4 ms·
This technology is fundamentally non-scalable because it relies on potassium hydroxide chemistry to sequester CO2. Let me explain: Potassium hydroxide (KOH) is
by jandrewrogers 8y ago
This technology is fundamentally non-scalable because it relies on potassium hydroxide chemistry to sequester CO2. Let me explain:
Potassium hydroxide (KOH) is manufactured by electrolysis, which is electrical power intensive. The amount of KOH manufactured every year is a microscopic fraction of the total CO2 emitted every year. Scaling this up to the same scale as CO2 production isn't simply a matter of building more KOH factories: the implied vast electrical power generation capacity and infrastructure simply doesn't exist at this scale. You would need to build massive power plants along side your KOH manufacturing. This is the kind of thing that only works when you have access to cheap excess hydropower.
And this ignores the secondary issue of scaling potassium supply sufficient to support throughput at CO2 scales, even with recycling. Potassium is a mined mineral with limited reserves that is critical for agriculture. Reliable access to mined potassium is already a major concern for food security and this would require increasing the rate of mining (and depletion) of potassium reserves many-fold. No one is going to care if we've reduced atmospheric CO2 if billions are starving to death.
tl;dr: This CO2 extraction process has severe practical limits to its industrial scalability. Its feasibility relies on leveraging the excess capacity of existing industrial processes, which is only possible at tiny scales for use as a point solution.
Atmospheric CO2 sequestration is a bitch. The thermodynamics and chemistry rate limiters are extremely unfavorable to an economical engineered solution. Fortunately, the planet has a prodigious background sequestration rate that can be leveraged for free if human CO2 production is reduced sufficiently.
- raverbashing 8y agoHence the question is: why can't they use NaOH which is much cheaper and easier to get?
- jandrewrogers 8y agoNaOH manufacturing is electrolytic just like KOH, and is similarly limited by power generation. As to why they can't use NaOH, NaOH being a cheaper material does not imply a cheaper process -- reaction rates matter to amortized unit costs. For example, the reaction rate of KOH is almost certainly much higher than the reaction rate of NaOH, which means it requires much less physical plant/material per unit of sequestration throughput. This plant cost savings could easily offset the lower material costs of NaOH. If it actually made sense to use NaOH, the designers of this process would have used it.
- Brakenshire 8y agoNaOH would at least be scalable though. So if they did manage to reduce the price it could play a part.
- jandrewrogers 8y agoNaOH is not scalable either. It doesn't address the core industrial scaling issue at all, which is the same for sodium and potassium, nor where we will find terawatts of available power generation. There is several trillion dollars in hidden CapEx baked into the idea that we can sequester atmospheric CO2 using this method before we even get to the direct costs. It assumes infrastructure that doesn't exist being built at mindboggling scales. To actively sequester atmospheric CO2 at net negative rate on a time frame of several decades would require $10T per year by their own numbers at their current cost using potassium and assuming the industrial infrastructure already existed. Using sodium would greatly increase this price tag, making it even less probable. There is no getting around those cold hard numbers. The fundamental thermodynamics makes it impossible, even ignoring the industrial scaling problem, to reduce the cost per ton to a level that is remotely economically plausible.