4 ms·
I think the issue is the difference between the force needed to trim the aircraft and the acceptable control gain between the yoke and the elevator. I think wit
by Gibbon1 8y ago
I think the issue is the difference between the force needed to trim the aircraft and the acceptable control gain between the yoke and the elevator. I think with light aircraft trim is what you think of it. Slightly centers the yoke so the aircraft will fly level without control input.
I think what's going on with the 737-MAX is the needed trim is way beyond what's needed to fly the plane.
I'm now wondering is the MACS is needed because the tendency to pitch up also exceeds the pilots control inputs which is why it had to be on the elevator and have that much authority. Meaning once the aircraft pitches up the pilot doesn't have enough authority to push the nose back down.
- linuxftw 8y ago> Meaning once the aircraft pitches up the pilot doesn't have enough authority to push the nose back down. Or, alternatively, the pitch up happens so quickly and severely the risk of stall is too great above a certain AoA and the pilot won't have adequate time to respond. If either is the case, it implies the aircraft is not safe to fly without MCAS operational, and possibly not at all.
- rootusrootus 8y agoMCAS is not an emergency system, it is a trim control system designed to make the plane behave predictably in an otherwise unstable flight regime. If you wanted it to move fast, you would use a stick pusher; moving the trim takes many seconds.