6 ms·
But these leaks might make him look bad, and that hurts the next re-election. Welcome to Amerika, where anyone who speaks out against you is branded a terroris
by jrockway 16y ago
But these leaks might make him look bad, and that hurts the next re-election.
Welcome to Amerika, where anyone who speaks out against you is branded a terrorist. (I have downmodded this exact comment a number of times, because I never thought it was really true. But this time, that's exactly what's happening! There is a well-established legal precedent in the US that you can publish anything that has been leaked, regardless of how you got that information. The person who leaked it gets in trouble, not the person who tells everyone about it. But now... we want to throw away our freedoms and call wikileaks a "terrorist organization". What the fuck? Terrorists fly airplanes full of people into buildings full of people. This is a collection of documents that say China hacked Google. NOT THE SAME AT ALL!)
</rant>
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoI'll give you nice counter-rant. Downvote if you like, but somebody needs to put what you said in context, so I'll play American Joe Sixpack for that purpose. What did you expect? Did you honestly think you could dump years of State Department cables on the internet and what? Somebody would come give wikileaks an award? They'd win the Nobel Peace Prize? (yikes, that still might happen) This is not wikileaks reporting that the war is going badly, ie making a point that we are being lied to by showing the lies. This isn't honorable. If you'll remember, when the Pentagon Papers happened the leaker was fully willing to take whatever punishment came to him. As he should have. This isn't that, either. This is some asshole with a computer connection hooking up with somebody else with a grievance and destroying billions of dollars of my collective property. His stated mission is to destroy the structure of my country by making it impossible for various nodes of the country to communicate with each other. No amount of ranting is going to make an anarchist into a superhero. We need leaks for society to function, not crazy self-centered promoters bent on single-handedly redesigning our way of life. </rant> (wink) On a more serious note, I told you guys when this happened that there aren't actions without reactions. If Assange is just getting started? Well the other side is just getting started too. Expect more of this.
- pavs 16y agoWikileaks is putting the governments of the world naked under the scanner the same way most of us are being put under the scanner every time you take a flight. If we can't have any privacy, the government can't either.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoYou guys keep hitting me over the head with what's fair or what's right or going on and on about some moral outrage and how wikileaks is needed. I keep telling you that none of that matters. Consent of the governed isn't about the best way of governing people, it's about the general agreement that things are working this way. Wikileaks has done nothing to change any of that. So it's just an attack on the government itself. Expect the government to react. That's all I saying. For every person you might convince that change is needed, you just created a hundred people wanting to throw the entire wikileaks bunch in jail. Honestly, I agree with you that individual freedoms are at an all-time low -- in all kinds of ways. It's a travesty and a horrible thing. I'm just telling you that the emotional argument about how screwed up things are isn't going to hold much say when pitted against the way groups of people work. To them, this is an attack and a crime. Hell, it's an attack and crime to me too, and I agree with it. (The two beliefs are not mutually exclusive) Yelling about being surprised at the response here doesn't make much sense to me. You can easily see where this all is headed, and it's not a new golden age of human freedom, as much as one is needed.
- rbarooah 16y agoSince you agree with the general sentiment (about individual freedoms), but think that expressing outrage here is futile, can you suggest a response that is constructive instead?
- mattmanser 16y agoGo into politics yourself. There's no better response, it's stand up or shut up with this kind of issue. Far too complex for most people to understand, ramifications of great consequence that are hard to vocalise. Just don't forget what you were getting into power for when you get there.