3 ms·
The advantage of MSRs is not that they can't melt down (or that they could use thorium; that's vastly overhyped), it's that there's no volatile material in the
by pfdietz 8y ago
The advantage of MSRs is not that they can't melt down (or that they could use thorium; that's vastly overhyped), it's that there's no volatile material in the containment building.
The containment of a LWR has to be large because it fills with radioactive steam in an accident. It has to be able to contain this steam, which means at least a certain amount of structure to withstand its pressure.
But MSRs don't use water as a coolant. They circulate salt in and out of the building. They can be designed to remain at low pressure even in a bad accident, just from heat transfer that occurs from thermal radiation at elevated temperature. As a result, the cost of the containment could be as much as 1/5th that of a LWR.
Unfortunately, MSRs are not available today, and likely will not be for decades (especially if new materials must be qualified; no one will buy an MSR if there is any question about the materials not lasting their projected lifespans.) By that time, renewables will have marched down their experience curves to an economic position that will likely be unassailable.
- acidburnNSA 8y agoI'm pretty convinced that they're worth working on today because in 20 years when we have vast renewable deployment we'll either have solved the storage/intermittency problem with no unexpected environmental or economic costs, or we'll desperately need advanced nuclear. It's kind of a Pascal's Wager type of thing: worst case if you work on advanced reactors is that you learn new things about reactors and maybe they'll be useful in deep space (far from the sun). Worse case if you don't work on advanced reactors is you get screwed by climate change when running into logistical issues with renewable intermittency.
- pfdietz 8y agoYes. MSRs are an insurance policy in case renewables suddenly stop getting cheaper. They might have niche uses (very high latitudes, actinide destruction), but that won't be earthshattering if we don't have it.
- icelancer 8y ago> By that time, renewables will have marched down their experience curves to an economic position that will likely be unassailable. You're posting this and statements like it all over this thread without a lot of supporting evidence that indicates very strong probability of it happening. Hacker News currently has a highly-ranked article on the main page regarding how there are massive battery and energy storage problems, and this particular issue is raised weekly here and in the news. Why are you so optimistic that seemingly significant blockers will be for sure eliminated in the short decades to come?
- pfdietz 8y agoThe reason to be optimistic about renewables is they have a proven track record of improvement. These experience curve effects are somewhat mysterious, but they've been shown to occur in a wide variety of industries. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Experience_curve_effects#The_experience_curve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Experience_curve_effects#The_e... Solar has declined in price by 20% (or perhaps a bit more) for each doubling of cumulative production. This empirical observation has been sustained over a history during which solar's cost has declined by more than two orders of magnitude. Wind has showed similar learning effects. Nuclear, on the other hand, has not shown consistent experience effects (or, arguably, any, if one discard as unreliable the numbers from South Korea). Talk is cheap, but renewables have actually demonstrated, in the real world, that they get cheaper as they are built out (and, if anything, the learning rate has increased recently). Nuclear proponents are hanging the future of their technology on the assumption, unsupported by much of anything, that these real world trends will suddenly switch places.
- jabl 8y agoYes, for reactors operating at atmospheric pressure like MSR or metal cooled reactors, the containment building is much cheaper. And by not needing stuff that stands up to 15 MPa, you can frickin' stamp out the reactors from sheet metal. Well, not quite, but a lot simpler and faster than building large pressure vessels capable of LWR pressures with 25cm thick walls.