3 ms·
The lack of second order thinking seems to be the essence of what ails modern medicine. "I have an infection!" "Time for antibiotics!" Don't bother to ask "A
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
The lack of second order thinking seems to be the essence of what ails modern medicine.
"I have an infection!"
"Time for antibiotics!"
Don't bother to ask "And then what?"
Some populations are given antibiotics so regularly that it isn't uncommon for them to develop antibiotic resistant infections and even lose their colon to E. Coli.
We are given drugs with a multi page handout covering side effects, the doctors take credit for short term improvement -- "Look! Your latest infection got better!" -- then blame your condition for long term decline. No one stops to wonder if it's the drugs -- even though in some cases we absolutely know the drugs caused X.
- mschuller 8y agoSecond order thinking was thought further by Hans Jonas [1], a philosopher known for his contribution to environmentalism. In his book "The Imperative of Responsibility"[2] he argues that because of our technological breakthroughs (e.g. medicine) it's so easy to make impacts beyond your control that thinking through whatever you do has to become the core of a new ethic. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans_Jonas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans_Jonas [2] https://www.press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/I/bo5953283.html https://www.press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/I/bo59...
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI'm an environmental studies major. It's been very helpful in trying to develop mental models for thinking about my health issues.
- Pamar 8y agoThis is interesting: can you provide some examples?
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI've had a class in Hydrology and also read "Salt Dreams" (about water in Southern California) and a book about the history of water development in Fresno County. Modern people often seem to have mental models of the world where a river has a set place, similar to a road. This is not accurate. Water percolates down into the soil. Rivers meander. The amount and type of plants impacts rain patterns. Water is constantly moving and cycles through the air and moves through the ground, both largely invisible to the naked eye, but critical to the pieces we can readily see. Plus, its movement occurs in a larger context, such as the Moon causing ocean tides. The human body's relationship to water is similar. It isn't just limited to how much you drink, how much you sweat and how much you pee. Like the Earth's crust, your skin takes in water. aso, for example, you can get hydrated with a bath, especially a salt water bath. This is helpful to understand if you are so sick that you are having trouble taking anything by mouth. My condition predisposes me to retain fluids. I've made progress on reducing the chronic bloat in part because I have mental models for how water moves through the environment. Invasive species disrupt ecosystems. This is not unlike infection. Trying to fix a thing like that is far more complicated than our current medical mental model of just giving out antibiotics for infection. On some island, someone wanted to eradicate mosquitoes. They poisoned the mosquitoes, which all died. Small animals ate they poisoned mosquitoes and they died too. This went through several layers, almost like the Biblical plagues (deconstructed and analyzed by modern science on some TV show). Those sorts of things influence my concept of the body's relationship to disease. I don't accept the mental model that "Well, just add antibiotics to the mix and voila! All better now!" We know antibiotics kill gut flora. We know gut flora are critical to our digestion and even help provide certain nutrients. We know that killing gut flora not only screws up digestion, it also promotes the overgrowth of Invaders like E. Coli. Yet we currently do not have a policy of making sure to remediate what antibiotics do to the body. We assume the gut will just repair itself over time without active intervention. Some individuals know to at least eat yogurt, but doctors do not give out handouts with recommendations for "The Post Antibiotics Diet." And then we kind of shrug if someone "mysteriously" develops serious and chronic gut issues. Broader society also seems to fail to understand the gut as the foundation of the immune system.
- pryce 8y agoA significant amount of medical academia is definitely concerned with upstream causes, especially since a great deal of overall mortality these days is from cancers and heart disease, where impeding the upstream causes can have a large affect on overall mortality rates. This in some ways contrasts with a perspective where people fall ill primarily to infections and it is primarily the role of medicine to identify and cure those. Even when an upstream cause for an issue is infective, (for example the young adult deaths from Rhuematic Fever in my country, New Zealand), there are many further upstream causes such as the level of insulation in housing, socioeconomic deprivation, the level of access to primary care physicians, access to transport, etc. A crucial issue is whether the healthcare and economic system are geared to encourage or discourage addressing the most strongly associated upstream causes that are identified. In countries with established government-funded healthcare systems, options like public health campaigns and legislation are considered as tools that can potentially be brought to bear on these issues. In other countries where government-funded healthcare is not a norm, these options are less emphasised. In a system oriented towards private healthcare, often the approach leans more reactive than proactive, eg likely to be initiated as the response to a costly court ruling.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThere is a lot of interesting research these days. I'm quite interested in microbiome articles, among other things. But the practice of medicine has changed within my lifetime from doctors being purveyors of wisdom to doctors being technicians with fancy testing apparatus and, all too often, insufficient context. Doctors used to be some of the best educated people in a community and you tended to see the same doctor for many years. They probably also saw your extended family. It wasn't uncommon for all the children and their cousins to be seen and treated at the same time, thereby putting a stop to an infection instead of it being passed round and round like seems to be fairly common these days. I'm quite fond of this scene from Doc Hollywood: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xMjEmE1YLSU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xMjEmE1YLSU
- toomuchequate 8y agoI thought it was the 300,000,000 dollars the American Medical Association has contributed to politicians.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoNot just modern medicine. Most government programs originate out of first order thinking. Most corporate plans, too, for that matter.
- dTal 8y agoOr if someone is an overweight, depressed shut-in, the treatment will be antidepressants and gastric bypass - when what they really need is a therapist/PT/buddy who plays sports and drags them out of the house to play squash. The medical system is not currently equipped to handle solutions like that. The inability to account for second-order effects seems to be a chronic failure of the large-scale systems we build. I wonder if it's because specialization means that nobody understands or is in charge of the big picture. A old-fashioned generalist "village doctor" would understand the context of your existence because they were also in your social circle, while a modern GP's role in your life is highly abstracted. Or take capitalism - if you're mono-focused on making Widgets, then you neither know nor care that Widgets are causing trouble somewhere else in the world, and you will fight viciously against anyone telling you to make fewer Widgets.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoIn tribal culture, a Medicine Man is both a spiritual role and a medical role. There is no separation of your physical health from the larger picture of your life. Even in modern medicine, physicians were historically de facto "village wise men." They largely have abandoned that role these days and it frequently goes bad places.