3 ms·
As a counter argument to keeping everything open there's a bunch of things you want encrypted. Radio controlled things. This is even a problem for the people th
by godelski 8y ago
As a counter argument to keeping everything open there's a bunch of things you want encrypted. Radio controlled things. This is even a problem for the people that are trying to create HAM internet connections. You can't use any SSL. Though it'd be slow, I'd love to see a world wide internet that could be accessed by HAM. I can't think of anything more world changing than having an open internet that everyone can reach with a $10 device.
So I think there are cases where being able to use encryption would be nice. But there are also plenty of cases to keep things open. So maybe we need to talk about some compromise. Maybe keeping certain bands open and others not.
- tzs 8y agoThe rule against encryption on ham bands doesn't prohibit digital signatures. It just prohibits encryption of message content. For radio control a protocol that sends commands in the clear but signs them should be sufficient to let you securely control something without violating the rules.
- godelski 8y agoFrom my understanding because of this limitation you can't send encrypted passwords.
- rietta 8y agoWhich is why you have to use other protocols and key authentication. Whatever the current equivalent of Cram-MD5 or just plain public key HMACS. I wrote about this 15 years ago in April 2004 - https://rietta.com/blog/2009/08/17/authentication-without-encryption-for/ https://rietta.com/blog/2009/08/17/authentication-without-en...
- vageli 8y agoA ham radio license enables you to transmit encrypted messages only when operating a space radio station or remote aircraft which is something, but not much.