4 ms·
If ICE had compelled Motel 6 to hand over the lists, that would be a very different thing and we would be having a very different conversation. But that's not
by gamblor956 8y ago
If ICE had compelled Motel 6 to hand over the lists, that would be a very different thing and we would be having a very different conversation.
But that's not what happened, and let's not pretend like that is what happened.
ICE asked nicely, expecting to be turned down by Motel 6 like most other hotel chains did. But Motel 6 went along with the request without any sort of coercion and in fact in violation of local consumer protection laws prohibiting such data release absent a countervailing legal requirement (such as a subpoena) requiring them to turn over such information.
- shawnz 8y agoHow does a government agent ask you to break the law nicely? ICE could ask me anything as nicely as they want and I'd still feel compelled. They are in an immense position of power over Motel 6 here.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bredren 8y agoDid you watch the video on the wapo article I linked to, and if so, do you think that officer was asking nicely when he spoke to that driver?
- Frondo 8y agoDo we know how ICE asked for these records? Because, from everything else I've ever seen about law enforcement making such requests, there's nothing nice about it, and there's everything coercive about it. And it's a scary kind of coercion because they do have the force of the state backing them up, in a way that plays on our built-in desire to please authority, built-in desire to not rock the boat, and built-in fear of consequences of the crushing weight of the state pummeling down on us. People generally regard law enforcement with a mix of fear and antipathy, because we know that, despite the checks and balances that exist, they can ruin lives and face no consequence for doing so. So when ICE comes and asks, however nicely they may actually phrase it (though I don't expect they said "please" and "thank you,"), they're also coming at these hoteliers with a very big stick. It's just shitty that the hoteliers did, in fact, cave and hand over this data.
- gamblor956 8y agoLet's get this straight guys: If ICE had used any coecion at all to get the guest lists, Motel 6 wouldn't be in trouble with the state of Washington. Motel 6 is in trouble because they violated the law voluntarily. ICE deals with businesses differently than they deal with individuals. You're all imagining scenarios which did not happen.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Do we know how ICE asked for these records? We know that Motel 6 didn't claim their staff were misled into a belief that they were legally compelled, which—even if it wasn't a legal defense, for PR reasons—you'd expect them to do if it was true.
- oasisbob 8y agoThis isn't like it was just people caving to law enforcement in the moment, it was codified Motel 6 policy: > 4.3 ICE's usual practice was to come to Motel 6's reception desk and request the guest list from the receptionist. The receptionist would print out the guest list and give it to the ICE agent, along with a "law enforcement acknowledgment form" for the agent to sign, acknowledging receipt of the guest list. The ICE agent would review the guest list and identify individuals of interest to ICE.
- shawnz 8y agoThis could just mean that it was the management that was pressured and not the receptionists. I just don't see any other reason why they might willingly endanger their business and customers for absolutely no benefit to themselves, besides governmental pressure.
- gamblor956 8y agoPlease do some more research before you keep throwing out hypothetical complaints about something that didn't happen. Motel 6 didn't just go along with ICE's request, per the complaint, Motel6 actually trained their employees to turn over such information even before ICE came calling. The reason? Motel 6 is owned by the Blackstone Group. Most of the directors and executives of the Blackstone Group are die-hard Trump supporters and have espoused hard-line views on immigration. The benefit to themselves was supporting their president's policies.
- rdiddly 8y agoWhen you share your source maybe I'll be as sure as you are.
- gamblor956 8y agoOasisbob shared the civil complaint. It states quite clearly that there was no coercion on ICE's part...moreover that it was Motel 6 that actually directed its employees to just turn over the information. On a related note...the owner of the Motel 6 chain is a die-hard supporter of President Trump and has very conservative views of immigration, which supports the theory that Motel 6 was in the wrong here and ICE was merely taking advantage of their corporate generosity.
- rdiddly 8y agoAha, missed that, thanks.
- oasisbob 8y agoThis is all from the original complaint: https://agportal-s3bucket.s3.amazonaws.com/uploadedfiles/Another/News/Press_Releases/Complaint.Scan2.pdf https://agportal-s3bucket.s3.amazonaws.com/uploadedfiles/Ano... https://www.atg.wa.gov/motel-6-settlement-claim-information https://www.atg.wa.gov/motel-6-settlement-claim-information
- gamblor956 8y agoMotel 6 trained its new employees to follow the practice described above to provide 24 guest lists to ICE agents upon request, without requiring the agents to show any reasonable 25 suspicion, probable cause, or search warrant for the guest registry information.