2 ms·
Evolutionary processes aren't magic, they can only move along gradients defined by small changes. If it can be shown that these bacteria have something so radic
by jerf 16y ago
Evolutionary processes aren't magic, they can only move along gradients defined by small changes. If it can be shown that these bacteria have something so radically different that it couldn't possibly have gotten there by small changes, such as by having a biology with no resemblance to DNA/RNA as we know it, then I'll have to accept a second origin.
However, if these things were just discovered I find it unlikely these have been analyzed to the point that we can be conclusive about it. Historically speaking people have tended to get radically more excited about this sort of thing than they have scientific justification for, for a variety of reasons. The full answer will probably take longer, unless they've been successfully sitting on this for a rather long time. A slow process of swapping in arsenic for phosphorus might cover it and leave something superficially distinct from modern life but still clearly descended from it.