3 ms·
So, I'm hedging because I frankly know next to nothing about WireGuard. It's clear you know a lot more. But, without knowing more details, I can't really say if
by steveklabnik 8y ago
So, I'm hedging because I frankly know next to nothing about WireGuard. It's clear you know a lot more. But, without knowing more details, I can't really say if it's good or bad.
> then rolled it out as a proprietary offering that WireGuard itself is not allowed to connect to.
So, I said this in the link, but the implementation of the protocol itself is, as Zack said, fully open source. To me, that's the high order bit here. And as I said on the reddit thread, it appears from the outside that this is more of a support issue than anything else. Maybe that's a lie, but I'm inclined to take jgc at his word.
On working with upstream, what they said publicly is this: https://blog.cloudflare.com/boringtun-userspace-wireguard-rust/#comment-4401651800 https://blog.cloudflare.com/boringtun-userspace-wireguard-ru...
> We communicated with Jason throughout the process and have a ton of respect for him and the entire WireGuard community. In the short term, we need the flexibility to quickly update BoringTun's code base to support the project we built it for. That's harder when you need to coordinate with people outside Cloudflare and when we need to move as fast as we plan to. However, we really believe in Open Source and want the WireGuard community to thrive. We licensed the code very openly (3-paragraph BSD) and WireGuard may choose to fork it. If they do, we'll support it and plan to contribute any improvements in our own fork back. Over the long term, I think we're very open to merging this back into the upstream project.
This seems very reasonable to me. YMMV. I have no idea what requirements would cause this friction at the moment, but peeking at https://www.wireguard.com/#contributing https://www.wireguard.com/#contributing it looks like they do the "non-GitHub server + mailing list" for development. I mean, I'm literally wearing a GitHub hoodie, but I know that I personally prefer the GitHub workflow to the point where if doing work via that system were an upstream requirement, I'd probably do my own thing on GitHub too.
Basically, it may be good, it may be bad. I don't have enough information to really pass judgement.
- tptacek 8y agoHold on, you had no trouble judging whether it was good or bad on that Reddit thread. And, in case the subtext isn't clear: you've been at Cloud Flare for like, a minute. And as you said downthread: this is what you do: you advocate and evangelize. So this seems like pretty legitimate grist for discussion. Are you comfortable with your advocacy here, or having second thoughts about it? :gif_of_homer_simpson_backing_slowly_into_the_hedge: is a totally legit response to this whole situation, for what it's worth. (I'll reiterate: it would be amusing if your employer just smote me where I stand by revealing the large donation they've made to Jason's project).
- steveklabnik 8y ago> So this seems like pretty legitimate grist for discussion. Are you comfortable with your advocacy here, or having second thoughts about it? My job isn't to be a PR person for everything Cloudflare does. Cloudflare has and does things I disagree with. It's a company with a lot of people working there, after all :) All of this stuff is completely outside of what is going to be my job. And a job I haven't even started yet! I mean, sure, it's legitimate to talk about like anything is, but if you want to know what's going on, I'm certainly not the person to talk to about it.
- tptacek 8y ago... right! I agree! So, again: why were you volunteering opinions about the norms-compliance of this Cloud Flare project on Reddit, rather than just saying, "huh, no idea, wasn't involved"?
- steveklabnik 8y agoBecause, while it's a personal thing I am working on, I haven't yet totally learned to not write paragraphs of text when someone asks me a question. I'll get there :) I'll save this thread as a reminder for next time I'm tempted ;)
- tptacek 8y agoTotally legit response. Thanks!