3 ms·
> Point them to a study like this, and you're met with "Nuh-uh! Not valid! Nope!" Are they really saying that or did they point out the small sample size, age
by acdha 8y ago
> Point them to a study like this, and you're met with "Nuh-uh! Not valid! Nope!"
Are they really saying that or did they point out the small sample size, age of the study, inconsistent preparation of the participants, and ask about whether it had been replicated? I mean, the authors themselves acknowledge this and it'd be interesting to know how they would view it a couple of decades later, especially since there have been huge improvements across the board in languages and things like quality of tooling, availability of documentation, etc.
Unfortunately, the way you chose to start that post sounded like you were assuming that any position which didn't support your favorite language couldn't be correct. I think that's just as unproductive as the sentiment you complained about, especially because one of the big trends over the last couple of decades has been appreciation for the exact concepts you quoted in other languages. People are writing more functional-styled code than ever before so it seems more likely that extremely complex and important decisions like choice of programming language aren't driven by a single purity test.