3 ms·
Putting on the Wild Ass Guess hat. I remember reading that the MCAS system uses the exact same physical contacts as the pilot's electrical trim adjustment swit
by salawat 8y ago
Putting on the Wild Ass Guess hat.
I remember reading that the MCAS system uses the exact same physical contacts as the pilot's electrical trim adjustment switches.
I'm wondering if they're trying to change their software implementation to more cleanly separate the two abstractions in the code in order to avoid having to do a hardware or firmware change on the jackscrew motor controllers.
If before, the signalling was such that the signalling was handled as a sort of one off block jammed into some function somewhere, they may now have to be doing much more thorough refactoring to separate out those interfaces, and improve the traceability, testability, and readability, all with the overhead of a system likely reclassified to "catastrophic" system hazard rating.
Either way, after some number crunching of my own, I can only see going forward with MCAS reasonable if there is some way to discretely disable its' ability to signal the jackscrew motor while leaving the electronic trim available in case of erroneous MCAS activation in the future, because with the requisite torque involved to quickly actuate that control surface against potential overspeed loads exacerbated by elevator up pitch commands, you'd need the electric motors, period.
Without taking into account friction, and using the stabilizer dimensions of the 737-800, in air conditions approximate to Addis Ababa, at 350 knots, discluding extra load from elevator up, and assuming an M24 jackscrew thread, it would have taken 357 ft-lbs torque to actuate against that wind load.
That's the output of a non-trivial automotive engine to bring that down to something the non-mathematically inclined can recognize, and while theoretically may be possible to gear for from a hand crank, I'm not confident I'm going to be able to figure out a gear train that can gear reduce enough to allow anywhere near enough speed when rotated by one pilot to get that horizontal stabilizer where it needs to be in so short a length of time.
Either way, I foresee a lot of chaos, and scrutiny moving forward in the handling of this, and can only hope we can finally come to terms as a nation with why certain regulatory agencies are worth the cost of investing in if only to keep the seeds of such tragedies as happened here from ever being able to germinate again.
- tropo 8y agoSo, to get the aircraft back flying again, we just need to mandate some physical strength standards for air crews.