4 ms·
> Historically governments that primarily paid for services by printing money (as opposed to taxes) have rarely, if ever, done so responsibly. In theory it's po
by WorldMaker 8y ago
> Historically governments that primarily paid for services by printing money (as opposed to taxes) have rarely, if ever, done so responsibly. In theory it's possible but MMT lacks the economic pushback caused by taxes.
My understanding is that you and the article here are both missing a concept that most MMT theory flows from taxes. That the "print money to spend" power of MMT is only true when derived from a strong tax policy. The way I've had MMT described to me, in a fiat currency the only inherent value of the currency is its ability to pay taxes to the government. I've heard that tax policy is where MMT sets the value of the dollar (including impacting inflation). It's taxes that keep money moving, which is a critical component to every good version of MMT I've heard (spending isn't useful if it isn't moving after spent).
I've heard it said that the best spending polices under some of the best versions of MMT are those described almost entirely as loans to be recouped entirely by taxes eventually somehow (not always directly in the same person's income tax), and that most of the "magic" in the "print money to spend money" ability is in defining what the tax systems and time horizons are for "recouping" those loans.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoThe problem with that is that, in the US at least, taxes are set by Congress. Apart from the theoretical difficulties with the picture you present, the practical difficulty is that Congress is a dysfunctional, incompetent mess. Do you trust them to actually tax the right amounts, at the right time, to make MMT work? I don't. I expect them to make a total mess of it, and ruin the economy in the process. I don't want them anywhere near monetary policy. I consider any idea that requires them to correctly implement part of it to be doomed, in practice even if not in theory.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Apart from the theoretical difficulties with the picture you present, the practical difficulty is that Congress is a dysfunctional, incompetent mess. Do you trust them to actually tax the right amounts, at the right time, to make MMT work? There's no amount to make MMT work: MMT “works” by explaining that the “fisc”, the finite treasury you have to fill with taxes or borrowing in order to spend, is artifice, a set of unnecessary and misleading complications that comes from treating fiat currency as if it were commodity currency; tax and spending levels have monetary effects, and those are the fundamental constraints. > I don't want them anywhere near monetary policy. MMT tells you this is a self-delusion: “fiscal” policy is fundamentally monetary, and moreover it's powerful monetary policy, which the notional “monetary” authority is denied because of a fictitious distinction. If you want an independent guarantor of sound monetary policy, MMT tells you, great, and you can give them control of the level of a universal stipend and/or a parameter that is part of the definition of the tax rates for all tax brsckets, while leaving Congress to set the distributional policy (who is qualified for the stipend, what the other factors in tax rates are, etc.), and its fine because aggregate levels of spending and taxes are no less monetary policy than interbank interest rates sre.