8 ms·
Foods for healthier people and a healthier planet [pdf]
- seltzered_ 8y agoI bookmarked this a couple weeks ago, to help with your own note-taking, here's the list: # Algae Laver seaweed Wakame seaweed Beans & Pulses Adzuki beans Black turtle beans Broad beans Bambara groundnuts Cowpeas Lentils # Cacti Nopales # Cereals & Grains Amaranth Buckwheat Finger millet Fonio Knorasan wheat Quinoa Spelt # Fruit Vegetables Pumpkin flowers Okra Orange tomatoes # Leaf Greens Beet greens Broccoli rabe Kale Moringa Pak-choi Pumpkin leaves # Mushrooms Enoki mushrooms Maitake mushrooms Saffron milk cap mushrooms # Nuts & Seeds Flax seeds Hemp seeds Sesame seeds Walnuts # Root Vegetables Black salsify Parsley root White icicle radish # Sprouts Alfalfa sprouts Sprouted kidney beans Sprouted chickpeas # Tubers Lotus root Ube (purple yam) Jicama Red Indonesian sweet potato
- Jeff_Brown 8y agoIt looks like you left out the # next to Beans and Pulses.
- sabareesh 8y agoMuch easier to read. Thank you
- pndy 8y agoKnorr Future 50 Report? Title should be changed to inform that it's not WWF report alone.
- endorphone 8y agoIt should be changed as the report was spearheaded by Dorothy Shaver, "Registered Dietitian and Global Knorr Sustainability Lead." Some will view that cynically, but there is absolutely nothing in the report that seems biased or benefiting Knorr in any way, beyond sincerely trying to herald sustainable food and at most getting a bit of credit for trying to do good. It still is an interesting read.
- mekoka 8y agoI scanned the report for Knorr's involvement and nothing seemed fishy to me. There was this paragraph: This was assessed by Knorr cross-functional teams of marketers, nutritionists, chefs, and product developers spanning across Asia, Africa, North America, South America, Europe and Australia, who answered the assessment questions with yes/no/maybe for every ingredient. The data were collated and assessed to determine which foods should potentially be eliminated based on responses. If more than half of the countries answered ‘no’ to one of the questions, the ingredient was eliminated. The relative nutrient density scores (NRF) were considered when choosing between foods with similar input, ensuring the foods in the final list would be nutritious. Then later near the bottom: Knorr and WWF have joined forces with other leaders in nutrition and sustainability to develop Future 50 Foods In writing this report, Knorr, WWF and Adam Drewnowski are grateful for input and review from experts at Bioversity International, Crops For the Future, EAT Foundation, Edelman, Food and Land Use Coalition (FOLU), Food Reform for Sustainability and Health (FReSH), GAIN, Global Crop Diversity Trust, Gro Intelligence, Oxfam GB, SDG2 Advocacy Hub, Wageningen University and Yolélé Foods. This report ultimately reflects the views of Knorr, WWF and Adam Drewnowski. The creation of this report was led by Dorothy Shaver, Registered Dietitian and Global Knorr Sustainability Lead. It was published in February 2019.
- papermachete 8y agoThis is a joke, right? Call me when they sell this at my local groceries' (for cheap).
- fenwick67 8y agoMany of the items on this list are very cheap today.
- fsloth 8y agoThis. Western world has a bit skewed view of food anyway, since most distribution is handled by large companies that optimize for their own profit, and this applies to producers as well. We couldn't survive without modern "food chains", but that does not mean the crops used by the modern processes are the only viable ones. Rather, they are the most popular ones for which the processes have been optimized for.
- dmix 8y agoA huge part of it is that they make money on what people want to buy as well. I’m sure if they put seaweed and cacti in most American grocery stores most people would skip them for what they think will be good for dinner. Therefore having zero profit without the companies margins having anything to do with it. What’s available has typically played a role but it’s not the only metric.
- firethief 8y agoWhere do you live, Maine? Every grocery store around me has seaweed and cacti and I live in the sticks. Only the most demographically challenged parts of the country lack Asian and Mexican options in the supermarkets.
- dmix 8y agoI just said whether or not it’s available isn’t the only metric but whether people want to eat it or not. Which plays far more into revenue than just margins. The fact some grocery stores have it is besides the point.
- xaqar 8y agoWhy are all 50 items on the list "SNAP INTO A SLIM JIM!"? What do you mean the "other" WWF?
- dstroot 8y agoVery few jokes here on HN. Upvoted due to involuntary chuckle. ;)
- MegaDeKay 8y agoBecause OH YEAAAAH. That's why.
- nobody271 8y agoFor a more hyrdated planet the WWF suggests Brondo. It's got electrolytes.
- AznHisoka 8y agoCame here for this comment. For me there is no other WWF, damn it!
- hdpq 8y agoseriously what i thought when i clicked on this ...
- OneWordSoln 8y ago(Side note: that is one gorgeous document.) After watching the excellent documentary "Eating You Alive", I have mostly switched to a whole-food plant-based diet and feel fantastic, although I do eat the occasional pair of eggs. The big difficulty with the diet is avoiding all the refined oils that permeate our packaged food culture. Luckily, my wife is a professional cook and still cooks at home. That said, this document already has some of my favs and has added a ton of new ideas. This crazy diet is really difficult just from a "finding foods I can actually eat" sense. As such, I have lost a few pounds but one thing I notice for sure is that my skin is in much better shape now. The beautiful thing about the diet is that I find that my body can handle cheat foods much better and I feel happy to get back on the diet right after. Of all the things I miss, I miss cheese the most, but coffee with oat milk is just fine. Ultimately, I think the beauty of this diet is that I am forced to eat things like beans, tubers, tofu and whole grains for lack of anything else to eat. And I'm usually so dang hungry that I love them, thanks to my wife's efforts. Oh, and the diet is actually much less expensive, especially when you buy dry beans.
- sachdevap 8y agoDid I miss something in this comment? I don't understand the downvotes.
- OneWordSoln 8y agoThanks for asking the obvious, but I sure don't know and the only people who do have a clue (i.e. those who did the downvoting) probably don't have the guts to explain themselves because it would likely prove their pettiness. That we live in a world full of cowards is the sad-ass truth.
- Proven 8y agoThanks but no thanks
- qwerty456127 8y agoLooks yummy.
- tyingq 8y agoIn case you decide to experiment with some things on the list...saffron milk cap mushrooms turn your urine reddish orange. Harmless, but a potential scare if you aren't aware.
- Valmar 8y agoSo... a Vegan diet? No thanks.
- jdavis703 8y agoThis list recommends many foods that are rare in common western diets. You can eat none of the foods, some of the foods, or exclusively all the foods listed.
- mises 8y agoIt's worth noting for anyone that advocates this sort of diet that it is a luxury. Many people mention that you can make good food on such a diet, but it is doubtless time-consuming. What of those who work by the hour? And the ingredients are expensive. Many of the fancy foods on here come from Whole Foods, not HEB. Even if they become affordable, the time aspect is still important; most don't want to spend 2 hours cooking regularly. Honest question for those who follow such a diet: how do you not feel hungry? If I don't have meat, I tend to stay hungry. I regularly eat lots of meat for this reason, and am still very slim (no health issues), so it's not like it's hurting me. I tried not eating meat for a month or so, and I perform measurably worse (comparing my output on days when I ate meat vs not). Maybe it just doesn't work for everyone?
- ethbro 8y agoDo you eat equivalent amounts of protein when you eat less meat? I've started eating a lot less meat, but typically through limiting how much of a meal it comprises vs no-meat meals. If I replace meat with greek yogurt or beans, I haven't noticed much difference.
- batmands 8y agoBeans and grains are generally pretty cheap and available pretty widely. You can make a lot at a time, and stick it in a tupperware container to later combine/season. Eating beans/grains can also be quite filling. I personally grow tired of eating such things after a while, but I don't think they are expensive/time-consuming and they do satisfy hunger.
- CodeGlitch 8y agoThey also have the added advantage of long shelf-life. ie. tinned beans, dried, etc. This means you can buy them in bulk = price savings.
- luckylion 8y ago> I personally grow tired of eating such things after a while, but I don't think they are expensive/time-consuming and they do satisfy hunger. "Satisfy hunger" does sound pretty basic though, doesn't it? I don't think the idea was "you can survive for a long time on this", but rather "this is tasty, ethical and nutritious, go try it".
- hirundo 8y agoOf the five Guiding Principles on page 52 only about 1.5 of them are primarily concerned with the nutrition content of the food. The rest are mostly focused on their environmental impact. Not that there's anything wrong with that. And clearly that's aligned with the mission of the WWF. But I think you'd get a much different list if it was just about maximizing the health of the eater. E.g. meat. When I choose food at the grocery store I'm focused on which are better for me, not Earth. If I were convinced that there is a genuine discrepancy between those goals, I'd likely still choose me. Am I the bad guy?
- iscrewyou 8y agoNo, you are not the bad guy but it's good to be concerned. I focus on companies when I shop. If there are two similar choices of big 2.5 gallons of water, I don't choose arrowhead. I think that's what they are trying to get at.
- fastbeef 8y agoI really don’t want to come off as some sort of condescending euro-snob, but is the state of tap water in the US so bad so that you have to purchase plastic bottles of water?
- tzs 8y agoUS consumption of bottled water in 2017 was 42 gallons per capita (160 liters) [1]. That's behind Italy (188 liters per capita) and Germany (175 liters per capita). The EU average is 117 liters per capita [2]. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/183377/per-capita-consumption-of-bottled-water-in-the-us-since-1999/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/183377/per-capita-consum... [2] https://www.statista.com/statistics/455422/bottled-water-consumption-in-europe-per-capita/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/455422/bottled-water-con...
- fastbeef 8y agoThat's fascinating, thank you! Excellent site as well, looking forward to dig throuhg it.
- 2T1Qka0rEiPr 8y ago> Eating less common varieties of vegetables... drives demand which will increase the variety of types of crops grown, which, in turn, makes the food system more resilient I get this, but it seems fundamentally at odds with economies of scale which surely the natural market would gravitate towards. Seems like government intervention would be necessary here to overcome the externalities that growing a single variety at extreme quantities creates?
- luckylion 8y agoGrowing a single variety is likely too risky. While you may be able to minimize the risk with artificial watering, pest control etc, if it strikes, you'll end your company. Most companies don't aim for a series of all-or-nothing-bets even if the odds are in their favor on each one, they hedge their bets.
- 2T1Qka0rEiPr 8y agoThis might be true, but there are plenty of cases where this is exactly the case (e.g. bananas, rubber). Also, as the article points out, there are "heirloom" crops which would surely mitigate this danger somewhat but would presumably still be perfect for economies of scale - e.g. due to the reduced marginal cost for R&D to build machines etc. appropriate for harvesting?
- luckylion 8y agoBananas are an example of a local single-crop bet, and they are hedged by planting different crops elsewhere. There certainly is a desire to reduce variety, but it's likely to come down to a few dozen plants (out of thousands, and for each one, there have been hundreds of variations and sub-types), not to a single one - too risky, and regional conditions are too different to have a one-size-fits-all-crop.
- firethief 8y agoOn the supply side, government intervention is what it takes to internalize externalities. Monocropping is only the most profitable choice when the cost of heavy use of fertilizers and pesticides is low.
- skilled 8y agoImagine being so addicted to dairy and meat that you think that you can't survive without either.
- SlowRobotAhead 8y agoWay to personify the smug elistist diet. Lower and middle class blue collar worker arent walking around talking about their ‘addiction’ to diary and meat. Having a diet of single origin seaweed and small batch imported beans is a very nice luxary that is not for everyone. I’m glad you’ve found another way to be better than “those people”. Intersting how global climate change is happily used as a wedge against individuals so readily.
- skilled 8y agoI see what you are saying. But it's simply not true. Seeds, nuts, fruits, vegetables, and grains come in many different varieties. And most are very affordable. I think the bigger issues is that people don't want to look like birds while nibbling away on a bowl of pineapple rice pudding with chia seeds. I eat cooked food once or twice a week. Buckwheat and lentils (extremely cheap!) are my preferred choice. I can get a 2lb bag of soy protein with essential amino acids for exercise diet. Ohh, tempeh, tofu, Kimchi? Yeah man... soo elitist. If you want I can go on. I have many years of experience and live a paycheck lifestyle.
- Nasrudith 8y agoThat is an utterly vapid statement format that states only ones own sense of superiority with nothing about any actual merits. It brings to mind a smug inuit saying "Imagine being so addicted to eating plants from the ground that they you think you can't survive without it!" Or the same from someone living on a hypothetical full synthesized diet. It is absurd and meaningless.
- skilled 8y agoHaha, what are you trying to say, my friend? Are you saying that you are unaware of the current practices in meat mass-production? Because if you need a reminder, here is one link [1] and here is another. [2] Can you honestly have any argument against the fact that 99% of the meat and dairy you buy on the market has been in some way altered or modified? Not to mention that a lot of this product comes out enzyme-less by default, and by adding the factor if cooking it's just that much worse. Your body needs enzymes to process food, and if they're not there, you are literally dropping atomic bombs in your stomach that slow down your entire system. [3] I'm not trying to be hypocritical either. I grew up on meat and dairy. But somehow the transition away from it came naturally to me, many, many years ago. I lived near local farms for most of my life, and even the local farmers (in a "remote" part of the world) have started to use additive injections and questionable food choices because there is serious competition. And I understand your point of view. You think I come off sounding insensitive, but I am more than happy to talk facts and lay down some examples. Because, after all, that's what HN loves the most. [1]: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/oct/01/death-rates-surge-female-pigs-us https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/oct/01/death-ra... [2]: https://www.livestrong.com/article/464430-are-hormones-in-meat-affecting-humans/ https://www.livestrong.com/article/464430-are-hormones-in-me... [3]: https://greensmoothiegirl.com/digestive-enzymes/ https://greensmoothiegirl.com/digestive-enzymes/
- Synaesthesia 8y agoFava beans. You can make a very good falafel out of them and they’re cheap. I believe falafel is the future
- CodeGlitch 8y agoI admit I've never had flafel - a quick google does make them look tasty. I'm going to definintly look into cooking some.
- lucb1e 8y agoI've had falafel and don't understand why non-vegetarians/vegans rarely eat it. It's tasty like any other food (and more tasty than some of the stuff we do commonly eat like bread!).
- Synaesthesia 8y agoI make a lot and you preferably have to deep fry them but it’s easy if you have a food processor. If you have a middle eastern take away near you maybe you can get some there.
- random878 8y agoIt's the first thing I recommend if someone asks me about vegan fast food (or healthier alternative to other fast foods). Forget all that impossible burger nonsense, a great falafel place is the best!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kylek 8y agoFirst thought- HELL YAH I'M READY TO SNAP INTO A SLIM JIM. Second- disappointment :/
- aszantu 8y agoSo my depression, anxiety and adhd went away when I stopped eating plants. I have one sack of plastic waste per month and I buy locally and I spend about 16€ / week on meat and a few bucks more on cheese and eggs.
- majewsky 8y agoWhat qualifies you to extrapolate this single case into a global policy suggestion (as you seem to be implying)?
- johnchristopher 8y agoDid you figure out the link between plants consumption and your symptoms of depression ? What does your typical diet look like now ?
- lucb1e 8y ago> The Bambara groundnut is considered ‘complete food’ because of the balance of macronutrients accompanied by the amino acid and fatty acid content. Is a "complete food" a food that supplies most of what we need? I've heard one could almost live on potatoes, with only some vitamin supplements, is that also a 'complete food'?
- tzs 8y ago> I've heard one could almost live on potatoes, with only some vitamin supplements, is that also a 'complete food'? Yes. Here's an article about it, and some one actually tried it for a while [1]. [1] https://www.popsci.com/nutrition-single-food-survival https://www.popsci.com/nutrition-single-food-survival
- otabdeveloper2 8y ago> FOCUS ON PLANT-BASED FOODS A great idea if you want to save the planet by having people die out from exploding (pun intended) obesity.
- Pfhreak 8y agoWhat's the pun? And what's the connection between a diet primarily built around plants and obesity?
- byteman 8y agoSincere question: Do you actually believe that eating plants and not eating enough Meat and Dairy is what leads to obesity? Could you please elaborate on that? Also, I'd love to know what country you are from, if you don't mind me asking :)
- rpiguy 8y agoThe tone of the comments in this thread terrify me. We have exchanged one set of preachers trying to tell us how to live with a new set of preachers telling us how to live and it is just as bad or worse. Always a group of people trying to suppress your freedom and advertise their virtue.
- mekoka 8y agoNo reason to be terrified. The difference between now and the past times you're alluding to is that if back then people's freedom was being suppressed, nowadays they're volunteering it away. Want to stay free? Inform yourself from a variety of sources and infer the truth from the consistency of facts being reported. This report is but a supplemental source of input for you to dig in.
- Pfhreak 8y agoWhat does your comment even mean? "Here's 50 foods that reduce impact and feed more people" "STOP OPPRESSING ME!" Really? Like, if you don't think these foods are worth your time, maybe just do your own thing? These foods are already widely eaten by a whole range of people, cultures, and socieconomic statuses.
- rpiguy 8y agoI will happily do my own thing, until the do goodies decide my hamburger is destroying the environment and adding to national health costs and decide to tax it into oblivion. The article wasn’t bad, I was more offput by the comments. I will edit my post to remove the reference to the article.
- byteman 8y agoWell are you disputing the damage inflicted to the environment by meat consumption, or are you saying you should be allowed to harm the environment with no limitation or consequence whatsoever?
- 8y ago
- bellerose 8y agoI think the problem for most people not eating healthier is lack of knowledge in preparation, cooking and storing. Recently I purchased an instant pot and it makes cooking healthy food extremely easy with decreasing prep & cleaning time. I just throw everything into this pot with water, hit a few buttons and wait 30mins to an hour. All goes into containers in the fridge and can be reheated in the microwave. I can make a good week worth of food in a few hours. I'm still trying to perfect different meals since I never used to cook.
- jriot 8y agoMaybe we should eat foods native to our culture and region. Being from Louisiana, I eat plenty of meat (I have no ethical qualms with animals dying so I can eat meat, its apart of life), vegetables that can grow in the region, starches that also grow in the region e.g.,, converted Louisiana white rice, and take in a good portion of dairy. I don't need my food imported from around the world, I eat what is grown and raised here. Couple that with an active lifestyle and I don't see any need to change.
- lucb1e 8y ago> I have no ethical qualms with animals dying so I can eat meat Of the people I know that do not eat meat, including myself, they don't not eat it because of religion or animal pity...