4 ms·
He makes a number of excellent points; but I have to laugh wryly at his treatment of my personal pet peeve, interest rates. Boil his 'diagnosis' section down i
by roenxi 8y ago
He makes a number of excellent points; but I have to laugh wryly at his treatment of my personal pet peeve, interest rates.
Boil his 'diagnosis' section down into 3 points - the economic equilibrium is moving away from employing American workers to do work (1 & 2), the central banks are printing money (3) and government is ineffective (4).
Call me a cynic, but (4) on this list is probably a structural problem in that the people who vote governments in are a diverse crowd and lining them up is a bit more challenging than herding cats. Maybe something can be done.
(1 & 2) are issues of genuine concern. I've got nothing to add.
(3) is the laughable one. The problem is that there is money printing afoot and the money is going to wealthy people (see graphs). The billionaire solution is 'shifting money and credit into the hands of those who have a higher propensity to spend'.
What ever happened to the philosophy that we should shift money and credit to the people who have a propensity to build stuff that will be useful in the future? The thing capitalism is actually good at?
We should not want to funnel resources to the rich. We should not want resources to go to high spenders. We should not even want to funnel them to the poor. We want to funnel resources to people who create more resources. That way we will have more resources and can solve our problems using them.
Good old-fashioned flexible human thinking is needed to talk about how the system needs to change but in the same text say that quantitative easing is necessary when its purpose was, essentially, to prevent the system from changing.
- afarrell 8y agoHow do the builders know what is important to build unless those who are suffering can vote for solutions to their ills? Thats my argument for funneling resources to the poor: so that entrepreneurs can earn revenue fixing poor people’s problems. Or (and this is a reason to use markets) so entrepreneurs can earn revenue fixing the problems that entrepreneurs encounter when trying to fix poor people’s problems.
- AdrianB1 8y agoVoting for solutions does not make right solutions, just popular. For example in my country the majority voted for significant public employees salary and state pensions increase - great idea, you can vote yourself rich, it does not mean it can be done and it does not mean it is a good idea.
- afarrell 8y agoI’m using “vote” here in a slightly odd way—as an analogy: Spending money. When you buy bread, you are casting a vote that bread (and implicitly: bread-making equipment) is important in the economy.
- Terretta 8y agoWhat are “poor people’s problems”? Do such problems go away simply by not having poor people? In that case, do you solve the first order problems, or try to solve not having the poor? Would you try to differentiate the under-moneyed from the under-inspired? Are their problems the same? If you want to use “markets”, how do you avoid Idiocracy? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idiocracy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idiocracy
- YawningAngel 8y agoWhat are “poor people’s problems”? Do such problems go away simply by not having poor people? In that case, do you solve the first order problems, or try to solve not having the poor? There is a general correlation between a wide range of malignancies, including lower educational attainment (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0141192950210404 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1080/014119295021...) and lower life expectancy (https://jech.bmj.com/content/59/2/115.short https://jech.bmj.com/content/59/2/115.short). While it's plausible that these problems could be addressed by radically revising the structure of society (for example, if parents could not influence the educational institutions attended by their offspring, educational outcomes might be much more equal), the necessary revisions don't seem plausible in most Western societies as currently constituted. Thus, simply reducing gross inequality seems like a reasonable suggestion. Would you try to differentiate the under-moneyed from the under-inspired? Are their problems the same? No. Who cares, anyway? If you want to use “markets”, how do you avoid Idiocracy? The existence of the film Idiocracy is not an argument for believing that such a society is a plausible or likely outcome of massive redistribution.
- m0zg 8y ago> There is a general correlation between a wide > range of malignancies, including lower > educational attainment and lower life expectancy Or you could draw the arrow of causality slightly differently and say that life kind of sucks for people who didn't listen to the teacher in high school and didn't do their homework. Which, at least in my case, is supported by reams of evidence. It wasn't because they were poor (I grew up in the USSR, so everyone was poor), it was because they didn't give a shit.
- simonh 8y agoPoliticians picking winners is the last thing we need, and any system in which the government chooses how to funnel resources to entrepreneurs will risk doing that. For pork barrel reasons if nothing else.
- TomMckenny 8y agoAgreed, incentivizing productive sectors at the expense of non productive (including rent seeking) is the ideal. But it can be tricky to objectively and systematically spot the productive sectors. But note: if the poor had more spending power there would be more incentive to satisfy their needs without guessing. This would not only lift their productivity[1] but directly reduce misery and political instability. Further more it directly, bluntly and unambiguously addresses the inequality problem. We would, in essence, allow them to choose the industries that need backing and so avoid too many direct government decisions. And, necessarily, those are the industries that will relive the problem most quickly. [1]With the additional choices that additional prosperity brings, individuals tend to choose higher productivity activities.
- Nasrudith 8y agoThe issue here is with the definition of "value" and "resources" and how they are defined along with "produce". I am not convinced the idea is useful in our circumstances. It brings to mind the original great depression era Technocracy movement who set up essentially an ineffectual fascist cult and had unviable ideas thankfully never put into practice for a reason. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technocracy_movement https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technocracy_movement Since that logic could just as easily be used to justify all sorts of bad ideas like giving more money to rent seekers and extractives while completely ignoring those who actually could use the resources for gain. Furthermore the assumption that more resources will neccessarily solve the pronlem doesn't follow. There are many issues from distribution of resources and problems caused by production. We don't solve our problems via producing 15,000 tons of wheat per person per day while everyone is suffering from health issues. Even if the definition is smart enough to recognize secondary and tertiary steps there is the issue of attempted valuation of education and design work. Done wrong it could pay for copyright and patent trolls.
- Gibbon1 8y ago> What ever happened to the philosophy that we should shift money and credit to the people who have a propensity to build stuff that will be useful in the future? The thing capitalism is actually good at? But good lord man that's Hersey! About five years ago my opinion about California High Speed Rail is the state of California should have just up and borrowed $60 Billion at zero percent to pay for it.