15 ms·
>In this case, the demand is “the ability to express myself to a huge audience.” People are willing to pay to do that. Because of that, they see any job where t
by slg 8y ago
>In this case, the demand is “the ability to express myself to a huge audience.” People are willing to pay to do that. Because of that, they see any job where they get to do it as a net positive, even if the job is horrible.
This is true for any job that is just an extension of a hobby. People put on local community theater productions in their spare time because they find it fun and fulfilling. You don't have to pay people to do that, so the pay for people to do it professionally would naturally be low in a free market system.
Do you know another profession like that? Software development. People spend countless hours working on open source software for free just because they like it. The open source community saves businesses billions in labor costs every year. Would anyone suggest we get rid of the open source community so developers could be better compensated? We are just lucky enough that the global demand for general software development is much
higher than the demand for video game development or theater/TV/movies that it can offset these other factors.
- adrianhel 8y agoAnd the type of software people make for free is not the same software people get paid to create. I bet few people would be eager to develop banking software on their free time for instance.
- cheez 8y agoSomething something Satoshi
- sokoloff 8y agoThere's a lot more overlap than I'd have predicted 30 years ago. There are very good open source databases, content management systems, web servers, full text corpus search systems, operating systems, and 100s of other "kind of boring" things that a 20 year old version of me would assume people would need to be paid to create. (Some of those are a crossover where a substantial portion of the development was originally paid, of course, but many others are not.)
- archgoon 8y agoPeople would not want to build banking software for a specific company; however, if banks were to describe their problems in a sufficiently well defined way, people would cheerfully build various 'bank frameworks' for free. Some college student would happily have it on their resume. This of course would have to have banks be more open about how they operate, so it probably won't happen. This is to say, it's not really the type of software that is the issue, but rather lack of openness about the problem domain.
- ghaff 8y agoMight be starting to happen more than you think. AMQP (messaging) came out of JPMC and other financial institutions Financial institutions are also involved in blockchain projects Another random example: https://developer.capitalone.com/open-source/ https://developer.capitalone.com/open-source/
- indigochill 8y agoAlso Goldman Sachs just announced they'd be releasing some additional software on Github: https://www.fnlondon.com/articles/goldmans-trading-floor-is-going-open-source-sort-of-20190404 https://www.fnlondon.com/articles/goldmans-trading-floor-is-...
- dspillett 8y ago> This of course would have to have banks be more open about how they operate, As someone for whom the day job involves working on projects for investment banks and other regulated industries, I'd say this is not the first problem that needs to be solved. > if banks were to describe their problems in a sufficiently well defined way THIS is often the problem. They often don't know exactly what they want. Well, many people in the company think know what is needed/wanted but most of them don't agree with each other (and if they do they probably don't agree on priorities) beyond the rules set by the regulators (which are usually deliberately "non prescriptive", which is to say "vague"). They often have long lists of what they don't want, but no proper specification of what they do want. The larger organisations are often so siloed that the left hand doesn't know which foot the right hand is pointing a gun at and no one really knows which elbow they are collectivly sat on. When a project to clean things up starts it is usually populated by people seconded from elsewhere who either still have that job to do so can't commit themselves to the matter in the concentrated way required to deal with it properly, or are not close enough to the problem to have a full understanding of the nitty-gritty details and the interactions between those details. And sometimes those details are very difficult to find until they bite you due to the amount of legacy systems these groups have dotted around, especially in cases where organisations have formed from many mergers & acquisitions over the years. They don't want to openly share this state because it would be a public embarrassment. Of course, it is hardly a well-kept secret: they all know what state each other are in, as do those of us slowly trying to fix it and the consultants (internal and external to the organisations) making piles out of part-way fixing it (often by reinventing the problem space in new and expensively interesting ways!). But still they don't want it to be any more an open secret than can be avoided. I assume large organisations in other industries are similarly afflicted. It is human nature (we often don't individually know exactly what we want) magnified by scale. "It can't be that hard, can it?" you would be forgiven for asking. "Oh, but it can", I assure you! As others have pointed out elsewhere in the thread: things are improving, particularly in specific areas where new ideas are forcing, or at least allowing, more radical rethinks. But overall it'll be a complete mess for some time to come.
- excalibur 8y ago> I bet few people would be eager to develop banking software on their free time for instance. If a bank found someone who was eager to develop its software for free, it would have a pretty good reason to question their motives.
- mobiuscog 8y agoIt's not about creating the software, so much as supporting it.
- bena 8y agoThe way I look at it is that my employer isn't paying me to "make X", they're paying me so I'm not doing anything else.
- hevi_jos 8y agoI bet lots of people will contribute to open source banking software if creating a bank were not extremely regulated so creating public open source bank were legal. In that case, banking software would be very useful for the community and people will help. The fact that something is boring has nothing to do with it. There are few things as boring as developing operating systems like Hurd or developing Wayland and dealing all day with bugs and bugs and more bugs. Of course, people is not going to create banking software if the only ones who benefit are private companies that give nothing in return. There must be a good reason. Something that provides the sense of deep meaning for your work. Working for free so a private company could profit out of your work does not.
- ghaff 8y agoSee also photography, writing, art, etc. Some professionals are in fact resentful to greater or lesser degrees of amateurs willing to work for free (either just for fun or because it's useful to them professionally for reputational or other reasons). I asked a journalist I knew whether he minded the fact that people like myself publish articles/blogs for free in publications that also have paid staff/freelancers. His response was basically "That ship sailed long ago." But there are definitely people who feel more strongly that people having "fun" are taking food off their family's plate.
- lacey 8y agoI’m a photographer by hobby and you very often see people wanting to hire someone good but who isn’t expecting to make a living at it with offers like “I’ll let you shoot my event to help build your portfolio, and all you have to do is give me a copy of all the photos.” Or alternatively offering something like $100 for four hours to do lifestyle street shoots. I don’t know how often they are successful at getting photographers for these types of things but I know that if I were going to shoot for those kinds of wages I would rather donate my time to a charity that I support.
- ghaff 8y ago"For the exposure/to build your portfolio." Uggh. To be clear, I sometimes shoot events for free as a favor. And I sometimes shoot concerts or sporting events just because I feel like it. And if you find my photos on Flickr I'll probably give you permission to use them for free. (Though if you want to pay me, that's fine too and I do sometimes get annoyed with the presumption that I'm not going to ask for a fee.) But I'm probably not going to take you up on a minimum wage offer unless it were something I was going to do anyway.
- jackfraser 8y agoDo you _really_ think your photography job deserves the same hourly wage as an engineer or manager?
- vharuck 8y ago> People spend countless hours working on open source software for free just because they like it. Some people create or contribute as part of their job. If the job requires new software, the company doesn't want to sell the software, and the developer thinks others could use it, then why not open source?
- slg 8y agoBecause open sourcing that code is taking work away from future software developers. The second company which needs that software would otherwise have to pay employees to build it or purchase it from third party software developers. The person open sourcing the software is therefore lowering the global demand for software developers which hurts the wages of all software developers. For the record, I don't think this means we should abandon open source software. I simply thought it was a good analogy to illustrate why OP's argument was flawed and that we shouldn't be blaming people for taking these "terrible jobs".
- sokoloff 8y agoWhen I walk by a window and don't break it, am I taking work away from glaziers?
- slg 8y agoThat is stronger language than I would use, but yes you declined an opportunity to increase the demand for glaziers. I imagine your are trying to allude to the glazier's fallacy [1]. However that is only a fallacy from the perspective of the entire economy. An extra dollar spent on a glazier is going to benefit the glazier. The problem for the economy at large is that the dollar might have otherwise been spent on the tailor, baker, etc. To take this back to software development, the glazier fallacy is why I am not against open source software. The overall economy is made more efficient from it. However that doesn't change the fact that the increase in efficiency comes from not having to pay more money to software developers. That isn't great if you view the situation purely from the perspective of a (selfish) software developer. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window
- watwut 8y agoMajority of open source developers are paid or work jobs that gives them a lot of free time. Foss runs yearly polls to determine that.
- nostrademons 8y agoThe way I usually put it is "I'll happily code for free, but if you want me to code up your ideas, you have to pay me more than all the other folks that want me to code up theirs." Interestingly this holds up even though I'm now coding up my own ideas - even though I'm calling the shots on what I work on, they're still constrained by what there's potentially a market for, and so it's still not really passion coding. If I were completely free of constraints, I'd do stuff that's more useless, more prestigious, more beautiful, with fewer corner cases and fewer dependencies on outside software. That's economically unviable (and kinda solipsistic, too), so I don't.
- ido 8y agoIt works that way for me too. I’m (among other things) a game developer, and a few years ago someone asked me how much it’ll cost to make a game for them after looking my name up from one of the games I’ve made. I gave them a quote without thinking too much (“$100/h, maybe a bit less if it’s something really interesting”[0]) and they were shocked, saying something like “I didn’t think you made that much money from these games!”. Well, if I did I wouldn’t be taking on contract work to begin with but you’re not getting the same rate as my own projects :) [0] these days it would be more like $150/h.