3 ms·
The very first PC hard drives actually used binary sizes, or even slightly more: https://www.pcjs.org/disks/pcx86/drives/ https://www.pcjs.org/disks/pcx86/driv
by userbinator 8y ago
The very first PC hard drives actually used binary sizes, or even slightly more:
https://www.pcjs.org/disks/pcx86/drives/ https://www.pcjs.org/disks/pcx86/drives/
A 5MB drive contains 5326848 bytes, or 5.08 binary megabytes. The 10MB one has exactly twice that, for 10.16 binary megabytes, and the 20MB one has even slightly more than twice, owing to more than doubling the number of cylinders (from 306 to 615), at >20.4 binary megabytes.
I think there must've been some sort of agreement between HDD manufacturers after they settled on decimal sizes, to never again use the binary ones, since otherwise one of them could start creating and advertising drives "now with real gigabytes" or "bonus capacity" to one-up the others --- the difference between a binary and decimal terabyte is 99,511,627,776 bytes, or very nearly the size of a "100GB" drive and definitely not anything like an insignificant rounding error, but in terms of the physical media adding those extra bytes to a drive would probably not be that difficult; a small increase in density, much smaller than that caused by moving to the next highest density (per platter).
- dspillett 8y ago> I think there must've been some sort of agreement between HDD manufacturers after they settled on decimal sizes Agreeing a standard does not necessarily imply evil conspiracy! If you look at the specs of drive that simple quote bytes. The rounded numbers are marketing, as much by the resellers as the manufacturers.