10 ms·
How to Improve MacBook Pro Performance and Thermals
- userbinator 8y agoI see Apple hasn't changed at all --- these memorable pages from the official service manual of many years ago shows what they considered the "correct" amount of paste: http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200605/mobile01-514da8fc7fc5ce50359d0bd754a7c73c.jpg http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200605/mobile01-514da8fc7f... http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200605/mobile01-e89d3804df75a137bd9adbe040817a57.jpg http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200605/mobile01-e89d3804df... https://www.techpowerup.com/img/06-05-01/lol1qe.jpg https://www.techpowerup.com/img/06-05-01/lol1qe.jpg
- arthurcolle 8y agoSeems like way too much for such a small surface area.
- userbinator 8y agoYes, it's definitely excessive. There should be just enough to form a thin film after installation. Here's a picture from Intel's site showing the correct amount: https://www.intel.com/content/dam/support/us/en/images/processors/sb/img/cs030329_2.jpg https://www.intel.com/content/dam/support/us/en/images/proce... That's for a processor with a large heatspreader on top, so a small bare-die one like those in a laptop should have proportionally less.
- mbell 8y agoThis is mostly urban legend. You have to really get ridiculous to apply too much thermal paste but you can use too little, so no reason to err in that direction in mass manufacturing. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EUWVVTY63hc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EUWVVTY63hc
- masklinn 8y ago> you can use too little, so no reason to err in that direction in mass manufacturing Exactly. The thermal conductivity of air is 0.026 (W/m/K), your average thermal paste (non-metal) is at 2. For manufacturers it's way better to guarantee uniformly meh conductivity by using too much thermal paste than risking air bubbles by using too little. Most manufacturers will lean this way when they don't just use those POS thermal stickers. Same with average versus silver: silver provides a gain but a limited one, and it's conductive so you have to make very sure not to leak any onto circuits or you risk a short. That's why manufacturers don't bother.
- greyskull 8y agoIs there a meaningful impact of the thickness of excessive TIM? I suspect the answer is no given the clamping power of the mount will get the paste down to roughly a consistent thinness even with over-application. What about any excess TIM off the edges drawing heat away from the heat pipes/cold plate?
- philjohn 8y agoRemember that the amount needed differs if you have an IHS (every modern desktop processor) or straight die like in a laptop.
- sharkjacobs 8y agoIs this a joke? those photos are insane.
- LeftTurnSignal 8y agoI wish. I used to work at an Apple repair shop years ago. We never could figure out why they had so much in their manuals.
- szc 8y agoAre you sure those are Apple circuit boards? When and what boards used blue solder mask?
- kalleboo 8y agoYou can see it says "MacBook" in the background. Google white plastic MacBook teardown and you get https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/MacBook+Core+Duo+Logic+Board+Replacement/296 https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/MacBook+Core+Duo+Logic+Board+Re... which shows blue solder mask
- wtallis 8y agoI have some circa 2007-2008 MBP boards lying around that are blue. Based on a quick check of iFixit repair guides, it looks like they stopped using blue when they adopted the unibody chassis.
- userbinator 8y agoThe last picture comes from the MacBook Pro 2006 service manual. I believe the first two come from the MacBook (not pro) early 2006 service manual, since the colour of the paste is white instead of the grey of later manuals which show (only slightly) smaller amounts.
- szc 8y agoI should have looked more closely at the pictures, thanks for the comments.
- ThePowerOfFuet 8y agoThey are absolutely legit.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tedunangst 8y agoWhy would changing thermal paste reduce idle power draw by 1.6 watts (more than 50%)?
- rzzzt 8y agoJust guessing, but the fans might not start running that early with better heat dissipation.
- xxs 8y agoKeeping the silicon cool reduces power consumption by about 3.5-4% per 10K. But that should not be case for idle, so lower fan speeds (or no fan) seems logical
- bluegreyred 8y agoThis is correct. Lower power consumption as a result of better TIM and thus lower core temperatures: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poole–Frenkel_effect http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poole–Frenkel_effect https://forums.anandtech.com/threads/effect-of-temperature-on-power-consumption-with-the-i7-2600k.2200205/ https://forums.anandtech.com/threads/effect-of-temperature-o... The effect is so pronounced that a watercooled computer running under full load will typically use less power than an identical aircooled computer, because the lowered silicon current leakage more than makes up for the power consumption of the pump and additional fans.
- killjoywashere 8y agoMaybe he's not the thermal paste genius he thinks he is and his paste job actually caused more heat, which decreased impedance?
- pvg 8y agoI'm not sure these numbers are quite right, it looks like the author is just taking the instant values Power Gadget shows even when the clock and utilization are quite different at that particular moment - measured utilization is about a factor of two different. It would have been saner to dump the Power Gadget log and munge it a bit over some time window for more meaningful comparative data.
- eaenki 8y agoCan I bring my MBP which is under warranty to the Apple Store along with the paste and ask them to do it? I tried bringing my MBP here in EU to an Apple Store for thermal issues and they told me everything it’s fine while it obviously isn’t and they weren’t wiling to do anything but to keep it for “weeks” to see if there’s any issue through a more in depth review.
- lloydde 8y agoVery unlikely. If you can convince them of a repair, they’ll want to use their own supplies. This reminds of Canadian CBC National investigation into how instead of identifying problems, Apple was caught misdiagnosing and pushing purchasing new products. https://youtu.be/_XneTBhRPYk https://youtu.be/_XneTBhRPYk I don’t know if you’d have to pay, I suspect you would, but an independent repair shop is likely going to care more about you and your nuanced issue.
- megy 8y agoSure, you can do that. They will not do it, but you can certainly try.
- ttsda 8y agoThey will refuse to do it with 100% certainty. Apple is absolutely obsessed with control, and they go to pretty extreme lengths to prevent people (especially shops) from repairing their devices.
- amanzi 8y agoI would have liked to see more photos of the paste being applied. And is that the CPU and GPU sharing the same heatsink? Or is there another one that needed to be taken apart?
- saagarjha 8y ago13” MacBook Pros have integrated Intel Iris graphics.
- nathancahill 8y agoAwesome. Going to try this. Ardent believer in the 2015 MBP.
- spectramax 8y agoI swapped PTIM (stock thermal paste) with Gallium alloy (Grizzly Conductonaut or Coolaboratories Liquid Metal). The results were absolutely incredible, better than what this article exemplifies. If you're going to open up the chassis, might as well go to the full extent and replace thermal paste with liquid gallium.
- DonHopkins 8y agoHow much do you use and how do you apply it? Is there no chance of it oozing out and causing havoc with the circuitry?
- simongr3dal 8y agoA lot of the premium thermal paste products are non-conductive (electrically) and still way better than the stuff they put on at the factory and will improve you situation. I don’t think that thermal grizzly products are a bad place to start looking. I haven’t tried them myself, but GamersNexus are advertising/recommending them and I do trust them.
- darkpuma 8y agoIs there no chance of that gallium alloy amalgamating with other metals it might encounter? It seems really sketchy, but I guess it's probably not since I've not heard horror stories.
- xxs 8y agoGallium eats aluminum like butter[0]:. Copper is safe, nickel plated copper is ok as well (might tarnish though)... solder joins are dead however. One should be very careful if that stuff can leak. [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k919f7Qi4es&vl=en https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k919f7Qi4es&vl=en <--random video
- xxs 8y ago> I haven’t tried them myself, you should. kryonaut and conductonaut are both great. However I'd not recommend liquid metal (gallium) for daily use in a laptop with low tension force. I use liquid metal on delidded ones and kryounat elsewhere.
- saagarjha 8y ago> only hard drives and memory can be replaced / upgraded on Macbook Pros by the owner without affecting the warranty Not on this MacBook Pro.
- mushufasa 8y agoeh. instead of buying $400 screwdrivers and opening up the chassis to mess with the thermal paste, i've fixed my 2015 mbp thermal issues by getting a $15 usb laptop cooling pad on amazon. works like a charm, even with multiple editing sessions on many monitors. edit: i misread the price of the screwdrivers. I still recommend a cooling pad. High power draw is usually when I'm using extra monitors at a desk anyways.
- Shoop 8y ago$400 screwdrivers? The screwdrivers pictured were 349 rupees ~ $5.
- _bxg1 8y agoI had to do a double-take when the he said the paste cost "740". I don't know much about thermal paste so I could've believed it was dollars if it was really something special. But then I noticed the "Rs." beneath the image.
- minusf 8y agoso now you use even more energy to cool down warmth from using too much energy?
- thatssosid 8y agoThe Currency mentioned is in Indian Rupees.
- isugimpy 8y agoPost author called out the warranty multiple times. If you're in the USA, at least, bear in mind that doing what's described in the post does not void the warranty. The Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act explicitly requires the manufacturer to prove that your action caused the negative impact the warranty claim is made against, otherwise they legally can't void your warranty.
- darkpuma 8y agoIf Apple decides to flagrantly break that law, what options does an individual consumer have? Is there a government agency that will fight on behalf of that consumer, or does the consumer have to hire their own lawyer?
- crooked-v 8y agoSmall claims court can cover up to at least $5,000 or $10,000 in most states, and is generally friendly to the layman or may even ban the use of trained lawyers in some locations.
- chrisseaton 8y ago> may even ban the use of trained lawyers in some locations So who do companies send to defend themselves?
- k_sze 8y agoMaybe legal executives who have studied enough law but not entered the Bar (on purpose?).
- jdietrich 8y agoThey often don't bother - the cost of sending a representative is frequently greater than the cost of paying the judgement.
- torstenvl 8y agoA representative, usually a regional customer service executive or analogous. They'll often try to deal out first (it may be small claims court's policy to try mediation first).
- maximilianroos 8y agoAny ideas why Apple doesn't do this themselves? I understand that it doesn't make the system look better to a low-information buyer. So Lenovo aren't doing it. But Apply seem motivated to add small costs in exchange for moderate (if invisible) benefits.
- m45t3r 8y agoApplying thermal paste "the correct way" needs some person to do very delicated labor. And also is impossible to do a proper QA. Now imagine doing this in a factory pipeline. I don't think this would scale.
- jaak 8y agoI would disagree - to give an electronics example, this level of work is done all the time at large scale on PCB manufacturers with solder mask, solder paste, silk screens, etc. Print shops can do this kind of work, too (precise amounts, sub-millimeter accuracy, irregular surfaces, almost any kind of coating, etc.).
- jandrese 8y agoThey could, but when you open up a laptop where the manufacturer used thermal paste and you'll more often than not find it apparently applied with a turkey baster in a tenth of a second. Just a big old splat.
- jdietrich 8y agoThe problem is rarely poor application of paste, but degradation of the paste's performance over time. The paste can chemically degrade, or it can be pumped out of the interface by the movement caused by repeated thermal cycles. Many manufacturers use a solid thermal interface material rather than a paste, which has poorer initial performance but more consistent performance over time. https://www.electronics-cooling.com/2007/11/reliability-testing-of-thermal-greases/ https://www.electronics-cooling.com/2007/11/reliability-test...
- ComputerGuru 8y agoIt's the first thing I do with any new laptop, be it Apple, HP, Dell, or Lenovo. It really makes a massive difference. In my experience HP pushes the thermal boundary more than most (they generally offer higher TDP options for custom builds than their competitors without tailoring for it). Some people take this to the next level and decap the processors and then use liquid thermal compound instead of the paste. That probably voids your warranty.
- sebazzz 8y agoI don't know about those other machines from HP, but the Spectre with i7 standard high-end issue in my office (Big4) is only trouble. Those are nice if you develop a spreadsheet with some VBA now and then, but once you actually need the power if you're developing enterprise applications you can forget it. Under any serious load they overheat and clock the processor down from 3Ghz+ to 2Ghz.
- masklinn 8y ago> Some people take this to the next level and decap the processors and then use liquid thermal compound instead of the paste. They're probably deliding the CPU (removing the integrated heat spreader (IHS) to put the compound on the die directly), not decapping it. I can't imagine a CPU surviving the latter. The CPU in the article is lid-less so that's not a concern. And some CPUs have a soldered heatspreader, this allows for much better heat transfer to the IHS but means delidding is destructive (though way less necessary to be fair). Ryzen chips are soldered.
- ComputerGuru 8y agoSorry, I did indeed mean delid. As far as I know, the practice only became common once manufacturers stopped soldering the heatspreaders.
- peter_l_downs 8y agoIn case the author shows up here -- I clicked through to the next post (https://bsid.io/posts/2019/03/my-experiment-with-honesty/ https://bsid.io/posts/2019/03/my-experiment-with-honesty/) which describes what I think is the author getting ripped off and having their work stolen by another individual. If you're reading this, author: you should publicly shame that individual, or outright sue them if you have the resources. In particular you should contact their employer or advisers and let them know that the paper they published is your work, not theirs.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sircastor 8y agoI have a mid 2014 MBP, and I wonder if my machine could benefit from this kind of effort...
- pvg 8y agoJust popping it open and cleaning out the dust and gunk will give you most of the benefit without having to fiddle with goo and funny screwdrivers.
- PascLeRasc 8y agoAbsolutely. I have a '14 MBP too and repasting gave me an extra hour of battery life.
- minusf 8y agoundervolting the CPU (with Intel extreme tuning) can also help without opening up the notebook. unfortunately that's Windows only. not sure what is for macos...
- bluegreyred 8y agoOlder Haswell rMBPs can be undervolted with but it requires disabling SIP which is not recommended. Read the warnings and disclaimers and inspect the source code: https://github.com/sicreative/VoltageShift https://github.com/sicreative/VoltageShift newer MBPs (2016+) appear to be locked down.
- threeseed 8y agoWhatever you do please do not do this on a 2016+ MacBook Pro. It is significantly more complex than on previous generations. There are a lot of very tiny, very fragile cables which are very easy to break. It gets a 1/10 rating for repairability for a reason.
- thijsvandien 8y agoIn fact, it’s already fragile without opening it at all...
- LeonM 8y agoPro tip: If your MBP is overheating (constant high fan speeds) the problem is usually a lot simpler than the thermal paste issue described in the article. It's usually just dust buildup. I have fixed multiple overheating Macbook pro's by simply cleaning out the dust buildup underneath the rubber pad, between the fan housing and the heatsink. The airflow compresses the dust into an almost solid piece (like felt), which blocks the airflow. You can usually pull it out as one piece. All you need is a pentalobe screwdriver, a pair of tweezers and maybe some compressed air. Especially if your laptop often gets into contact with fabrics (on your lap or in bed), you should do this cleaning once a year.
- bla3 8y agoHow do you open it?
- LeonM 8y agoYou can Google that and find many guides on that topic. iFixit has really good guides. TLDR: Remove the screws on the bottom. You need a special screwdriver and keep in mind that (at least on the <=2015 models afaik) there are different size screws used around the hinge.
- Something1234 8y agoYou probably won't find that screwdriver at local hardware store though. I had endless issues finding even semi-common torx bits at Lowe's.
- kristofferR 8y agoWhat's with this weird font that puts the Norwegian letter Ø instead of 0s?
- avivo 8y agoIs it possible to have someone experienced do this for you or your company in San Francisco? Either cleaning out the dust, and/or applying new paste? (how much would it likely cost if so?) (also, does it apply to a MacBook Air?)
- rolleiflex 8y agoYes it does — and it’s simple enough that most people can do it, provided that you agree to not hold them responsible if things break. Just go to any tech repair shop and bring them your own thermal paste, which is like $5. Or better, find a friend to do it for you for a beer. This is just basic maintenance, so very low skill kind of thing.
- avivo 8y agoThe reason I ask is because I specifically am interested in those who have the professional confidence to be held responsible if something goes wrong (even in complex situations; e.g. a warped chassis).
- rolleiflex 8y agoI don’t think anybody would ever sign that contract, however if you’d still like to try, your best bet is Apple authorised repair shops.
- 9935c101ab17a66 8y agoWithout seeing results AFTER the dust was removed and BEFORE the new thermal paste was applied, it is impossible to attribute the resulting improvement to the thermal paste itself. That computer is super dusty, and I suspect the significant amount of dust removed from the fan and inbetween the fins of the heat sink would explain a large portion of the difference. If the author has results from after the cleaning, they would help paint a clearer picture.
- thatssosid 8y agoI guess the dust wasn't that significant to affect the results. This can be seen in the post-Thumbnail. The image was taken immediately after opening the backplate.
- thatssosid 8y agoAuthor here. Happy to answer any questions.
- aiyodev 8y agoDon’t do this. I have the same model. Had overheating problems. Took it to the Apple store. They fixed it and refurbished it for me. Even replaced the bottom case because of a couple of dents. It’s like a brand new machine. Charged me $0. This is why I love Apple and will never switch.
- Matthias247 8y agoWith or without having apple care and still being under warranty?
- ttsda 8y agoYou love apple because they don't repair their products, they just trick you into paying for insurance that lets them swap huge chunks of your device instead of finding and fixing what's wrong.
- aiyodev 8y agoYou're wrong. I never paid for Applecare.
- brianpgordon 8y agoOne little nitpick- > This only works efficiently, though, if a very thin layer of thermal paste is applied between CPU and heatsink in such a way that minimises the chance of creating “air bubbles” (air has a bad thermal conductivity). The issue here isn't really air bubbles. It's true that air has very poor thermal conductivity, but the real issue is that the thermal paste itself has very poor thermal conductivity compared to the solid copper heatsink. The paste is really just supposed to fill in any microscopic pits in the surface to get the copper in good contact. People go to great lengths to make the surfaces as smooth as possible, going as far as to hand lap their heatsinks to a mirror polished finish.
- steve19 8y agoSeems I have been doing it wrong So I really want just a tiny amount of thermal paste?
- brianpgordon 8y agoYes, you always want the minimum amount which will ensure good contact across the whole surface. You should be pressing (hard) to mate the surfaces and squeeze out excess thermal transfer medium anyway. Desktop/server CPU sockets typically have a mechanical lever action to do that for you and secure the package in place.
- jdietrich 8y agoThe maximum thickness of the paste layer is determined wholly by the clamping pressure and coplanarity of the thermal interface. You can only end up with an excess of paste between the CPU and heatsink if a) the heatsink contact plate or CPU package aren't flat or b) the clamping mechanism isn't properly pressing them together. Apply too much thermal paste and it'll just squeeze out of the edges, which is merely inconvenient as long as the paste is reasonably non-conductive. Apply too little paste and you'll get air gaps, which have terrible thermal conductivity. If in doubt, just spread the paste to ensure that it fully covers the contact area. https://www.gamersnexus.net/guides/3346-thermal-paste-application-benchmark-too-much-thermal-paste https://www.gamersnexus.net/guides/3346-thermal-paste-applic... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r2MEAnZ3swQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r2MEAnZ3swQ
- christkv 8y agoHas anyone tried thermal pads instead? What was the result compared to paste ?
- JustFinishedBSG 8y agoNormal Thermal pads are TERRRIBLE and will cause the computer to overheat. Except those new fancy graphite thermal pads ( thermal grizzly sells some ). Those are generally worse than good paste but are pretty good and they have the added pro of being reusable and keeping their thermal property forever unlike paste. In a laptop that is subject to tension stress they may provide better cooling over time.
- wheels 8y agoI did the same with my 2011 Macbook Pro in 2017, also to similar effect. As another poster points out, the more frequent maintenance task that makes a big difference is removing the fan and pulling the dust out. https://scotchi.net/2017/03/04/considering-reapplying-the-thermal-paste-on-a-2011-macbook-pro/ https://scotchi.net/2017/03/04/considering-reapplying-the-th... With that, my 2011 2.7 GHz i7 Macbook Pro continues to be completely usable even for C++ development (also has a 1 TB SSD and 8 GB of RAM), and hopefully will get me through to a point that Apple releases a laptop that I actually want to buy. If they haven't released a Macbook with a better keyboard by the time this thing dies, it'll be my last Apple laptop.
- ksec 8y agoQuestions. What other possible ways to clean up the dust without opening my machine? Would Apple reapply the paste and clean up the dust if I had other form of repair, assuming I am still under AppleCare+?
- thatssosid 8y agoAuthor here. A small update regarding warranty Opening the base plate doesn't void warranty [1] [1]https://www.reddit.com/r/apple/comments/3zix1f/does_this_void_a_macbook_pros_warranty/ https://www.reddit.com/r/apple/comments/3zix1f/does_this_voi...
- torgian 8y agoMake it thicker? XD
- James_Owens_69 8y agoNot buying from Apple?