3 ms·
This kind of "I never said that" semantic quibble raises one essential question: Have you stopped beating your elderly mother yet? Things have implications bey
by chc 16y ago
This kind of "I never said that" semantic quibble raises one essential question: Have you stopped beating your elderly mother yet?
Things have implications beyond their explicit claims.
- mcn 16y agoThe two quibbles above seem nearly identical to me. It's interesting what role the assumptions of the audience play in their reaction to a statement. I assumed that a snopes link would credit or discredit the claim (that this was a test from 1895.)
- jsolson 16y agoI've always preferred "Do you still beat your wife?" Rolls off the tongue better.
- cwp 16y agoPointing out a classic fallacy is hardly a quibble, and certainly not a question of semantics. On the other hand, yes, it's quite true that all arguments appear in a specific context. I think we must live in quite different political contexts, though, because I don't see anything in the article that implies a decline in educational standards.