4 ms·
A lot of the "reputable ones" were funded by the industry. The truth is this is very hard to measure. You have something that happens over a period of years an
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
A lot of the "reputable ones" were funded by the industry.
The truth is this is very hard to measure. You have something that happens over a period of years and is difficult to control for. How do you find a group of people in modern times who haven't used cell phones in the last decade, but at the same time are not a group of monks or Amish people with so many other lifestyle differences that everything is hopelessly confounded?
Being hard to measure isn't the same as not existing. The question is, what choice do you make when it's hard to get good information? Build a lot more radio transmitters that may or may not be a major contributor to the modern trend of increasing cancer rates, or prefer wired networks that don't?
- zzzcpan 8y agoWe don't need to study how specific complex tech affects humans if we know how radiation does in general, what energies are needed to penetrate the skin, etc. There is pretty much no reason to study 5g tech specifically.
- godelski 8y ago> A lot of the "reputable ones" were funded by the industry. This just tells me you're looking for conspiracy and distrust. To comment implying that there's no way to measure, you definitely can. You look at cancer rates over time (we have that data). You also look to see if there are correlations with growth in areas where cell phone usage increased faster than in areas that were slow to adopt (this even happens in America, and we have this data). For example, New York more quickly adopted cell phones (and other radio technology) than Montana. Just because you can't figure out how to measure something doesn't mean it isn't an already well established practice that has been verified through many different studies. Many different disciplines use this method as well. The nice thing about this method is that it is also easy to test to see if researchers are p-hacking or doing other types of data manipulation that one would expect if there was a conspiracy going on.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> This just tells me you're looking for conspiracy and distrust. Industry funded research, for all industries, is inherently unreliable because they get to choose whether to publish it after they've seen the results. This is not a conspiracy, it's just what actually happens. They're generally not going to publish a finding that hurts their business or exposes them to litigation. And then you're here: https://xkcd.com/882/ https://xkcd.com/882/ > You look at cancer rates over time (we have that data). You also look to see if there are correlations with growth in areas where cell phone usage increased faster than in areas that were slow to adopt (this even happens in America, and we have this data). For example, New York more quickly adopted cell phones (and other radio technology) than Montana. At which point you're back to different lifestyles and many confounders. Worse, availability of mobile phones affects human behavior directly, so you have to somehow account for the consequences of those behavioral changes that directly correlate with mobile usage. Also this: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0152719 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal... Doing this properly is hard. So hard that people generally screw it up at least a little bit. Then we get studies showing both positive and negative results, but they're all flawed in at least minor ways so everybody gets to point to the flaws in the studies whose result they didn't like. See also: Replication crisis. In practice the result is that we don't actually know the answer, so the question is what we should do when we're not sure.
- godelski 8y agoAhhhh, the replication crisis. You know that isn't true in every field, right? Plus, the exact thing we're talking about HAS been replicated. Many times. Talk to a scientist about the replication scientist. Talk to ones in different fields. You'll see different responses. Correlation between the softer and harder. I'll admit particle physics has replication problems, but that's for different reasons (machines) than psychology (lots of reasons). Some fields require what would be equivalent to p values of far far less than 0.05. When we get multiple experiments agreeing when chance of coincidence is one in ten million, we tend to think that's good. Also you're confounding the experiment. You can't do this just over New York and Montana. You do it over a lot of places. Over many countries. Plus we have other ways to test this. You can look to see if radio waves heat tissue. The fact is cell phone radiation (radio waves) are non-ionizing and unless you turn the power WAY WAY up, it isn't dangerous. Both these methods are well established and we know what we're doing. So after just these two (there's been others) we have two experiments that match our current theory. I want to repeat that. Experiments are fitting our theory. Not hypothesis. Theory. We've been studying electromagnetism for a long time. We've been studying radio for a long time. The data is matching well established theories. This is completely different than your jellybean case because that doesn't match any good hypothesis. There's no underlining reasoning for why only a green jellybean causes acne. That doesn't deny the jellybean correlation, but that's all it is at that point. Correlation. Which is different than causation. To graduate to causation (which is actually the thing being pointed out in that xkcd) you need to give reasoning. There are plenty of things that correlate that don't cause. [0] That's where theory comes in. But if you can't establish a good link, then you just have [0] and people laughing at you. Tldr: go talk to scientists. tldrr: you aren't smarter than domain experts (in their domain) tldrrr: don't shout replication crisis when the issue we're talking about has been replicated with similar results with multile well established methods. [0] https://tylervigen.com/spurious-correlations https://tylervigen.com/spurious-correlations