5 ms·
Math is as far as we can tell a totally universal building kit for anything we want to set up, all the way from elegant models like Newton's laws to billion-par
by whatshisface 8y ago
Math is as far as we can tell a totally universal building kit for anything we want to set up, all the way from elegant models like Newton's laws to billion-parameter monster neural networks. The surprise is not so much the unreasonable effectiveness of math as it is the unreasonable simplicity of fundamental physics.
- elevenoh 8y agoExample of physics' 'unreasonable simplicity'?
- Kurtose 8y agoS = k. log W
- evanb 8y agoEverything but gravity seems exquisitely described, if you look close enough, by 22 parameters.
- thegabriele 8y agoCould you elaborate about the 22 parameters? Are you referring to universal constants or fundamental particles?
- evanb 8y agoThere are 3 generations of 4 fermions, each has a mass. One sets the scale of the theory, meaning we should express all the dimensionful quantities in terms of that mass. So, that gives 11 parameters. Then there are the mixing angles in the CKM matrix. For three generations, that matrix is a 3x3 unitary matrix = 9 parameters. But, we can absorb arbitrary phases into each quark field, but should add one back for the global U(1) phase for 9-6+1 = 4 parameters, 3 mixing angles and 1 CP-violating phase. We're up to 15. We have 3 forces in the Standard Model, each has a gauge coupling. 18. There's the Higgs vev and mass, 20. QCD admits a marginal topological quantity, θ_QCD. As far as anyone knows it's zero to many digits of precision. Still, it's in principle a free parameter of the Standard Model, so 21. Then there's the Planck mass (or equivalently, G), 22, which is the number I remember. I suppose now that we are certain neutrinos have mass I should include the parameters of the PMNS mixing matrix, if you're willing to count them in the Standard Model (they're not in the Glashow-Weinberg-Salaam work, for example). How many free parameters it contains depends on whether neutrinos are Majorana. If they're Dirac, it's 4 parameters (like the CKM matrix), if they're Majorana there are 2 additional CP-violating phases. So, 26 or 28 continuous parameters in the Cosmic Control Booth according to the Standard Model. There's of course discrete kinds of questions you can ask, like "Why is the gauge group SU(3) x SU(2) x U(1)"; I'm not sure how to count such a choice. I think it's fair to ask, "Here's the physical theory with the matter content set, what are the free parameters?".
- matt4077 8y agoPhysics is the poster boy for reductionism, i. e. the ability to split any situation into its parts, understand those, and then reassemble a complete model that actually describes the world. Hence the jokes about spherical chickens (the approach works, but not for chickens). Physics has also taught us to expect absurdly simple laws as the inner workings of seemingly complex observations. e = mcc would feel like a cruel joke on anyone trying to grapple with how reality works pre-Newton. This mindset, and the so obvious wins of physics in its golden age (ca 1900-1970), from the atom bomb to the moon landing, also set unreasonable expectations for the other sciences. Hence, people expected no less than a cure for ageing from the unraveling of the genetic code and the decryption of the human genome. Yet, as it turns out, biology cannot be reduced in the way that physics can. Genetics is a madman’s den of complexity, nonlinearity, and unpredictability. It’s almost literally what you would expect from a few million years of Perl snippets evolving. The same is true of neuroscience, meteorology, sociology, and, to a lesser degree, chemistry.
- cinquemb 8y ago>Yet, as it turns out, biology cannot be reduced in the way that physics can. Genetics is a madman’s den of complexity, nonlinearity, and unpredictability. It’s almost literally what you would expect from a few million years of Perl snippets evolving. The same is true of neuroscience, meteorology, sociology, and, to a lesser degree, chemistry. I would say that we cannot to sufficient degree today (the 0 to 1) that people are expecting from the endless hype, but the mathematics used to describe/locate/correlate brain activity (LCMV beamforming + DSP + MCMC priors), and speeding of the design process of molten salts are getting a lot better/more accessible over time (relying on mathematics from local spin density approximations + gradient density correction theories + UNIFAC).
- denzil_correa 8y ago> Yet, as it turns out, biology cannot be reduced in the way that physics can Most "systems" we have (including physics) are complex, non-linear and dynamic [0]. Some of them are relatively less complex than the others but they are still complex nonetheless. [0] https://www.art-sciencefactory.com/complexity-map_feb09.html https://www.art-sciencefactory.com/complexity-map_feb09.html
- xelxebar 8y agoTo be fair though, even Newton's equations have flaws from a pure mathematical physics standpoint [0]. The problem is that certain classes of initial conditions produce infinities. The obvious case is for particle collisions, where gravitational attraction grows without bound in finite time. However, it turns out that similar infinities can arise even if particles don't collide (cf. Xia 1995). Infinities from colliding particles aren't seen as such a big problem, because they require impossibly precise initial conditions, i.e. the initial conditions sit on a measure-zero set in configuration space. AFAIK, the jury is out on whether we can say the same about non-colliding singularities. It seems reasonable to susept that's the case, but if not then Newtoian gravity alone would be demonstrably broken even in the math. [0]:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Painlev%C3%A9_conjecture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Painlev%C3%A9_conjecture
- dahfizz 8y agoIt seems all of these "problems" arise because you're taking particles to have no volume (point masses). This feels like a garbage in garbage out kind of deal. If your starting assumptions are physically impossible, it's not surprising to get strange results.
- heavenlyblue 8y ago>> It seems all of these "problems" arise because you're taking particles to have no volume (point masses). No, these problems arise, as the parent had said - because those zero-point particles have a non zero probability of occupying the same coordinates if you're simulating their positions using e.g. floating-point variables.
- dahfizz 8y agoThis is a very straightforward consequence of using zero volume point masses.
- Ay_Ay_Ron 8y agoIn your example, floating point numbers are an abstraction for the underlying math which assumes space is continuous. If we're talking about events over a continuous sample space, the probability of two particles being in exactly the same space is identically zero since we can only assign finite probabilities to _intervals_.
- discreteevent 8y agoThe limited, and hence reasonable, effectiveness of mathematics in physics http://arxiv.org/abs/1506.03733 http://arxiv.org/abs/1506.03733
- denzil_correa 8y ago> the unreasonable simplicity of fundamental physics. How do you measure simplicity and how did you come up to the conclusion that fundamental physics was "simple"?
- Sharlin 8y agoWhen physicists (and mathematicians) say a system is simple they usually mean that it exhibits features such as the following: – High degree of symmetry: laws that govern the system are invariant under various transformations – Reducibility: complex entities can be understood as being composed of building blocks governed by a smaller set of rules instead of being irreducible, ”ontologically basic” – Differentiability: the way the system evolves can be modeled using differential equations and other tools of analysis – Low order of approximation: the behavior of the system can be approximated by power series with a small number of terms; higher-order terms converge quickly – Small number of free parameters: the laws of the system do not require a large number of ad-hoc parameters with arbitrary values
- Sharlin 8y agoFor a completely rigorous definition of simplicity, we can introduce the Kolmogorov complexity of an object, defined as the length of the shortest computer program (in some agreed-on encoding) that produces the object as output when run.
- chalst 8y agoMaxwell's equations seem unreasonably simple. But their successor, electroweak interaction, is far more complex. Who knows what complexity an electrostrong theory might hold?
- frutiger 8y agoElectroweak theory does describe more phenomena though. By analogy, Coulomb’s law is simpler than Maxwell’s equations, and describes fewer phenomena. Also, incidentally, Maxwell’s original formulation was very complicated.
- chalst 8y agoThe claim made before is that the description of physics becomes simpler as you go deeper (and deeper means more general). But that seems to have gone into reverse now.
- Iv 8y agoThe philosophical question is how much math describes the universe and how much it describes the things our mind considers understandable.
- adelsk 8y agoTo be fair, physics is only simple, symmetric and nice when considered in the very high or very low energy spectrum. Unfortunately, in the middle physics gets very hard, and all the cool math tools become unusable.