7 ms·
California now has more than 1,300 charter schools – Alt.Ed gone bad
- duxup 8y agoThere doesn't seem to be a real market type motivator to encourage charter schools to operate legitimately. I'm sure many do operate legitimately, but just hoping the proprietors do so and then expecting local school districts to dedicate resources to police them (something that is far outside their core competency) seems like a recipe for things going sideways.
- nostrademons 8y agoThe check on charter schools is that if they provide a bad education, the students will leave. If they create a bad working environment for teachers, the teachers will leave. The latter actually seems to have checked the subject of the article effectively: teacher turnover was high, and the teachers profiled here both ultimately did leave.
- kartan 8y ago> The check on charter schools is that if they provide a bad education, the students will leave. It sound estrange for me. But, I think that you are right that this is the intention. Are the kids responsibility to evaluate the validity of the education system? Aren't they just kids that are in school to learn the most basic stuff? There is a reason why kids are not legally adults. And it is their lack of maturity and experience to take decisions. > If they create a bad working environment for teachers, the teachers will leave. The latter actually seems to have checked the subject of the article effectively: teacher turnover was high, and the teachers profiled here both ultimately did leave. It is interesting that the adults where the ones actually leaving.
- nostrademons 8y agoKids know when they're not getting a good education - it usually comes out in unexplained bad behavior, withdrawal, refusal to do the work because it's bullshit, etc. If you're lucky they might even tell you as such. It's up to the adults in their life to listen.
- bobthepanda 8y agoThe problem is that kids don’t really get catch up time to learn more at their grade level, and switching schools comes at huge cost (costs of applying, costs of transferring schools, arranging new transportation, shifting schedules around, the child losing their existing social networks etc.)
- nostrademons 8y agoI know - I switched schools (from public to charter) in 8th grade. It was a drastic move (particularly since the new school was 23 miles away and so it meant I had to be driven 45 minutes to see any of my new friends), but well worth it - IMHO it literally saved my life. Usually if someone is thinking of switching schools catching up is the least of their concerns, because they're not learning anything anyway in their current situation.
- bobthepanda 8y agoI guess what I'm saying is that applying the market to schools is suboptimal, because the market "correcting" means you've fucked up one year's worth of schooling for a bunch of kids, and it's not something that is easy to recover from.
- nostrademons 8y agoThat's the case with all market "corrections", though - when the stock market corrects people can lose their life savings, when the mainframe market corrects skilled professionals lose their whole careers, when the coal market corrects whole towns find themselves in poverty. What I'm saying is that without that market correction, the consequences are worse: instead of fucking up one year's worth of schooling (which is not easy to recover from), you fuck up 12 years worth of schooling (which is impossible to recover from). And that is actually the status quo right now - there are large swaths of America that are essentially unemployable because they are lacking basic skills needed for today's economy.
- 8y ago
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoStudents aren't the customers, they don't write the checks and make the decisions. A charter school can provide a bad education and convince parents to fund them anyways - touting religious stuff seems like the easiest path for this.
- mwfunk 8y agoIn fact, what most people would consider "a bad education" in some cases might even be the parents' reason for putting their kids in such a school to begin with. Like, they'd really rather homeschool them for religious or tribal indoctrination reasons, but for whatever reason they can't, so a charter school might be the next best thing to them.
- nostrademons 8y agoThere's a principal-agent problem with all parenting: you're making decisions on behalf of another human being and hoping that those decisions line up with the best interests and wishes of the person in question. Obviously this isn't always the case, but both common sense and Western legal traditions assume that the parent's interests will be most closely aligned with their child, and that they're better suited to make those decisions than a bureaucrat, a CEO, or even a teacher. Societies that assume the state is better qualified to make decisions on behalf of children than the parents are have gone to dark places.
- SilasX 8y agoThe same is true of regular public schools though, with predictable results.
- AceyMan 8y agoMods— why is the title completely rewritten? The source article is titled, "How a couple worked charter school regulations to make millions." My son is having a great experience at a well-run LA charter school and the current headline seems in violation of HN rules. [edit; now flagged tfa]
- TimTheTinker 8y agoFYI - the best way to get mod attention is to flag the article.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoI changed the title because the title seemed to be click baity and a personal attack. I didn’t want the discussion to be about the couple but about charter schools.
- TimTheTinker 8y ago"Alt.Ed gone bad"? That's far more of an attack (and clickbait) than the article's title. As for discussion, nothing wrong with posting your opinion in the comments -- we all can discuss.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoHi...So, if you read the article, it does talk about how charter schools in CA are managed and how extensive govt involvement is and how there is no oversight. So I still stand by my title. Maybe I could add ‘California’ (if I have enough words left) but otherwise I am comfortable with my choice of words for change in title. Eta: looks like I can’t edit it now.
- AceyMan 8y agoI read the article (well, 75% so far). It's primarily how this couple gamed the system; I don't see that it casts the LAUSD policy or leaders in a bad light. We all know any sufficiently byzantine bureaucracy can be gamed by motivated players. Such is the case here, it seems. Contrast with my son's school: it's well-run, has strong leadership and wonderful teachers ... and they still have to work hard, year over year, to stay right with the LAUSD policies. Tl;dr This story isn't about charter schools so much as it is a public outing of the weirdo couple who runs (and profits from) one specific charter in the LA system.
- ArtDev 8y agoCharter schools are vastly superior with only one exception: school districts like to keep them underfunded. Which is absurd considering how much better they are in every way. Both my kids go to charter schools.
- excitom 8y agoOh, where do I start. Let's trade anecdotes. One of my children went to a charter school and my experience is the opposite of yours.
- TimTheTinker 8y agoCharter schools live or die on their own merits, which means (a) they're likely to be more variable in terms of quality than public schools, and (b) the best charter schools will far exceed public schools in quality. As long as we're trading anecdotes, the charter schools I know of near me are extremely high quality. Several kids I know attend some of them, and their experience has been phenomenal. Why not institute whatever's necessary to weed out those that are abusing the system (i.e. embezzling, failing to educate, etc.), and give people the freedom to decide on the rest? I suspect a lot of the attacks on charter schools are coming from folks who view education primarily as a means of propagating their political viewpoints.
- excitom 8y agoI don't necessarily agree with your (b) but I'll concede it if you agree to a (c) the worst charter schools can fall far short of public schools on quality ... in agreement with your point (a). Just read the linked LA Times article to see what I mean.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoIt’s still funded by Big Gov and doesn’t have oversight. And whatever is necessary to be implemented isn’t and hence it’s an effort gone bad. The article is pretty extensive about the issues of CA charter schools.