3 ms·
Again, if your offer includes a stock grant/option/whatever stake that doesn't have the same priority as those owned by the executive team then you need to trea
by olliej 8y ago
Again, if your offer includes a stock grant/option/whatever stake that doesn't have the same priority as those owned by the executive team then you need to treat it as having zero value.
If a company believe its stock is sufficiently valuable to be worth being used as compensation then it shouldn't feel the need to give pre-IPO employees low-priority "equity".
I recognize people argue that you're taking a lower salary because the potential return, but it fails to acknowledge that there is additional risk and cost to the employee:
* the potential to suddenly have no employment or insurance
* vastly inferior insurance and benefits
* significantly reduced job mobility - often this "equity" is surrendered when you leave a company, but that equity is ostensibly to make up for a reduced salary. It's earned income that can be stolen from people who earned it.
The first also has a future cost as well, because subsequent salary negotiations will happen with your prospective employer knowing that you need your job.
So rather than trying to pretend that "equity" justifies a lower salary, employers need to recognize that equity is being granted to compensate for the risk their employees are taking on. The more risky the stock, the more stock needs to be granted - so if the equity is structured to put employees at the end of the spectrum of exercisable equity needs to represent vastly more of the post-investor-payouts equity.
- librish 8y agoI don't understand why you think such black-and-white thinking is needed. The correct thing should be to appropriately discount the options to account for these things instead of saying it's zero. Sure, walking in with the naive approach will lead most people to vastly overvalue options, but I feel like the counter movement you're championing here acts as if no early employee has ever earned money on options no matter the outcome.
- olliej 8y agoAs the amount of risk in the equity increases, the expected value of the equity reduces to zero. So anything that reduces the priority of employee equity vs that of the original employees and investors implicitly increases the risk in addition to the explicit reduction in face value. The real problem to me has been the absurd notion that someone explicitly investing cash is somehow investing more on a dollar for dollar basis than regular employees. * VC or whatever invests a dollar amount: they write a cheque. * Employee invests a dollar amount: Employees at startups are expected to work 80 hours a week, so if we're assuming a regular job is 40 hours a week, then their salary should be twice their regular market rate salary. So in that case, an employee is making an annually recurring investment of (2 * market rate salary - actual salary). In spite of this a VC or whatever gets priority on getting that money back, gets a say in the running of the company, ownership/dollar lower than "equity" grants to employees. The employee gets no voting rights, has a reduced payout priority, and on top of all of that even if the equity grants were equal, the employee is still taking more risk than the cash investors because the company is also their source of employment: if the company fails every one loses their investment, but employees have also lost their jobs. So if anyone should get higher priority for divestment opportunities it should be employees - think of it this way: if you have 10 developers working for 100k, vs. a market rate of 150k, and they're working 80 hours a week, you are looking at a per-employee annual investment of 200k. If you have 10 employees, they are collectively investing $2million a year. That's getting super close to the "big" funding rounds (and for many cases more than) from various startups. In response to the claim that they're not providing cash flow: if you were paying market rates, you would need to find a separate investor to raise cash for twice as many employees, all being paid more. That sounds like they're providing cashflow.
- librish 8y agoThat all startup employees work 80 hour weeks for 50% below market salary is not something I think is true at all. I would like to see a source on that start-up employees (not founders) work significantly longer hours than other tech workers in the area. While I understand your mental math I also think it's a weird way to think about things, because it is very clear going in that working extra hours is not going to give you any extra stake in the company, so any employee who chooses to do so are obviously doing it for other reasons. Finally, $2M (which is for 10 employees in your example, not 1) would be considered a small round today.