7 ms·
Codecademy vs. the BBC Micro
- spzb 8y agoThere's a lot of us mid-forties IT staff who owe our careers to the BBC Micro and accompanying TV programmes. It would come as a huge surprise to today's kids but my school had just one computer (a BBC Micro, of course) which was wheeled on a trolley from one classroom to the next. We'd all take turns, usually in groups of three or four, to run whatever educational game was related to the work we were doing (usually maths quizzes)
- rahimnathwani 8y agoWe're about the same age. My primary school also had a BBC Micro on a trolley. We didn't get to use it much, I guess because our teacher wasn't interested in it. When I was ~10, my parents spent £129.99 (a lot of money for them at the time) to buy me an Acorn Electron (a cut down version of the BBC Micro). One thing that was frustrating for me at the time is that I had no one to answer questions. For example, I was writing some 6502 assembly to do something simple (I don't remember what) and the book (either the user guide that came in the box, or the Acorn Electron Advanced User Guide) said I had to provide some value using two's complement. I had no idea what it was or how to find an answer. So I wrote a letter (yes, with a stamp, in the mail) to a Teletext page where these things were discussed, and a few days/weeks later they actually answered my question on one of the pages.
- telesilla 8y agoThe Acorn was my first programming computer at school - I didn't know it was from BBC Micro lineage! We were pretty lucky to have about 20 of them. I did NOT make enough use of this resource as a teenager, to my adult self's chagrin. This was largely because as a teenage girl, the last thing that was gonna happen was spending my lunch hours in the computer room where boys were playing adventure games. Lame. (Future me kicks teenage me).
- Lio 8y agoAcorn was the manufacturer rather than the model. So the Acorn logo was on the back of the BBC computers, the Electron and on later Archimedes lines.
- jacquesm 8y agoThis one started it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acorn_System_1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acorn_System_1 And this was the breakthrough Acorn Atom: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acorn_Atom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acorn_Atom The lessons learned there all went into the BBC Micro.
- Wildgoose 8y agoI still my have my Acorn Atom - a FANTASTIC computer. The manual was exceptionally good as well, with the catchy title "Atomic Theory and Practise". I taught myself to program using that.
- nmstoker 8y agoI suspect that telesilla knew that and merely missed out the word Electron by mistake (given the post it was a response to mentioning the Electron connection).
- Lio 8y agoYep that could easily be possible, I would hope my reply hasn’t come across negatively. Certainly not my intention. I do remember from the time that referring the Electron simply as The Acorn (due the prominent Acorn logo on the top) was very common so my reading it as such in the parent post didn’t seem unusual. I always assumed it was because the BBC Micro had such strong branding that people didn’t realise it was an Acorn product. The logo was there on the back but very small.
- bjelkeman-again 8y agoWriting a paper letter to Teletext and get an answer, love it. The internet and the web has som serious warts, but it is also amazing.
- timthorn 8y agoAnd if you were really into Teletext (and had enough cash) you could get an adaptor to download software OTA: http://www.heyrick.co.uk/software/ttx/ttxouse.html http://www.heyrick.co.uk/software/ttx/ttxouse.html
- rahimnathwani 8y agoThis reminds me that I saw a TV programme once where they played the tape of a program for the BBC Micro over the air, and suggested that a viewer hold up their tape recorder to the TV speaker, to record it, for later loading onto the computer. I never tried it. I'm not sure whether acoustic coupling would have worked well enough to load successfully.
- Someone 8y agoIt could be made to work, even without error correction. See for example https://www.hobbyscoop.nl/the-history-of-basicode/ https://www.hobbyscoop.nl/the-history-of-basicode/, which describes the Dutch way to broadcast (portable!) Basic programs over radio. I think they broadcast every program multiple times, though.
- rikkus 8y agoSame issue for me on the questions. I could see from the Spectrum 48k manual that there was more that could be done than writing plain BASIC but didn’t know how to find out more. I didn’t have any idea what all those POKES I saw in others’ code (typed in from magazines) were doing. Same issue when I got a BBC B. No reference beyond the simple user guide, and I couldn’t find anything out about other books that might be available by asking at the library, because they didn’t understand what I was asking about. Getting onto the Internet in 1994 made a huge difference!
- timthorn 8y agoWas it the L-Shaped Room, perhaps? <Dusts off memory>
- dspillett 8y ago> There's a lot of us mid-forties IT staff who owe our careers to the BBC Micro Only just in 40s here so I was a bit late for the TV programs, but the Acorn computers (Micros and Master Series on trollies in school, and an Electron then later a Master at home) are essentially why I've ended up as a senior-developer-come-DBA. A large part of that is BBC Basic. Compared to anything else available at home at the time it was magical. Instantly accessible (10 PRINT "Expletive" 20 GOTO 10), had proper sub-procedures & functions and long identifier names (so you could create usefully structured code), build-in multi-pass assembler for when you started to need/want lower level access, many of BASIC's parts could be accessed in a documented manner from assembled code too and not just those where it was providing a thin wrapper around other ROM functions, ... That and many type-in examples in magazines of the time to try, learn from and modify: from "frivolous" one-liners (usually producing something pretty on screen), through little "ten liner" games and other demos, to much larger projects. Heck, they fuelled some of my interest in mathematics too as those examples sometimes explored concepts such as fractals, strange attractors, 3D transforms, and so on, while making the pretty display (the explanations were fairly superficial, but usually had the right keywords for me to go lookup more detail in the library when my interest was awoken).
- parenthesis 8y agoYes! The BBC Micro came out just before I started primary school. Initially our school (200-300 pupils) had one, on a trolley, with a concept keyboard too ( http://www.beebmaster.co.uk/8bitadd/Concept.html http://www.beebmaster.co.uk/8bitadd/Concept.html ). By the time I left primary school, we had three or four! In primary one, I remember some very simple `cat and mouse' game. Later on, a text adventure game, possibly something to do with a frog. And then Granny's Garden, and The Flowers of Crystal. At some point, I got permission to basically mess around on one during some lunchtimes. There is so much more I could say!
- CmdrKrool 8y agoLove that people are repeating the detail about the trolley. I too remember that almost as vividly as the computer itself :) Never saw a Concept Keyboard though, it looks both forward thinking and antiquated (reminiscent of the ZX81). But as it happens I read about an Amiga version of this keyboard just the other day. It was expensive: https://archive.org/details/amigaformatmagazine-026/page/n135 https://archive.org/details/amigaformatmagazine-026/page/n13...
- TomAnthony 8y agoYes, Granny's Garden! I remember there was a Part 2 for Granny's Garden, but it wasn't there when you did the default load key combo. You had to *CAT then CHAIN the second file. I recall being 7/8 years old and a student fetching me to go to the other classroom to load it for another class!
- darrenf 8y agoMy high school (years 1987-90) was crazily well equipped – we actually had two rooms full of BBC Micros and gasp an Archimedes. What's more, they were networked so we could chat to each other ... in between political simulation games. Thought it was called "Prime", but perhaps it was Great Britain Ltd: http://bbcmicro.co.uk/index.php?search=Simulation+%28Politics%29&on_G=on http://bbcmicro.co.uk/index.php?search=Simulation+%28Politic... I don't recall actually having classes there so perhaps I only used them at lunch hours. We did also have a BBC Micro-on-a-trolley in my form room though, and I do remember vaguely impressing my classmates by "hacking" some BASIC Lunar Lander game to start with -1 lives, ensuring the "decrement, check against zero" game over condition would never trip. Though in reality that just gave some of the kids licence to never relinquish control, since their game never finished.
- mywacaday 8y agoWe had one in a small Irish school, all I remember are logotron,some word editing and Mr. Ee. We used to leave one of the windows off the latch and go back into the school after hours to play Mr Ee, good times :-)
- rollthehard6 8y agoSlightly older but there were BBCs at my school and a pal had one, but I was never allowed to use them at school as this was a privilege reserved for those that were better at maths than I :) Probably also the reason I ended up studying Chemistry at Uni and getting a hodge podge of credits Science BSc at the end of it. Exposure there to a VAX/VMS cluster ultimately took me on my journey from analyst/programmer to sysadmin/DBA/SAN/backup and now cloud IaC Devops engineer.
- ben7799 8y agoIt wasn't a BBC Micro but this is actually pretty similar to what we had in the US in the 1980s... I'm 41, mid 1980s we had one Apple IIe that got wheeled around on a trolley. There were a handful of us who had parents who worked in the computer/tech/software industry, it was hilarious cause some of us were already ahead of the teachers by 10 or 11. I had taken my first BASIC class in 4th grade at a local college. The teachers were reading from a script teaching us about how to switch between insert and delete mode on the keyboard and giving us assignments that amounted to writing out a sentence and then editing it in a word processor and there were a handful of us kids ready to do BASIC, etc..
- stevekemp 8y agoI wonder how many peoples's eyes would light up if I said "Granny's Garden?" Me? I know we had a BBC at our school, but I did my coding on the computer I had, a rubber-keyed 48k ZX Spectrum. That's what my friends had too. Nobody I knew owned a BBC, so it was wheeled out now and again and somehow a class was supposed to share it in 45-minute windows. Didn't really work. I have fond memories of GG, and some kind of game where you were Prime Minister and you had to raise taxes, and handle unemployment. I guess a text-based sim-city, of a kind!
- timthorn 8y agoThe programmes in question are available online: https://computer-literacy-project.pilots.bbcconnectedstudio.co.uk/ https://computer-literacy-project.pilots.bbcconnectedstudio....
- royjacobs 8y agoI recently went through most of these old shows, it's amazing that the BBC has taken the time to preserve them in this manner.
- pjc50 8y agoThe computer literacy project was basically the last UK government attempt at doing industrial policy. It was a huge success, so they gave up on it and have abandoned industrial policy to market forces and financialisation. We have gone from that to "eff business". https://www.theyworkforyou.com/debates/?id=2019-02-14b.1068.8#g1125.1 https://www.theyworkforyou.com/debates/?id=2019-02-14b.1068....
- camjw1123 8y agoI think this is a bit harsh, the current industrial strategy is pretty decent (https://www.gov.uk/government/topical-events/the-uks-industrial-strategy https://www.gov.uk/government/topical-events/the-uks-industr...), whether they will deliver on this remains to be seen but it's not like they aren't thinking about industrial policy.
- jdietrich 8y agoThe scale of ambition is completely different. The Computer Literacy Project put a computer in every school and led to 141 TV programmes over a decade. At the highest levels of government, it was seen as an urgent priority. We wanted to be a world leader in software and we heavily invested to make that at least plausible on a per-capita basis. Today, there's lots of ambition but very little follow-through. They talk a good game, but it's all piecemeal and penny-ante. It's very difficult to actually find out the specifics of what the government is spending, but it's abundantly clear that we're being left in the dust by China.
- camjw1123 8y agoToday, there's lots of ambition but very little follow-through Yeah, I definitely agree with this. Nothing to add really, hopefully when there is more political bandwidth for this sort of stuff things will change.
- balabaster 8y agoThe UK may have wanted to be a world leader in software and may have heavily invested in education, but then they failed to keep their programmers by creating jobs that paid those developers a competitive enough salary to stay in the UK. A huge portion of us left the country to take our software skills to countries we would be paid competitive salaries and have a high quality of life. Those countries are exploiting the UK's investment by offering a high quality of life and a streamlined path through their immigration policies, pillaging UK developers and negating the billions of dollars the UK spent to get ahead. Having kept a close eye on the development market in the UK for the past 20 years, it's becoming apparent that there will never be an opportunity to bring our skills back home. It's no good investing in education if you don't provide the opportunity for that education to bring long term benefit to the UK. You need to keep the people once you've trained them and they're just not going to stick around while other countries salaries and immigration policies make it easy to take those skills where they're going to be guaranteed easy access to a high quality of life. Those developers are never going to come back if they face the prospect of losing 80% of their salary and their partner not being able to work for for a period during the immigration process. This is a huge gap that the UK seriously needs to look at. There's no point in having an industrial policy that trains people if you're just going to lose a huge portion of them at the end of that training, never to see them again.
- yoted 8y agoInteresting comparison. Learning computing back then did involve getting right down to bits and bytes and assembly language if you wanted to push yourself. It resulted in an underlying understanding of computing which may be missing this days.
- forinti 8y agoBBC Basic was a really good Basic. Its low level routines (for floating point, for example) were available at certain addresses so you could call them from assembly. And since you could mix assembly into Basic also, it gave you a nice path from simple programs to really making the most of the machine. I find it astonishing how well thought out this machine was.
- jlarcombe 8y agoYes it really was well thought out. Another good example is the 'tube' interface for second processors. Enthusiasts have recently put this to use to interface with a Raspberry Pi which can emulate various processors from back in the day at unheard-of speeds, and also provides a modern native ARM coprocessor. The neat thing is that this all works with no changes to the BBC and no special software; you just use the operating system routines as usual on code running on the second processor and it all just works. Not bad for a system designed in 1981. https://github.com/hoglet67/PiTubeDirect/wiki https://github.com/hoglet67/PiTubeDirect/wiki
- russfink 8y agoIn the U.S. as a kid, they aired some of these programs. On one episode, they showed a computer playing tic-tac-toe (naughts and crosses) and claimed that it learned as it went. To this day, I don't know how it did that - maybe building a simple game tree? Still impressive. I always wanted one, but could afford only the TS-1000 (ZX81 but black). I was like 12.
- martincmartin 8y agoI did this as a kid in the 1980s. :) If you exploit the symmetry, so that there are only 3 initial moves (center, corner and edge) its manageable to do by hand. Don't even need a computer. And here's an old Scientific American article about a device that learns a simplified subset of chess called Hexapawn. It's not a computer, but about 25 matchboxes. :) https://www.gwern.net/docs/rl/1991-gardner-ch8amatchboxgamelearningmachine.pdf https://www.gwern.net/docs/rl/1991-gardner-ch8amatchboxgamel...
- mrguyorama 8y agoThat matchbox "computer" in action, courtesy of Standupmaths https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R9c-_neaxeU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R9c-_neaxeU
- protomyth 8y agoIn the history of computers, I don't think Sir Clive Sinclair gets near enough credit for the number of programmers that resulted from his machines that had no chance to afford something more.
- joosters 8y agoIf you haven't already seen it, 'Micro Men' is an excellent TV drama that details the history of the BBC's computer project and the battle to be the chosen computer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXBxV6-zamM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXBxV6-zamM
- Udo 8y agoWhen a friend attempted to teach basic programming to his kids, I realized we're in trouble (for some definition of trouble, see below). First of all, the article is right in opining that the pathways to computer literacy in general, and programming in particular, are not really all that accessible anymore. The problem becomes even worse due to the sheer number of "teaching" tools available. My friend had trouble even finding the right setting. It would have to be a device or an environment that seems relevant and recognizable to the kid, yet at the same time it must be approachable, well documented, didactically meaningful, and entertaining in a way that would motivate someone who could just play any game instead of making one. Second, being a tech-illiterate kid today is not a pain point anymore. Devices, apps, and entertainment media are easy enough for anybody to use. Kids are, somewhat reasonably, asking why they should spend any energy on this, to what end? At first I thought this was a problem. One of my friend's kids quit before the effort started essentially saying "this seems boring, why do I need this?" and the other quit after the first introduction with "nah, I'd rather do something else". I think this is actually fine. It has always been the case that being interested in computers came easier to social outcasts, and kids who had a genuine internal motivation towards technology. The web start up bubble may have skewed this perception for a time, because suddenly there was a lot of money accessible even for people with at best a passing interest in programming. But those days are petering out. Computing never had a broad appeal, except during short fads. I don't think we need more people in computing and programming. If anything, we need less, because the job market for programmers is likely not going to get better. Finally, I question whether there is an upside to teaching computing to kids who don't feel a connection to it. I actually agree with my friend's kids here: for what? Using software is as easy and productive as never before. Yes, being a programmer, I see the glaring issues in today's software, but if we're honest we have gained a lot more than we lost in terms of what the "unskilled" user can do.
- wffurr 8y agoThe short answer to "why do I need this" is that there a lot of good paying jobs in using programs to manipulate data, from software engineering to doing analysis in Excel. Maybe those kids are too young for that to be relevant, but that's also the best time to start learning.
- mcv 8y agoThe computer I grew up with was the BBC's little brother, the Acorn Electron. Lovely little thing. Only 32 kB of RAM, but it had a special port at the back where basically the motherboard itself could be extended, so there were official and unofficial extensions that let you extend this little computer-in-a-keyboard to a massive desk-filling beast with a whopping 224 kB of ROM (though still only 32 kB of RAM). It had no power switch, so you had to use the wall plug to turn it on or off, and with all this stuff added it had become so unstable you often had to try a couple of times before it would boot without hanging. Fun times.
- zerodollar30 8y agoas a 46 year old professional software developer I can honestly say I owe my entire career to the BBC literacy project. Thank you BBC!
- CmdrKrool 8y agoI had a Spectrum at the time but looking back, I'm impressed by the thoroughness of the manual that came with the BBC Micro. From connecting the leads to BASIC to ROM system calls to assembly language, in one book. http://bbc.nvg.org/doc/BBCUserGuide-1.00.pdf http://bbc.nvg.org/doc/BBCUserGuide-1.00.pdf
- jlarcombe 8y agoYes, though actually the ZX Spectrum was also pretty good.. the famous Chapter 24 about the memory map was my first introduction to such matters and left a deep impression at a young age.
- stevekemp 8y agoI still have the orange-covered spiral-bound ZX Spectrum manual, complete with the Z80 opcodes and binary/hex numbers alongside them. Alone it wasn't sufficient to program in assembly, but the BASIC tutorials/documentation were adequate.
- djhworld 8y agoI'm reading "But How Do It Know" right now and programming a software version of the computer the book is describing. It's fun and gets you to learn about NAND gates and other things without intimidating electronic engineering knowledge (I don't have much of a background here) I've implemented a the memory module (256 bytes!) the ALU and am just moving into the CPU section now. The book builds up from creating a "bit" out of a few NAND gates, onto registers, the data bus etc It's actually been a very rewarding little project, yes it's far removed from x86 and modern systems but I think the principles are there to build knowledge on. People might say what's the point, your day job is gluing libraries together to run websites and stuff who cares about hardware, but I think that's a shame because from what I can tell it's not that complicated and makes what is going on under the hood a little easier to reason about, even if you don't understand the complexities of modern processors I'm looking forward to getting my little computer to run toy programs :)
- mxcrossb 8y agoThe article seems very concerned about what is the right level of abstraction to teach. I understand the appeal of starting with Jacob’s loom, especially when you’re going to follow up with something low level like basic. But maybe code academy disagrees. Maybe young people these days don’t need convincing that computers just follow language commands, and with a high level language that’s maybe a safe lie to teach. We might further wonder about what to teach for futures non von Neumann architectures. What is the Jacob’s loom if a multi core machine? The organ of a quantum computer?
- el_cujo 8y agoI guess I've never seen the BBC series, but from the description I don't think it really has the same target audience or goals as Codeacademy. Codeacademy is (mostly) targeted to giving people practical skills to get a job with, while the BBC series sounds like it's more about general education on computers for people who might casually encounter them in real life, not those who are interested in computers as a career. Sort of like in college when everyone might have to take a general biology class, I imagine this would not be structured the same as a biology class targeted to medical school students or those majoring in biology.