3 ms·
>>> today because the first sale doctrine protected the video rental business. First sale only applies if the video rental business purchases physical copies.
by sandworm101 8y ago
>>> today because the first sale doctrine protected the video rental business.
First sale only applies if the video rental business purchases physical copies. It is/was not unusual for a large rental business to, rather than buy copies, to license the work for distribution during a particular time/area. That allowed them to burn/build DVDs to meet demand and replaced broken disks as needed. When the license was over, the DVDs were destroyed per the licensing contract.
- bnjms 8y agoThe threat of first sale was still enough to protect the video stores during negotiations so the threat mattered. As an example, I recall hearing Netflix had some early negotiations fail and went to buy disks in stores as an end run.
- skywhopper 8y agoSure, but they only needed that surge in inventory when the rental was in high demand. But a few copies could be purchased outright to remain on the shelves, available to rent for market rates, loyalty discounts, etc, for the lifetime of the media itself. The status quo today is far worse.