5 ms·
To me this is a story about how financial security impacts national security. It gets me wondering about the mortgage he couldn't pay. What were the terms? How
by Waterluvian 8y ago
To me this is a story about how financial security impacts national security. It gets me wondering about the mortgage he couldn't pay. What were the terms? How out on a limb did he get with his finances?
I doubt this is a fresh argument but it makes me more inclined to see things like mortgage regulations as a national security issue.
- supertrope 8y agoThe Servicemembers Civil Relief Act is probably motivated by debt motivated espionage in addition to being a general benefit for military personnel.
- FakeComments 8y agoHaving a healthy society has always been a national security issue: there’s literally millennia of documents on how governments collapsed because outsiders funded dissidents. These morality lessons we see aimed at societies aren’t mere moralizing — they’re an evolved code of conduct designed to keep a vibrant whole in the face of genuine adversarial conditions. People have forgotten the value of a strong national identity in many Western nations, largely because of the activity of groups funded by outside nations.
- mikeash 8y agoMy understanding is that personal finances are a major consideration when evaluating people for security clearances.
- dx87 8y agoThey are. An officer in charge of me in the military couldn't get his clearance renewed because after the housing bubble popped, he was forced to move to a new duty station. He couldn't afford to pay two mortgages, and couldn't sell his first home for what he owed, so he fell behind on payments and had to do a short sale. The military now provides assisstance where they'll make up the difference in situations like his, but it effectively ended his career in the military since no support system was in place at the time.
- yardie 8y agoWow that is truly fucked.
- HarryHirsch 8y agoThis fellow spent 15+ years in the military, he is out of money, and the country that he served will assist the bankers but not him. He now has not only money reasons to work for a foreign government, he has ideological reasons, too. You can't entrust him with anything confidential. You'd think that the government implemented the mortgage assistance because they couldn't afford to lose too many career military personnel.
- mikeash 8y agoI’m reminded of how being gay was once considered grounds for denying a clearance. Why? Because a foreign government could discover that and threaten to blackmail you with it. What if you’re already out? Doesn’t matter, they could threaten to destroy your career since it would get your clearance revoked!
- yardie 8y agoPrevious reply was missing a lot of context because I was on transport and my stop was coming up. I'm reminded of a similar circumstance of a family member. They bought a home prior to the financial crisis. They were given new orders and had to leave their home. They did manage to rent it but the lease was less than the mortgage and taxes. Their duty change sent them from a cheap southeast home to expensive northwestern apartment. Since that house ended up eating up a good chunk of their housing allowance they could only afford a 1 bedroom apartment for a family of 4. They didn't have to do a short sale, but for 2 years they were just scraping by financially, and mentally. Your officers story just made me remember what he was going through and just how close he could have lost it all.
- CodesInChaos 8y agoFinancial stability is one of the most important criteria checked when you apply for clearance. I read through a public list of the decisions on clearance appeals a couple of years ago, and financial concerns were a very common reason for denied clearances. (Might have been http://ogc.osd.mil/doha/industrial/ http://ogc.osd.mil/doha/industrial/) Another thing I found interesting from that list was that a lot of concerns (e.g. earlier drug consumption) could be successfully addressed, but lying on the questionnaire was pretty close to an absolute no-go. I also expected a lot more denials for political opinion to stop ideologically motivated whistleblowers, but barely found any such entries.
- Swenrekcah 8y agoInteresting, thanks. Regarding the last point, I might add that I would expect any denial that is really based on political ideology to be offically due to anything but.
- dx87 8y agoI think the only politically related questions you get asked are whether or not you've ever been a terrorist, and whether or not you've been a member of or supported an organization that was attempting to violently overthrow the governemnt. You're spot on about drugs though. They really don't care what you did in your past, as long as you don't have a criminal record from it, and you're honest. They just don't want people hiding things that can be used for blackmail.
- yornax 8y agoQ. Hey, guy, you're not a... terrorist, are ya? A. Why, no! Of course not! I would never! Right this way, sir!
- o10449366 8y agoNot for the current administration, apparently. "...Ms. Newbold also asserted that the Trump administration had made changes to security protocols that made it easier for individuals to get clearances. The changes included stopping credit checks on applicants to work in the White House, which she said helps identify if employees of the president could be susceptible to blackmail."[0] [0]: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/01/us/politics/trump-security-clearances.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/01/us/politics/trump-securit...
- acdha 8y agoThere’s definitely a strong angle about irresponsible decisions in this guy’s case but note also that areas like DC are extremely expensive and civil service pay scales have been slipping behind the private sector for decades. Most people react by cashing out to a contractor but there’s always a risk of something more nefarious, and the opposition only needs a few bites.