3 ms·
> Electric motors are routinely made to run for 100,000 hours and upwards, because they have rotary bearings and only torque to contend with versus the 2500 rp
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> Electric motors are routinely made to run for 100,000 hours and upwards, because they have rotary bearings and only torque to contend with versus the 2500 rpm of IC engines with bearing impact bangs of the IC engine many times per revolution, and the timing belts, and the tappets hammering and the valves burning away, and the muffler and pollution control gizmos rotting and crumbling away.
This is why the series hybrids don't really make sense. If you have to add an engine to generate electricity then it needs a fuel tank, a cooling system, an exhaust system, etc. By the time you add all of that stuff, you might as well just use that cost and weight to put in a bigger battery.
There is no technical reason you can't use an arbitrarily large battery to get arbitrarily long range, it's just that the incremental cost exceeds the incremental benefit for most people, so the current EVs are targeting the much larger number of people who don't actually need that much range. They're also supply constrained on battery production right now, so targeting the niche that requires a very large battery doesn't make sense yet.
This is somewhat what I would expect to eventually see out of a pickup or something that competes with a Chevy Suburban. You have a large vehicle, so plenty of room for batteries in the floor, which you also need to get reasonable range when transporting heavy loads. But then if you're not transporting a heavy load, the same batteries provide much more range than a vehicle which is trying to be spry and sporty.
- ianai 8y agoI think battery tech needs to be much cheaper for it to really answer peoples’ needs. But I do see the situations you’re describing. A half ton truck can afford a pretty hefty battery pack, weight wise. Budget wise it gets pricy quickly. I wonder what sort of battery could be afforded in a larger chassis that’d normally go for 90k, though.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> I think battery tech needs to be much cheaper for it to really answer peoples’ needs. Yes, absolutely, which is what's happening. Lithium battery prices have been falling for years. The price today is too high for a competitive light truck. The price in four or five years time, however?
- thucydidesofusa 8y agoSadly, hybrids make sense to the degree that batteries don't. Although an electric motor and its rudimentary cooling system are trivial compared to a combustion engine and it's attendant systems, it starts to make sense when you consider that 1 gallon of gasoline buys you the energy available from a ~40 kWh battery. Heck, battery electrics arent' even strictly dominant over hydrogen electrics. Hydrogen makes a lot of sense in some applications, what does it say about batteries if people are willing to go to the hassle of developing fuel cells just to get around chemical batteries?
- aurizon 8y agoI think they trye to get the density and fast fill ability of a fluid system, but Hydrogen is an economic failure. Hydrogen is so light that it takes a huge strong tank if compressed and if liquid a huge cooled dewar tank. Hydrogen can be made to work in special cases, not for workaday driving
- dotancohen 8y agoWhy not have the standard 400 km battery pack in the car, and another auxiliary 400 km battery pack that one could place in the trunk, on the roof, on the backseat floor, in the frunk, etc, only when needed?
- de_watcher 8y agoThing is heavy, you'll need a crane in the garage.
- justtopost 8y agoEcars already have cooling systems, etc. The myth that ecars are more simple is just that. A myth.
- aurizon 8y agoWell, ecars ARE simpler, mechanically. IC cars drive the A/C from a pulley on the motor. This means there is a path for high pressure refrigerant gases to the atmosphere. In variably in 2-3 years you lose gas == $$ for the dealers. ecars use a sealed system, like a home refrigeration unit = no gas leakage path. There is another cooling path for the batteries to get rid of the charge/discharge heat, this is another fully sealed fluid circulating system that only leaks in some accident