5 ms·
The only one we for sure is in the wrong is Yelp, because they are letting people who have never been customers post bad reviews.
by Alex3917 16y ago
The only one we for sure is in the wrong is Yelp, because they are letting people who have never been customers post bad reviews.
- ceejayoz 16y agoHow on earth could you expect Yelp to automatically catch that?
- smackfu 16y agoThey do actually filter reviews automatically using some secret algorithm.
- ceejayoz 16y agoFrom what I've heard, that algorithm is essentially if($customer->has_paid && $review->score < 4) { delete_review(); }
- kls 16y agoEven though you jest, I have to agree. I really wish Google would buy out Yelp or would enter into direct competition. They would bring a level of credibility to an even playing fields for all parties involved. There are no many companies that carry around the kind of credibility needed to asway all concerns that people are not buying there way out of reviews.
- kls 16y agoDon't know why I got down-voted on this one, it is a serious concern. Yelp credibility in providing a level playing field has come into question on more than one occasion. Like it or not, Google brings a level of credibility to the table. When disagreeing with someones position please refrain from using the down-vote button for "I disagree" when a simple rebuttal would suffice.
- Splines 16y agoAt some stores I've been given a receipt with a code on it that I can use for giving customer feedback. Plus, there's an incentive of entering a contest if you give them feedback. Seems like the right sort of solution to me. Random example: http://mfisurvey.marketforce.com/raisingcanes/ http://mfisurvey.marketforce.com/raisingcanes/
- ceejayoz 16y agoThat can still easily be gamed. "Oh, sorry, the receipt printer is out of order today, Mr. Pissed Customer!"
- Avenger42 16y agoTrue, but if the corporate office notices that one store almost never has any reviews posted, or notices that their sponsored site (with the receipt codes) has a store getting 5-star reviews (indicating that the receipts are only being given out to people likely to be positive), while a non-sponsored site has markedly lower scores, then you'd probably look into what's going on there. And the best way to figure out how a store is actually doing is still to go there and see for yourself.
- mkramlich 16y agoExactly. And if Yelp can't guarantee that a poster truly has been a customer of said business they are reviewing, then perhaps they should not be allowed to post it. Otherwise it opens the gates to what is effectively blackmail and lynch mobbing.