4 ms·
No, nuclear is sadly not a viable solution, due to cost. If nuclear were affordable it would be pushed through regardless of opposition. But it has just not w
by pfdietz 8y ago
No, nuclear is sadly not a viable solution, due to cost. If nuclear were affordable it would be pushed through regardless of opposition. But it has just not worked out.
The people with the money saw what happened at Vogtle and Summer (and also at Flamanville, Olkiluoto, Hinkley Point). Those efforts to make nuclear affordable failed spectacularly, even with public and government support. Westinghouse and Areva were just unable to execute.
This failure should not have been a surprise, as it mirrored what happened in the last big nuclear construction boom. That didn't stop because of accidents; it stopped because the nuclear plants in that boom experienced substantial cost overruns (i.e., the nuclear vendors were not honest about what the technology would actually cost.)
- DennisP 8y agoHalf the article was about the reasons costs are so much higher in the U.S. than South Korea, and how to fix it.
- pfdietz 8y agoWe've heard that sort of thing for decades. How many more times does Lucy have to pull the football away before you catch on?
- acidburnNSA 8y agoTo be fair, the US never did any of the things that we now know make nuclear cheap. Standard design, experienced workforce, established supply chain. Until we try those things you can't quite say Lucy has been pulling the football. There's a really awesome way of getting all this: build nuclear reactors in shipyards.
- godelski 8y agoI never buy the cost problem. I mean look at France. That's another great example. Has some of the cheapest electricity and is 75% nuclear.
- natmaka 8y agoElectricity in France is not "one of the cheapest", it is average in Europe and quickly rising. Moreover part of the total related costs (R&D...) was historically paid by the taxpayer. Future decommission and waste-management costs may lead to a financial disaster (take a look at decommission costs in the UK). https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php/Electricity_price_statistics https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php...
- eMSF 8y agoOlkiluoto was not an exercise to make nuclear power affordable. The company was granted with a permission to build a single reactor, the first permit in decades, so they chose the most powerful one available, a first of its kind. With all the overruns, it has certainly proved to be an expensive build. However, it's all been done with private money, unlike the so called cheap renewables that cost the public hundreds of millions in subsidies.
- eMSF 8y agoHey, downvoter. You forgot to name yourself as to who we should look up to. In any case, I'll dedicate an extra litre of petrol for you -- hope it was worth it! (I hope you understand why you "greens" don't fare so well when it comes to elections -- you don't have a message to stand on!)
- dang 8y agoCan you please not post dross comments to HN? They break the site guidelines in many ways. It would be great if you're review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and take the spirit of this site to heart.