4 ms·
1- 1/r^2 is the most natural in 3D space. Think of it as the surface of en expanding sphere. A lot of things follow the inverse square law: electric fields, lig
by GuB-42 8y ago
1- 1/r^2 is the most natural in 3D space. Think of it as the surface of en expanding sphere. A lot of things follow the inverse square law: electric fields, light intensity, sound intensity,... It is not a strong argument: there are other things that don't follow 1/r^2 and we are not even sure our universe really is 3D (though there is strong evidence for it).
2- Theories that don't involve 1/r^2 (MOND) exist, but they are not sufficient to match observations without involving dark matter. And following Occam's razor, since MOND introduces another parameter (the behavior of gravity on long scales), but doesn't simplify anything (dark matter is still there), it is not preferred.
3- While we don't know the details about dark matter, we "see" it in a way. We see it affect the movement of galaxies, and the gravitational lensing effect it has. It is just that we can't observe it with our preferred methods, which involve electromagnetism. I mean, we don't need to see a glass panel to know that it's there. Sure, we'd like to know more, and evidence of dark matter is weaker than our glass pane, but we simply don't have anything better right now.
- mikorym 8y agoA question on 1-: does introduction of intermediary objects stack well? What I mean, for instance: If the moon is between us and the sun, the light gets blocked out but gravity does not. Light intensity then does not stack well (for visible light frequencies) when there are intermediate objects. Or does the analogy here require a more formal transposition to GR and the distortion of spacetime?
- Steuard 8y agoI'm not sure that I understand your question. Certainly all of our understanding of astronomical effects includes (and often depends on) the effects of intervening clouds of gas and dust: that hasn't been overlooked or omitted from any professional-level analysis. (My memory/guess is that in the presence of an absorptive medium, influences like light intensity will fall off as e^(-a*r)/r^2 rather than just 1/r^2. But the point is that we can model that absorptive term reasonably well, and the underlying 1/r^2 still results naturally from 3D space.) (Meanwhile, to a first approximation, intervening dense objects like planets or stars are rare enough to be negligible: even in a region like our solar system where such objects are most likely to be found, the available volume is overwhelmingly empty space.)
- mikorym 8y agoMy question is whether gravity works like light, or whether you can just ignore the planets in between. When for example you calculate the effect of the sun on the earth but venus or mercury happen to be in a line of sight, does it influence the sun-earth calculation component? (Of course, the other planets have their own gravitational influence in line with r^2.)
- xenophonf 8y agoAre you indirectly asking whether planets can be dark matter candidates? If so, those are called MACHOs (massive compact halo objects). They have been studied via the gravitational microlensing effect. The presence of MACHOs can't account for most dark matter. https://arxiv.org/pdf/astro-ph/0001272.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/astro-ph/0001272.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/astro-ph/9904401.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/astro-ph/9904401.pdf When you see figures like "1E-7 to 1E-2 M⊙ mass range" (from the above paper's introduction), note that a Jupiter mass is about 1E-3 M⊙---one thousandth or 0.1% the mass of the Sun. Earth is 3E-6 M⊙, the Moon is 3.7E-8 M⊙, and Pluto is 6.6E-9 M⊙; or 0.00037%, 0.000004%, and 0.00000066% the mass of the Sun respectively. Compared to stars, planets comprise a tiny fraction of the mass of a galaxy. TL;DR - No, that's not how gravity works, but you can still ignore the planets in between because they're tiny.
- ruds 8y agoI think the question is: given a 3-body system with objects A, B, and C, is C's gravitational effect on A altered in any way by the position of B, or are B's and C's effects on A independent? The reason for the question, I think, is because of an intuition built up around EM. In the system A B C B can block and otherwise interfere with C's EM radiation so that its effect on A is different depending on B's location.
- fhars 8y agoNo, if you want to think of gravity in analogy to light, you can see every mass as analog to a fully transparent light source. There is nothing in this universe that can absorb gravity.