4 ms·
> it's VERY thorough and personally invasive to minimize the risks And yet, near completely useless as shown by cases known to wide public. If you think black
by baybal2 8y ago
> it's VERY thorough and personally invasive to minimize the risks
And yet, near completely useless as shown by cases known to wide public.
If you think blackmail is the only thing that can compromise a man, you have a lot to learn about life.
History: some of most baffling espionage cases were "walk ins"
I think, it is the type of personality that services all around the world seek – somebody brilliant, but easy to guide, and motivateable with BS pretenses, that itself makes such people to seek to play with fire.
- caymanjim 8y agoThis guy is the textbook case for clearance exclusion: lots of personal debt that he couldn't manage. It's the number one reason people are rejected or have their clearance revoked. While the article doesn't state it, I assume he had already stolen the information prior to losing his clearance, and that they were no longer monitoring his finances (nor could they know he had the information stashed away). It does show some premeditation, though; the fact that he saved information tells me he was always planning to use it if the opportunity arose.
- baybal2 8y agoWell, that's a textbook case for sure... And it is one more reason against having intelligence activities being ran by civilians as in USA.
- caymanjim 8y agoA CIA case officer isn't exactly a normal civilian. I'm also not sure why you think being in the military would make any difference here. For all we know, he was recruited out of the military. There's nothing magically special about non-civilians that makes them more or less likely to commit espionage.
- globbledyGeau 8y agoRead between the lines, you twit. What he's saying is it doesn't make sense to place a schlub in command of exceptionally potent information, if they feel even remotely unfulfilled. To wit, the nuclear launch codes. Do you want someone mildly depressed in charge of them? And yet, no questionnaire on earth can adequately quantify a propensity for depression, well enough that the authority for launching the missiles might be reasonably secure an any one person's hands.
- ironSkillet 8y agoIn fact in the article it states that he spent time in the army before joining the CIA, so there you go...
- couldveBeenYou 8y agoWoweee! You sure showed him on this internet forum. Sure looks like somebody's always right, and thank God for that! I bet it feels really good to educate the public with guerilla campaigns to promote and get out the awareness to the masses! Yay! Thank you so mich for enlightening me! Wheeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!!!!!!!1one
- baybal2 8y ago> There's nothing magically special about non-civilians that makes them more or less likely to commit espionage. There is quite a lot...
- walshemj 8y agoWho else would you suggest ?
- creato 8y ago> And yet, near completely useless as shown by cases known to wide public. How do you know that? A few public failures says nothing about how many successes there are or aren't. Any system involving hundreds of thousands (millions?) of people is going to have some failures, no matter how good the system might be.
- GVIrish 8y ago> And yet, near completely useless as shown by cases known to wide public. Just because a system isn't foolproof, doesn't mean it's useless. There are certainly many improvements that can be made to how we protect secrets and conduct investigations into individuals but what we have in place now is far from useless.
- tgragnato 8y ago> When he received a LinkedIn message from a Chinese headhunter. At the beginning I wondered how can the Chinese know who to contact.. On LinkedIn! Then a glimpse at the OPM data breach made my realise that the system might not be useless, but certainly dated and suitable to a very different threat model. It's not easy to update your operating procedures to an information asymmetry at your disadvantage, after decades of advantage in info gathering. Realising that, the top comment starts to make a lot more sense, even if at first sight it's potentially unrelated to the topic: they need to be much more careful about all sorts of things.
- caymanjim 8y agoBecause people who worked for the CIA have resumes too. Do you think they all have cover jobs? Sure, some do, but most people don't. I've worked for a number of defense intelligence agencies. In my case, indirectly via commercial entities, but it's not hard to read between the lines. We dealt with classified information, but the fact that I worked for them isn't classified, and the nature of the projects isn't classified. I put this all on my resume, and so does almost everyone else who works in intelligence. It's just another career.
- tgragnato 8y agoThat's the point. The US has a loose approach. China is aggressive and takes advantage of every weakness. This is not an isolated case, as you will be well aware. https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/state-department-employee-arrested-and-charged-concealing-extensive-contacts-foreign-agents https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/state-department-employee-arr... https://sinosphere.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/04/15/using-china-as-an-example-f-b-i-video-warns-americans-about-study-abroad/ https://sinosphere.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/04/15/using-china-... https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/20/world/asia/china-cia-spies-espionage.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/20/world/asia/china-cia-spie... > "the country’s extensive security apparatus makes it exceptionally hard for Western spy services to develop sources there" That's why I wrote it's an asymmetry.
- darkpuma 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motives_for_spying https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motives_for_spying I don't think anybody here believes that blackmail is the only thing that can motivate somebody to spy.
- lightpuma 8y agoI mean, what would motivate me to betray my country? Considering that "countries" are a naive object of belief to begin with, the premise of the question is qualitatively silly. What's a country, but a manifestation of a military's cumulative threat of violence, organized around, for the most part, language. So lingual zones are the root of most conflict, since animalistic urges find a wall in the inability to express thought beyond the language barrier. But diplomatic channels have long since been forged, and the keys of economic, social, and political interchange have been interlocked for more than half a century since atomic and nuclear annihilation has become well-known and understood. So, to betray a "country" conceptually, as a means of understanding... character? I mean come on. Get real. That's not what any of this is about. Philosophically, social contract theory reveals that this guy was left out in the cold. While kids make millions from goofing off in front of a camera for youtube subscribers, this guy gets jail time for being old. And ain't that something? But, if this is a problem, what's the fix? Pretty much a turkey in every pot. Something that's still not guaranteed, as some of us risk retiring from a life of flipping burgers into a life of eating cat food for dinner, in tenements and hovels, or under bridges and overpasses, in vans down by the river. So we get ghosted. Left out in the cold by youth smartphone leagues, and for what? For being a good boy. For being convenient enough to fold up and fit in your pocket, so as not to be a nuisance, while you search for an appropriate trash receptacle in yet another liminal zone we share together for but a moment while we still live and breath. Ah, there we are. A place to put recyclables. In you go! Wouldn't want to litter! Wouldn't want to pollute! Go quietly to your grave. If starvation is uour fate, so be it, friend.