3 ms·
Realistically signal/noise ratio of 0.05 to 0.01 is good enough in open forum comments. It's still possible to scan comments and find the signal from the noi
by nabla9 8y ago
Realistically signal/noise ratio of 0.05 to 0.01 is good enough in open forum comments. It's still possible to scan comments and find the signal from the noise.
Usenet was incredible before the eternal September. There was noise, trolls, flame wars and mentally instable people and good and bad moderation decisions, but the good was really good. Party due to the higher quality of the users and from the inability to make money from it. Top people were reading and lurking in relevant newsgroups and commented sometimes or sent private comment via email.
HN has two things common with Usenet, good moderation and higher than average users. What has changed is the motives. There are many users who are self promoting or marketing with pseudo-informative submissions. They push blog posts that are just written to increase visibility and "what I experienced when doing business", many of those stories made up.
With all this negative stuff, HN has still good singal/noise ratio and you can learn from comments and discussions.
- vasili111 8y agoDo you know other such high quality comment places as hacker news or early Usernet?
- colejohnson66 8y agoLobsters, I’d presume, but it’s invite only
- eitland 8y agoAsk for an invite. That's how I got my account there. Be ready to supply an email address and be aware that at least some of thise who sends invites dig through posting history before sending an invite. Also note that posting and commenting guidelines might be experienced as somewhat stricter than here.