5 ms·
It further entrenches Facebook and Google's monopoly on adtech and solves nothing against the companies that people worry about most (and ironically give up the
by manigandham 8y ago
It further entrenches Facebook and Google's monopoly on adtech and solves nothing against the companies that people worry about most (and ironically give up the most data too). It also does nothing to stop the wild-west of mobile app tracking.
The ideal solution would be to offer up the device's Advertising ID to the browser, just like it is available to mobile apps. That would remove all the tracking pixels and workarounds and improve privacy as the user can easily reset their ID whenever they want to.
- saagarjha 8y ago> It further entrenches Facebook and Google's monopoly on adtech How so?
- manigandham 8y agoThey have 1st party connections to their users through both apps and websites and will always know who the person is. ITP does nothing to stop them. Amazon will be the 3rd major adtech company soon and ISPs will also be unaffected as they're starting to build up more adtech businesses themselves. ITP is mostly a PR play for Apple's "privacy" marketing push that again hurts publishers and smaller independent internet companies.
- matt4077 8y agoQuote: „Going a step further, Intelligent Tracking Prevention now also limits long-term tracking for JavaScript first-party cookies.“
- manigandham 8y agoThat means nothing in practice. These companies have the data, reach, and 1st party connection for those cookies to be constantly replaced and augmented with plenty of other signals.
- manigandham 8y agoSince this is downvoted, I'll be extra clear: these companies have websites and network traffic that billions of people use directly which means they can serve HTTP cookies and other signals which are not touched at all by ITP.
- taf2 8y agoWhile also completely ignoring the real issue native apps.
- atticmanatee 8y agoHow can Safari 12.1 impact mobile apps?
- manigandham 8y agoThe point is that mobile apps are 1000x more intrusive than anything on the web (which was always designed for anonymous users). Apple does not do anything to stop mobile apps tracking even with the app store review and the ability to scan them both on submission and as they're running in the OS. Mobile apps are 90% of the source of adfraud and privacy issues on iOS. Meanwhile Mobile Safari (even without ITP) has caused numerous problems with apps trying to offer webviews for content while trying to keep users signed in. There are numerous effective improvements to be made instead of messing with cookies.
- hombre_fatal 8y agoSomewhat aside: After discovering mitmproxy, I checked out various apps on my Macbook. Found plenty that at least phoned home to Google Analytics on boot. Some even phoned on every action/keypress. Not sure why HN has such a hard-on for native/mobile apps. You get performance at the expense of basically everything else. There's no dev toolbar. No extension system. No customization. No uBlock. You take it all or nothing. And you need intrusive tools like mitmproxy or Little Snitch just to get insight into their network traffic.
- kitsunesoba 8y agoNative apps often (not always) get you not just performance, but also efficiency, no annoying browser chrome, adherence to platform UI conventions, and utilization of platform-specific features (no lowest common denominator syndrome). Electron apps can get rid of the browser chrome at least, but it comes with the cost of a redundant copy of Chromium for each app, which is worse than running in-browser in terms of resource consumption. Web apps would be great if they could deliver the things mentioned in the first paragraph on top of their security/privacy benefits, but I don’t see that happening any time soon.
- 8y ago
- jen729w 8y ago> It further entrenches Facebook and Google's monopoly on adtech Just don’t use those sites. I don’t.
- Simon_says 8y agoI don't use those sites either, but a rather large fraction of websites include javascript from Google. You can try to avoid those sites, too, but it's a lesser Internet.
- NetOpWibby 8y agoAnd a better Internet IMO.
- manigandham 8y agoAre you being sarcastic? Or seriously suggesting the billions of users of Google and Facebook should just stop using them? If it was that easy then why all this trouble with ITP in the first place?
- jen729w 8y agoWhy would this be sarcastic? I haven’t used Facebook for about 10 years now. I stopped using Google last year. DDG is great. What’s so hard?
- manigandham 8y ago>> What's so hard? Ah the classic HN comment. The problem is you don't speak for the billions of people use various Facebook and Google services to live their lives without easy alternatives. When someone is using Gmail to run their small business or using Facebook to keep in touch with their distant relatives, I'm sure saying "what's so hard" is all it takes to get them to see the error of their ways.