4 ms·
This is the thing that gets missed is renuables are competing with peaking power which is more expensive than base load power. The way to think of baseload powe
by Gibbon1 8y ago
This is the thing that gets missed is renuables are competing with peaking power which is more expensive than base load power. The way to think of baseload power is it's the lowest quality power source. If you contract for it you have to use it. And it's generated when other consumers don't need it. Which is why it's cheap.
Batteries are competing with very expensive grid stabilization technologies. Solar is selling into the peek daily power cycle.
- 0815test 8y ago> This is the thing that gets missed is renuables are competing with peaking power The other thing that gets missed is that they aren't competing at all, because renewables are unreliable and non-dispatchable. So, more renewables means more peaking power other things being equal. What can directly compete with peaking power is battery storage (though pumped hydro is king there) and demand-response.
- behindmyscreen 8y ago.....woooosh.....
- breakyerself 8y agoRenewable + storage are competing directly with peakers. The storage makes renewables dispatchable and if you look at the performance of the battery in Australia it appears to be much higher performance. The system dispatchs power in a fraction of the time a peaker plant can.
- Scipio_Afri 8y agoTakes a lot less time to throw a switch on what is essentially a capacitor than start a gas turbine, even if its the small peaker gas turbines.
- Retric 8y agoWind and solar are baseload power. Very cheap, but don’t follow the demand curve. That’s a fairly direct replacement for coal and nuclear, it’s just peeking power in we need to deal with. Because they are so cheap wasting some power output each day is simply not as big a deal. The balance point between extra wasted production, storage, and peaking power plants is not obvious or nessisarily stable as prices change.
- the8472 8y agoWind and solar are neither baseload nor peaking power sources. They are intermittent sources where you need other parts of the grid to smooth out the intermittent nature. Either via storage, via peakers or via additional baseload on top and something that consumes the excess that intermittent + baseload can produce. Sun is totally out during the night. And wind is only as much a reliable baseload provider as it will provide during the worst days of the year, which in many locations can be a tiny fraction of their average load factor.
- rossdavidh 8y agoMany good points above, I just wanted to point out that there are lots of places like where I live, where peak electricity is nearly completely correlated with the sun shining (air conditioning). Not that this matters for places where it's not that way, just pointing that out.
- Retric 8y agoThe fact that wind and solar don’t produce steady state power is completely irrelevant. What power companies care about is the difference between the cheap energy sources production and demand. Night time demand is often so much lower than peak demand that it takes less peaking power plants to cover solars night time deficit than coals daytime deficit. PS: The difference between winds minimum expected output and average output is also smaller than most assume. Locations that get more wind at specific times of the day are common and let you tailor supply and demand. Unusually high winds end up wasted, but discarding 5% of output does little to change the relative costs.
- SomewhatLikely 8y agoIf batteries are the enabler, couldn't you just over generate using a cheap base load tech, dumping excess to battery? Or are renewables plus batteries cheaper than base load tech plus batteries?
- Gibbon1 8y agoYeah battery storage is a arbitrage business. Buy cheap sell high. Buy midnight wind from North Texas at three cents a kwh and resell it on a cloudy humid afternoon in Phoenix for thirty. Currently fossil fuel and nuclear power is really cheap late at night. In the future it'll be less predictable but there is absolutely a business there.