4 ms·
Why's it 'land'? Did they helicopter in or something? They make it sound like a special forces raid. > Only the state can act like this under proper laws Didn
by chrisseaton 8y ago
Why's it 'land'? Did they helicopter in or something? They make it sound like a special forces raid.
> Only the state can act like this under proper laws
Didn't they just go and knock on his door? Anyone can knock on a door. There's no law against this.
- teh_klev 8y agoIt's an Indian news site so I'm guessing their usage of english likely varies somewhat from say British english. > Anyone can knock on a door. There's no law against this Again, this happened in India, so the laws on behaviour like this may be different.
- _jgdh 8y agoThere are no laws against knocking on doors in India. If you don't want folks knocking on your doors, you would employ someone to prevent them from doing so.
- jjgreen 8y agoIt's an Indian site, and Indian English idiom can often sound odd to English or American ears.
- jogjayr 8y agoIt's a common way to say "show up unannounced" in Indian English.
- dogma1138 8y agoI wonder if it has anything to do with people showing unannounced and uninvited on the sub continent historically actually had to land there, i.e. the Portuguese and the British.
- scarejunba 8y agoMakes no sense. The subcontinent has had its fair share of land invasions that required no travel by sea.
- foobarchu 8y agoMost of them, in fact. I can think of no incursions by sea except for British, Portuguese, and French, none of which were actual 'invasions' at the time so much as merchants wanting to trade (which, of course, did lead directly to the british raj, but that was never the original intention of the EIC).
- jogjayr 8y agoThat seems like a stretch. It's not a literal translation of the equivalent phrase in any Indian language I speak. And there were nearly zero English speakers in India before Europeans came, so it's not like Indians made up the idiom as the British sailed their ships into the harbor.
- callmeal 8y ago>Didn't they just go and knock on his door? Anyone can knock on a door. There's no law against this. The Aadhaar card is the equivalent of a social security card. Imagine a FB team knocking on your door demanding your "papers" because of a post you made. Is that acceptable?
- chrisseaton 8y agoWhat does 'demanding' mean? What are they going to do if you say no? It sounds like they're asking for something and people don't have to give it if they don't want to. Facebook may stop doing business with them, but that's between them and Facebook. You're talking like Facebook would have arrested them or something if they didn't show it. I'm not sure that's what's going on here. They're just asking for something. Say 'no' if you don't want to show them. Unless they're showing up repeatedly or at weird hours of day but that's not implied at all. Sounds like it's just a business visit?
- Barrin92 8y agoaccording to a legal expert cited in the article what facebook did is a violation of the users privacy in India. Secondly, in what world is it normal for a social media company to knock on someone's door for content they posted on their platform? If I make a comment in the washington post online section, am I going to get 'business visits' from the moderators? This is entirely inappropriate, apparently not even legal in the country in question, and sounds like something out of a cyberpunk parody.
- chrisseaton 8y ago> If I make a comment in the washington post online section This is formal political advertising, isn't? That's heavily regulated everywhere I know. It's not the same as posting a comment as an individual. If you buy alcohol in a shop they ask for ID. Nobody thinks that's crazy. If you want to post a political advert they ask for ID. It seems like all they're doing here is rewording that to 'demanding' and making it sound like a police raid.