3 ms·
> SHA, RSA, and AES have caused more harm than good Do you mind elaborating or linking to a useful discussion somewhere? I’m having trouble imagining just what
by jacobolus 16y ago
> SHA, RSA, and AES have caused more harm than good
Do you mind elaborating or linking to a useful discussion somewhere? I’m having trouble imagining just what would be better without these algorithms.
- tptacek 16y agoThink hard about where these algorithms have actually been a user win. Sure, SSL and PGP (though these are both products of the 1990s). Maybe, maybe you could win an argument for SSH --- thought SSH has a really bad track record. What else? Mostly, people who try to use RSA or AES end up like the people at the turn of the last century who ingested radium tonics.
- jacobolus 16y agoOkay, but if they didn’t exist at all, why would we be better off? It’s not like the “people” here would suddenly all start making secure systems.
- tptacek 16y ago* Crypto has made minimal contributions to actual user security for the last 10 years. It's hard to claim crypto "got us through the 2000's" when, for much of that time span, every platform in common use was vulnerable to flaws that ultimately yielded your OS kernel to an attacker. * Meanwhile, most --- literally most --- efforts at deploying crypto have reduced security, by creating new attack surfaces riddled with easily-exploitable flaws. I don't think this is a very tricky argument, although the place it leads you to may feel counterintuitive and wrong.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]