7 ms·
I'm not really sure there is much in the way of "efforts". The drug companies now control and manipulate the market. One law here or there won't fix it. I t
by duxup 8y ago
I'm not really sure there is much in the way of "efforts".
The drug companies now control and manipulate the market. One law here or there won't fix it.
I think the larger question is if congress wants to effectively break the market and if the politicians want to take on the task of rewriting a lot of law / taking on the drug companies.
- maxxxxx 8y agoWhatever they will be doing will end like Obamacare. There may be some changes around the edges but the fundamental problems of US healthcare won’t even be touched. The incumbents are way too entrenched and their propaganda is very successful with a lot of citizens.
- nagVenkat 8y agoLot of incumbent democrats lost their seats in 2010 after voting for Obamacare.
- Dirlewanger 8y agoDon't have the data, but I'm willing to bet part of the reason is probably because a lot of people that didn't have an insurance plan before Obamacare now were forced to lest they pay the penalty; that's all the ACA really is anyway: a glorified mandate saying one had to pick private insurance from the government's limited marketplace or they'll be fined. Didn't solve dick...but hey, Obama did it so it must be progress!
- maxxxxx 8y agoThe change how preexisting conditions are handled was huge. Before Obamacare it was really hard to get and keep health insurance for people with chronic conditions. Unfortunately it seems the current administration wants to go back to these “glory days”
- scarface74 8y agoAs opposed to the way it was before where if you didn’t have insurance , you could go to the emergency room and they still had to treat you?
- peteey 8y agoUS forced insurance seems like part of the problem. From the article, the response to "when did drug prices ratchet ups" was "when prescription drug coverage became part of Medicare" This singular problem point was completely ignored by the rest of the article and in the proposed solutions. It seems like no matter what drug companies charge, our government MUST pay it. And citizens not covered by the government MUST buy health insurance. The ACA says it is illegal for you not to buy coverage; if you don't there is a fine. If you to not pay this fine (individual responsibility tax), you go to jail. The case of Nelene Fox shows that HMOs MUST pay for anything, even unreasonable procedures for terminally ill patients. How can the market function when you MUST PAY?
- maxxxxx 8y agoThe ban on Medicare negotiating drug prices was a nice giveaway for the companies by the Bush administration. But this can be changed anytime if the is political will.
- post_break 8y agoSerious question, if laws won't fix it, how does India do it? From my very limited understanding India doesn't have these high costs?
- b_tterc_p 8y agoThey manufacture their own drugs piggy-backing off American R&D and then sell them for much much smaller margins. America's lucrative drug market funds research which allows the rest of the world to benefit at no cost to them. Edit: seem to be getting downvoted because people think I’m saying drug companies do this out of benevolence. Not my intention. I’m saying that wrenching maximum dollars out of America but having little ability to capture returns elsewhere is a mechanism by which new drugs are created and later manufactured as foreign generics
- saiya-jin 8y agoThat is only partially true - real costs of drugs say in Switzerland are properly astronomical (don't know their comparison to US but would expect same or higher). But we have pretty effective medical insurance - after paying initial yearly sum, insurance kicks in and covers 90% of the costs. No massive incomprehensible bureaucracy and fooling around with various charges. It doesn't matter what your employer is, you pay it yourself, it covers you no matter the age, status or existing state. It can still be costly to encounter something serious, some other countries cover 100% of the costs (but question is the quality and speed of treatment, because if its free, old people with tons of mostly incurable ailments can easily flood the system). If it can properly ruin you, social system steps in.
- maxxxxx 8y ago“America's lucrative drug market funds research which allows the rest of the world to benefit at no cost to them.” I think it’s more likely that it funds higher profits for the companies and all the middlemen. This is just self serving propaganda by the pharmaceutical companies.
- b_tterc_p 8y ago
- astazangasta 8y agoOne point I would like everyone to keep top of mind in this conversation: a patent monopoly is not a market. Prices are dictated by the government, which will arrest anyone besides the patent holder who tries to sell. In this case the price is set to "whatever the drug company wants to charge", but it could as well be set to $0 if the government so desired.
- rayiner 8y agoYes and no. A patent exchanges short term protection for long term commoditization of the invention, which permits not only a market, but an extremely competitive one (because the invention has been documented and disseminated).
- LyndsySimon 8y ago> Prices are dictated by the government, which will arrest anyone besides the patent holder who tries to sell. I'd like to challenge this. Yes, the patent system allows for a time-limited monopoly for the inventor of a drug - but it does not, to my knowledge, in any way "dictate prices" for that drug. That is up to the owner of the patent, who rationally will optimize for profit. Optimizing for profit does not mean "charging as much as possible", either; it means "charging the amount resulting in the highest net profit". There is the supply and demand curve to take into account here.
- dan678 8y agoUnfortunately, optimizing for profit still puts too many people in a position where they go bankrupt or die because of lack of funds. It's not theory, this is happening today in the United States. We need reform.
- okr 8y agoI agree in general. But lets not forget, without the incentive to make profit, someone would not have done the investment and work to invent something in the first place. So some treatment would not even exist at all.