4 ms·
I'm a bit uncomfortable with ideas like this being promoted in the popular press so much recently. Spy-vs-spy is something that, for better or worse, nations d
by neilv 8y ago
I'm a bit uncomfortable with ideas like this being promoted in the popular press so much recently.
Spy-vs-spy is something that, for better or worse, nations do. It seems a complicated and delicate matter, and outside the experience of most of us.
In the Boston area, we have a wealth of colleagues, neighbors, and friends who arrived here from around the world. We welcome and appreciate them.
Ordinary people suspecting others, because of something they heard in the news (or amplified in some right-wing outlet), seems unfair and toxic. We've even seen recently that it can be deadly, when a violent mentally ill person is inspired.
I think the international spy business can best be left to the professionals (diplomats, intel agencies, law enforcement, corporate security), to handle discreetly, and the rest of us can just get along.
- sureaboutthis 8y agoCompletely agree but I'd bet that, if this was an article about US spies, there would be hundreds of comments deriding it by now.
- i_am_proteus 8y agoIf the US government engaged in industrial espionage against a foreign company, whatever US company benefitted could be sued in a US court. What troubles me (and many others) about the PRC's behavior is the PRC's disregard for IP: US/European/other countries have no recourse. https://law.stanford.edu/2018/04/10/intellectual-property-china-china-stealing-american-ip/ https://law.stanford.edu/2018/04/10/intellectual-property-ch...
- devoply 8y agoIn theory yes in reality no. In cases of both China and the USA. Please cite any exceptions of where anything as such went to court. The reason being that it's very difficult to prove that your secrets were stolen. Sure you can sue companies for copying your products, and you can also prevent US and Europe from importing goods from China which have been copied even if you can't get a Chinese court to decide wrongdoing in your favor.
- rasengan 8y agoThe article mentions that most are here for legitimate reasons. It seems like the headline could have had a better choice of words to be less of a blanket statement.
- toss1 8y agoWhy should you be uncomfortable? Even by your own definition, it is something that is often done but seldom discussed, and there is a change (Boston tech are targeted), so it is news. And, this IS different than ordinary "spy-vs-spy". That normally applies to keeping track of national adversaries' military strength & asset positioning, political maneuvering, treaty talks, etc. This, in contrast, is straight up industrial espionage for profit and/or military advantage, done by a nation state (vs just a competing company. While it may have occurred some in the past, PRC is taking it to a never-before-seen massive scale. It is part of the pervasive culture of IP theft in Chinese society and govt that runs form the smallest business right to the top of the govt. It is a serious threat to all western democracies, indeed all other nations, and should be taken seriously. What should make you uncomfortable is this fire, not the messenger who reports the fire.
- neilv 8y agoI'm uncomfortable about the fire, too. And I'd like to trust the firefighters to handle the fire, in this case. Not alarm non-firefighters, to go rushing in the way of firefighters, kicking in doors of houses that are not on fire, etc.
- mieseratte 8y ago> kicking in doors of houses that are not on fire, etc. I don't follow your metaphor.
- z2 8y agoTo hazard a guess, it should be up to to security/risk experts and the like to monitor and determine where the threats come from, set policies, and deny access accordingly. It shouldn't be up to citizen watchdogs to yank computers from people because they have a terminal up appear to be hacking things.
- mieseratte 8y ago> It shouldn't be up to citizen watchdogs to yank computers from people because they have a terminal up appear to be hacking things. Which is entirely reasonable, but I don't see anyone advocating this nor does the article so I'm a bit confused. Is someone advocating some kind of Chinese pogrom here?
- sailfast 8y agoI agree that general "All Chinese are spying on you!" is not a helpful message, but nation-state espionage, generally, is not a bad thing to be aware of overall. The article also doesn't seem to fear-monger so much as call out recent espionage attempts while also citing the difficulty of detection because most folks are here for the right reasons. As for "leave it to the professionals", you left out a key component from your list - the people doing the work - doing the research, building the devices. Engineers, professors. The people doing the work are the first line for any social engineering or simple vector attacks. Anyone that works with this information reads and signs things but if they haven't really been tested or understand the consequences, maybe they forget. Having a reminder that it's OK to be impolite when somebody you don't know asks you overly specific questions you're not supposed to share is not always a bad thing.
- neilv 8y agoWhen I said "leave it to the professionals", I meant to cover the workers indirectly when I said "corporate security". Corporate security personnel shouldn't be getting operational info from popular press.
- sailfast 8y agoAgreed, but corporate security is also not out at the bar on a Friday. One would hope that facilities security folks would at a minimum be briefing people, but that stuff costs money, and probably doesn't happen as much as it should.
- C1sc0cat 8y agoWould not anyone working in that sort of area not have been vetted and given guidance on what to look for.
- sailfast 8y agoI've found that people in many areas of work are given guidance and training then either: a) forget over time b) ignore the policy because they think they know better c) ignore the policy because it is inconvenient (this is my favorite!) d) ignore the policy because it is personally advantageous to them (either for reputation, money, etc) Reminders never hurt (assuming they are reminders and not over the top bigoted screeds) So many people think they understand what the impacts are if they bend some of these rules, or ignore them a bit for convenience. I would argue that most of the time, unless the stakes are consistently high, they do not.
- okmokmz 8y ago>diplomats, intel agencies, law enforcement, corporate security Personally, I have absolutely no trust in any of these, and I completely disagree that we should "leave it to the professionals" and let them "handle discretely" whatever is going on. This is how you end up with things like FISA courts, Gitmo, and PRISM.