4 ms·
>There should be laws preventing family members from prolonging the suffering of their loved ones. I can't think of a way to implement a law like that which wo
by whatshisface 8y ago
>There should be laws preventing family members from prolonging the suffering of their loved ones.
I can't think of a way to implement a law like that which wouldn't be fraught with horrible problems. Just imagine the misery associated with doctors deciding to "kill people's children," which in fact in some cases would be unjustified. (Nobody can always get it right, not even doctors.)
- busterarm 8y agoMy entire family is in medicine and I am well aware of this. However, cases like the one I mentioned are fairly clear cut, in my opinion.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoThat doesn’t mean we can’t explore the idea. In Australia, and I believe most places with well developed legal systems, you can get in quite a bit of trouble for mistreating an animal. No so much if you mistreat someone under the auspice of medical or aged care. Our culture has institutionalised the mistreatment of the terminally ill and frail-aged. There are good arguments to be made that this should be seen as a problem that should be addressed.
- Gibbon1 8y agoBrutal but I remember reading an excerpt from an army doctor during the Napoleonic wars. He had two soldiers in his care who had been burned in a gunpowder explosion. A one point a solder came in saw them and then bluntly asked if they would live and was told that it was hopeless. The guy then went and cut both of their necks. The doctor in shock screamed at the man you monster to which them man screamed back I'm not the monster you are.
- Nasrudith 8y agoReminds me of another account of a runway crash that left pilots trapped beneath burning wreckage and the understanding that any extraction and fire fighting would take hours when even minutes of a firey agonizing death, the local commanding officer on the ground grimly shot them both with his service pistol to shorten it to seconds and there was no disciplinary action even considered.
- Gibbon1 8y agoAnother story a friends 93 year old grandfather was found unresponsive in his apartment. Rushed to the hospital and they saved his life. And when he woke up he was utterly pissed because they cheated him out of an easy death. And as a devout Mormon he was done with this world. My born in Greece high school history teacher said the Greeks didn't care how a man died. It's was how you lived that was important. I've tried to keep that in mind.
- fnbr 8y agoAssisted suicide has been legal in Canada for a few years now, and there haven’t been many major issues (other than Catholic hospitals refusing to comply with the law). Doctors aren't fools, and won't do it in cases that aren't blatantly acceptable. Most of the scenarios where it is desirable are cut and dry, and we have ethics boards/courts to handle the other circumstances.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoAssisted suicide is a completely different thing than "laws preventing family members from prolonging the suffering of their loved ones." The first gives patients and families more options in how to deal with end of life care, the other takes options away.
- cronix 8y ago> the other takes options away Yes, it takes it out of the hands of the family and actually respects the patients final wishes, that they made for themselves while still lucid.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoWhat are you referring to? No one is talking about invalidating advance directives, or taking away medical power of attorney, etc., in cases where, as you put it, "the patients final wishes, that they made for themselves while still lucid" are known. Of course (unfortunately) most people still don't take these steps to make their wishes known. But the original comment was about "laws preventing family members from prolonging the suffering of their loved ones," specifically about an example of a young child, whose wishes were not known (and of course not really relevant for a toddler). The fact is in the absence of any advanced directive I would much rather have the family make decisions about the type of care desired by the patient than the state.
- coldacid 8y ago"Refusing to comply with the law" sounds like assisted suicide is mandated, when it's really a voluntary thing. As it is, where are there even still private, religious hospitals in the country? At least here in Ontario hospitals are all public institutions.
- jdietrich 8y ago>I can't think of a way to implement a law like that which wouldn't be fraught with horrible problems. Existing child protection laws are for the most part perfectly satisfactory, if they're actually used. The courts routinely decide on whether a parent is fit to make decisions about their child, or whether a particular decision is in the best interests of that child. Many of these cases will individually present very difficult decisions, but the legal principles are relatively straightforward. The impediment to actually using those laws is largely that of pro-life activism - few hospitals are willing to legally advocate on behalf of a suffering child because of the fear of becoming the centre of a media circus.
- bobthepanda 8y agoYeah, the Terri Schiavo case is a great example of how pro-life activism unnecessarily prolonged someone's suffering: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terri_Schiavo_case https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terri_Schiavo_case
- jrnichols 8y agoThat is what I was referring to earlier in the thread. I think that case had far reaching effects, even to this day.
- DanBC 8y agoIn some US states the doctors propose a plan, and if the parents of the child disagree with that plan they can go to court to get an injunction to prevent the doctors carrying it out. Compare that with England. The doctors propose a plan, and if the parents disagree with it the doctors go to court to get an order. The court has to look at the child's best interests and the paramountcy principle means that while everyone's (parents and childs) rights are looked at it's the rights of the child that take priority. > associated with doctors deciding to "kill people's children," They can already do this in most of the US.
- mikeash 8y agoThe current situation is already fraught with horrible problems! We torture innocent children to death! Would the problems you’re imagining really be worse?