7 ms·
In my opinion you don't even need to be an expert. - if you're a generally competent, learned person - and the new product feels like a giant leap from anythi
by Waterluvian 8y ago
In my opinion you don't even need to be an expert.
- if you're a generally competent, learned person
- and the new product feels like a giant leap from anything that exists already
- it's likely not all it claims to be.
- scrooched_moose 8y agoI've always had a 20% threshold If anyone is promising a 20% or greater improvement over the current leaders, I immediately file it away as a scam until I see extraordinary proof. Other than some very immature industries, even 20% leaps don't happen without earth shattering once-in-a-generation breakthroughs. Some call me a pessimist, and occasionally I'm unfairly dismissive of new technologies. But for every one I get wrong, I get 99 others correct.
- randomsearch 8y agoWhen Google first arrived, I’d say the improvement was way more than 20%. Did you experience that?
- Rexxar 8y agoSearch was not a mature industry at all.
- randomsearch 8y agoCompared to AI? I wouldn’t say search was more immature than Cloud APIs for AI, if that comparison even makes sense.
- ethbro 8y agoI'd definitely include that as a qualifier to the rule. Mature and/or competitive. 20%+ without a breakthrough can absolutely happen in niche industries that have historically lacked competition.
- smnrchrds 8y agoHow do you define immature? AI seems to be quite immature even compared to other subjects in computer science, which is as a whole quite young.
- scottlegrand2 8y agoCUDA delivered a 10x to 100x performance boost on legacy code for real. The hardware had been capable of doing this for at least a generations previously but it lacked a few operations to make it accessible and efficient. What I think made people miss it is no one wanted to refactor their code to run efficiently on GPUs. It wasn't that hard to do so in a lot of cases but it was work. And all this set the stage for deep learning. It was the opening act if you will...
- sk5t 8y ago> CUDA delivered a 10x to 100x performance boost on legacy code CUDA offered a way to access a limited set of operations on special-purpose hardware with a rewrite of critical sections. A pretty far cry from 'boosting legacy code.'
- megy 8y ago> If anyone is promising a 20% or greater improvement over the current leaders, I immediately file it away as a scam until I see extraordinary proof. Ha, this is just silly. Ok, so what percent were IBM promising? How do you ever reduce anything complicated into a percent change.
- Bjartr 8y agoI feel like people are interpreting your "20%" criteria more literally than you intended.