The problem with colleges teaching vocations, such as CS or engineering, is that they are too often remote from the realities of what is actually needed by prof

The problem with colleges teaching vocations, such as CS or engineering, is that they are too often remote from the realities of what is actually needed by professionals working in the field. To be honest, most vocations are better taught by apprenticeship, but we turned our back on that path a long time ago. I know a professional journalist who believes the same of his profession. College is not an especially good way of training someone for a profession, it's just that we have nearly eliminated the other ways of doing so, and thus by default it is pressed into service for a task it is not especially suited for.