2 ms·
The problem with fiction is that it suffers from the “author fiat” problem a.k.a. “it works and has no problems because the author says so”. Real life has no s
by teddyh 8y ago
The problem with fiction is that it suffers from the “author fiat” problem a.k.a. “it works and has no problems because the author says so”. Real life has no such cheat, and real history and situations can be more usefully examined for problems. Fiction can be useful for brainstorming ideas, but as realistic target it is dangerous.
Regarding Star Trek and post-scarcity, I can only say that not everybody is convinced by what it canonically presents itself to be:
http://www.stardestroyer.net/Empire/Essays/Trek-Marxism.html http://www.stardestroyer.net/Empire/Essays/Trek-Marxism.html
- krapp 8y agoStar Trek was never intended to portray a realistic, consistent or well thought out post-scarcity society. You could probably describe the entirety of what's portrayed about that society on the back of a napkin. It runs on magic and nonsensoleum (replicators, transporters and free energy, none of which can exist in the real world) and the unjustified assumption that humanity will simply abandon its vices and prejudices if presented with enough magical wish machines and space communism, rather than use those magical wish machines to manufacture weapons and drugs and rob banks and kidnap people with transporters. Star Trek is just entertainment, and any attempt to read more deeply into it or extrapolate it into the real world, other than through whatever vaguely moralistic message the plot, itself, attempts to portray, is bound to be a waste of time.