4 ms·
Since they started putting Rust in Firefox, it crashes literally hundreds of times a day. (Usually the crashes are in subprocesses. Not always.) Is Rust to blam
by ncmncm 8y ago
Since they started putting Rust in Firefox, it crashes literally hundreds of times a day. (Usually the crashes are in subprocesses. Not always.) Is Rust to blame? I don't know. But I would rather see some attention to the crashes than any new features, or new OSes, right at the moment.
- stouset 8y agoOn the flip side, I switched to Firefox once the first “quantum” version was released (62?) and I haven’t experienced a single crash. Then again, I don’t remember seeing a crash in either Safari or Chrome in ages, but the point being that Firefox seems at least as stable as it’s competition.
- tasty_freeze 8y agoI have three different (windows) machines which use firefox daily, and I get a subprocess crash less than once a month.
- majewsky 8y agoHow does a subprocess crash look like? Not sure if I've ever seen one.
- tialaramex 8y agoFirefox will tell you that the tab you opened or are looking at or whatever has crashed, it will apologise and offer to try loading it again. In my experience that usually works, but in principle of course it might not. I've used Mozilla M-series browsers back at the turn of the century and we crashed those "hundreds of times per day" but that's because we were DOM mangling back when that was new and exciting, not how everything works in every popular web page. Also the M-series weren't finished, hence the milestone number instead of a release version.
- lytedev 8y agoIf you're truly seeing crashes "literally hundreds of times per day", I'm sure the Firefox team would appreciate the information you have! I suspect that the problem is not Firefox itself, which I put through the ringer daily and am extremely happy with it.
- beatgammit 8y agoUsually this is graphics driver related, but there could definitely be some bugs that OP's unique usage triggers.
- tdurden 8y agoI find it hard to believe that you continue using software that crashes "literally hundreds of times a day".
- user5994461 8y agoDon't we all use software that crash every day? Maybe not a hundred times but more than zero.
- xiphias2 8y agoOf course, for me it's the Julia interpreter that crashes all the time. After I fix my program, and write some new code it crashes again, but differently. But for programs that I haven't written: no, they generally don't crash too often.
- zamadatix 8y agoErr... no? That would be ridiculously annoying. If you're having issues every day it's either time to find new software or new hardware.
- tdurden 8y agoI don't, but I can see how one could put up with it for a critical piece of software with no alternatives. In this case though, we are talking about hundreds of crashes a day for software that has multiple alternatives.
- littlestymaar 8y agoFor a “critical piece of software with no alternatives” you could imagine having one to a few crashes a day, but not hundreds of them. Using such a buggy software for “critical” stuff would be close to insanity ;).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 8y ago
- arghwhat 8y agoRust is not Firefox. Rust does not disallow crashes, it disallows that your code will run in unsafe manners, either with compile-time errors or runtime panics (with some exceptions for `unsafe` code). Browsers are to some extend more complicated than the operating system they run on, so it's no surprise that there are bugs in there. If you experience crashes, please do submit the crash reports, and if you already know what the cause of the crash is, please file a bug on bugzilla. Thanks!
- robin_reala 8y agoit disallows that your code will run in unsafe manners To be picky, it specifically allows unsafe code as long as it’s marked up as such.
- smolder 8y agoIf that's really the case, I think you have a hardware stability problem. Perhaps firefox is using AVX instructions or doing something else your system doesn't like.