> You can't refactor code without tests See this is where the conversation goes south. You will use the phrase "unit tests" when it suits you, and then, like a

> You can't refactor code without tests See this is where the conversation goes south. You will use the phrase "unit tests" when it suits you, and then, like a magician using indirection, generalize to the word "tests" when it suits you. Why are you listening to Uncle Bob so much? I mean you can do as you like. However, the strong "Uncle Bob" style assertions should probably be left out of most articles in favor of a more humble "this is what worked for me/us" approach. Universal rules for any discipline are very hard to come by. Sharing what worked for you on your projects is great but it becomes somewhat obnoxious when you try to generalize it to universal rules that works in all environments for everyone. Also, I think that large unit test suites, where most of the tests are redundant, come about in competitive environments where if you try to make a commit without a test some other competitive coder will try to use it as a "I know better" stepping stone and call you out on the change - "Where is the test". After 3 years of this behavior what do you think your going to have. A nice clean suite of tests or a monstrous big ball of stubs, mocks, faked, copy pasta that resulted from defensive social coding. Honestly, write a light suite of tests that get to the point, and keep your ability to code swiftly and make changes quickly. As the code matures you'll find the trouble spots and focus testing on those areas. Don't blindly follow methodologies that are going to have you writing large test suite for version pre-alpha 0.0, and now your updating a large test suite for every micro-change just to make it to beta 1. Here is an old article by DHH where he rails against unit testing dogma. Ironically it was ideas from the Ruby community that formed a lot of the basis of the mad dog McCarthyan style unit test dogma. https://dhh.dk/2014/tdd-is-dead-long-live-testing.html https://dhh.dk/2014/tdd-is-dead-long-live-testing.html