3 ms·
Meta-commentary: Sixth Tone is a propaganda outlet controlled by the Chinese government. So why are they running with this story? - The central government's AI
by yorwba 8y ago
Meta-commentary: Sixth Tone is a propaganda outlet controlled by the Chinese government. So why are they running with this story?
- The central government's AI strategy is never directly criticized. Instead you get quotes like
She agrees that the intention of “intelligent education” is positive. As the NGAIDP guidelines suggest, the purpose of the initiative is to assist teachers in developing customized teaching methods and study plans for every student.
- On ubiquitous surveillance cameras, the example given is finding criminals in a crowd, not rounding up dissidents.
- The parts that are criticized are more about the implementation than the intention behind it. The potential for misuse isn't even mentioned, the focus is on potential lack of accuracy instead.
- Responsibility is shifted to the schools and companies, despite following the government's plan:
The plan’s “intelligent education” section describes in detail how China’s government hopes to use AI to boost the country’s education system. Zhang reads me one paragraph from the guidelines without stammering. “So detailed. It’s like they wrote it with a [facial recognition] product right in front of them,” he says.
What I think this all means is that Sixth Tone is trying to be a source for high-quality journalism on social issues in China while conveniently avoiding topics the government would like to remain unmentioned.
- barry-cotter 8y ago> Meta-commentary: Sixth Tone is a propaganda outlet controlled by the Chinese government. So why are they running with this story? No they’re not. They’re journalists living and working in China who publish pieces they don’t anticipate will get them shut down. They’re not going to cover the concentration camps in Xinjiang but it’s not an actual propaganda outlet like Xinhua. > What I think this all means is that Sixth Tone is trying to be a source for high-quality journalism on social issues in China while conveniently avoiding topics the government would like to remain unmentioned. It’s like they expect their readers to be intelligent people who can read between the lines.
- Mirioron 8y ago>It’s like they expect their readers to be intelligent people who can read between the lines. To put it bluntly: this is what state censorship does to news. Even if they wanted to do better, they can't, because they'll get shut down or punished.
- yorwba 8y agoSixth Tone isn't directed at the Chinese market though, getting blocked by the government shouldn't be a problem for them, as SCMP proves. The difference is that SCMP is owned by Alibaba, while Sixth Tone is part of the Shanghai United Media Group, who are controlled by the party committee of Shanghai. The journalists might not think of their work as anything bad (宣传 doesn't have a negative connotation in Chinese, after all) and I don't think they'll publish outright lies, but they wouldn't exist if not to influence public opinion by countering the usually negative reporting on China with a more positive spin. That doesn't mean I advise against reading them (I did say that they publish high-quality articles, after all) but you need to be aware that they're not going to tell the whole truth.
- forkLding 8y agoSixth Tone isn't a propaganda outlet though, every media source in China has to get their news approved before they can publish it. The stuff in there is there because it had to be to get published. And I quote: "For instance, in November 2018, Chinese authorities wrongly accused entrepreneur Dong Mingzhu of jaywalking after a streetside camera identified her face in an ad on the side of a bus." - this is clearly not the work of a propagandist.
- yorwba 8y agoSee my reply to the sibling comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19603818 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19603818