechanism.
- SallySwanSmith 8y ago3D Touch to quick jump to a app with a notification buried in a folder is amazing
- stephenr 8y ago> Some may argue that the home button is a moving part and can fail but personally I've never had any issue with them. Asia wishes to disagree with you. There are literally millions of people here who turn on AssistiveTouch on a brand new phone for no other reason than to not use the physical home button because they believe it will wear out/break.
- Nextgrid 8y ago> they believe it will wear out/break But does it actually? Because if it's just a belief, nothing prevents the same belief from occurring with the 3D Touch home button. I guess it's going to be a feedback loop because obviously there wouldn't be reports of failures if nobody uses the physical button, but assuming normal usage, does the button fail frequently enough to be a concern? I think the west is a clear proof that this is not the case (unless something in Asia is breaking the buttons - climate maybe?).
- mixmastamyk 8y agoButton working fine on my 6s, older 5 my wife used worked fine as well. The 5 was finally replaced when the battery expanded. Anecdotal evidence says they are dependable.
- eridius 8y agoIt does, actually, AIUI the home button was the #1 driver of AppleCare incidents for non-accidental damage. It had the highest failure rate of any component on the phone.
- iainmerrick 8y agoThat’s a mass hysteria over nothing. Unfortunately it’s impossible to fix.
- stephenr 8y agoThe home button on my 5S failed (followed by the screen). So it’s not nothing. It may be an exaggerated fear but it’s clearly based on some failures, otherwise they wouldn’t use the phone at all, in case the screen “breaks”
- Nextgrid 8y agoI guess the difference between the screen and the button is that the screen is mandatory for using the phone, while the button is optional. Also I'm sure those people wouldn't actually use the phone at all if they had an equivalent way to achieve the same tasks that doesn't involve risking breaking a phone. Finally let's put it that way - if you use AssistiveTouch right away you lose the home button. If it breaks after X months/years of use you also lose the home button. Wouldn't it still be better to get value out of the button while it's still working rather than falling back to AT right away?
- stephenr 8y agoI didn’t say I agree with their usage patterns, just explaining that they have them (I’m not Asian but live here) It may be a cost/value issue. Better to protect a perceived fragile part so it’s not damaged when they want to sell it for a newer model.
- mikestew 8y agoAsia wishes to disagree with you. Yes, that was parent's "some may argue..." part. That doesn't mean Asia are right. Some in that same part of the world would argue that running a fan can kill me, so something something urban legends.
- masukomi 8y agoyeah, that's been written about before. It's a false belief based on info that's not applicable to current devices. It is just baseless superstition at this point. Unfortunately, everyone believes it and makes their lives far worse with that stupid assistive touch thing when they don't need to.
- gumby 8y ago...whereas I use 3D Touch all the time to interact with notifications and icons. It's an important part of my "workflow" because I can do certain things ("yes I just took that medication") rapidly and barely interrupting what I was actually in the middle of doing, which is living my life. I agree discovery of 3D interactions is terrible -- essentially nonexistent -- which does justify the epithet "useless" to some degree.
- kemoly 8y agoPlease, can you comment on which app you use to control your medications? From your brief description it sounds much better than mine, which forces me to go into the app, wait for a prompt, and then confirm that I took the medication. Thanks!
- gumby 8y agoI use Medisafe, and interact through notifications, its widget, and watch notification. It gets the job done. Good luck.
- CodeWriter23 8y agoI actually prefer the “emulation” of 3D Touch my entry-level iPad has: the long touch. Just tap and hold for maybe a quarter second. It feels snappier to me than mashing my iPhone screen.
- gumby 8y agoI suspect Apple may go that way, but, for example, long press and 3D Touch on a folder in springboard do different things, both useful.
- CodeWriter23 8y agoThat’s long press and even longer press on my iPad.
- eridius 8y ago