10 ms·
eSports at this level reminds me of the old circus/carnival freak shows, except the circus put naturally occuring freaks on display, whereas eSports participant
by gowld 8y ago
eSports at this level reminds me of the old circus/carnival freak shows, except the circus put naturally occuring freaks on display, whereas eSports participants transform themselves into freaks -- 60 hours a week of playing a videogame into its extreme corner cases, developing hyperspecific skills to an extreme level that have zero transferability or relevance outside the game.
- skrebbel 8y agoYou just described all pro sports
- sureste 8y agoThis sounds very narrow minded. What you are saying is no different than any other traditional sport. Take ice hockey goalies. In recent years they've become more athletic to the point that their bodies do things that non-goalies can't. How is that skill relevant or transferable outside of the game? Name a position in any sport and there will be close to zero relevance to the real world. Even chess, what I consider to be very early precursor of eSports, depends on a narrow set of skills that you can't easily abstract into real life situations.
- rchaud 8y agoWith hockey, or any other professional sport, it doesn't matter if the skills aren't transferable, as a good hockey player will be in demand for as long as hockey is around. There's a built in longevity to the game that there isn't in e-gaming. If you dedicate years to honing your Starcraft 2 skills, but consumer interest shifts to Overwatch or Destiny, can you retrain fast enough to compete at a similarly high level? In IRL sports, the rules of a specific game don't change. Neither does the size of the field, the goalposts, the ball itself. So as long as you're able to improve your physical/mental focus, you can improve your performance. That's not the case when multiple variables around the game itself are changing.
- bri3d 8y agoWhen a new game comes out everyone else is also starting at zero. As long as there's churn and new games are able to gain popularity, this isn't a huge issue. Also, the skills are more transferable than they'd first appear - for example, several players have been competitive in more than one FPS game. Plus, streaming, analysis, coaching, and commentary are becoming quite lucrative.
- tomashertus 8y agoBased on my observations, the skills are solely transferable in same genre of games. I've seen great FPS players switching to different titles. I have never seen a great FPS player doing well in RTS and opposite.
- fivefive55 8y agoSo how often do you see Baseball players end up pivoting to the NFL? RTS and FPS are essentially different sports.
- jhenkens 8y agoI believe the initial argument is that "pivoting" of the players is inevitable, due to the relatively short shelf-life of a video game's popularity. Whereas a professional athlete in traditional sports can typically play one sport from childhood till retirement (be it 20, 30, 40, or 50), an e-sport professional may have to switch games after 3 years, and every 3 years, to remain relevant.
- wbl 8y agoTell that to the 1.6 pros still winning today. (Ok, before Astralis dominated everything).
- moreira 8y agoThere’s a streamer, Fitzyhere, who has gone from playing SC2 (RTS) at a competitive level, to becoming one of the best players in Overwatch (FPS). So, it does happen, but you’re right in that the skills are not easily transferable. The only thing that is, is your dexterity.
- GuB-42 8y agoThere is a bit of transferability though. ElkY is a former Starcraft pro who turned to poker with great success. He now plays Hearthstone. He used his skills as a Starcraft player to play online poker on many tables at once. Reaching the highest levels on PokerStar and joining the resident team. And while there are hyperspecific skills, like any activity at such a high level of play, what differentiate e-sports from traditional sports is that things change fast, really fast. A video game lifespan is relatively short and between that are new content, patches, and new techniques. Adapting quickly is very important. And indeed, pro players are often young and don't stay on top for very long.
- 0x00000000 8y agoThere was a pro Counter Strike player Griffin Benger ("What up now Swedes" guy) who became a professional poker player and was once the highest winning online player and has a total earnings of over $10m now. I think there are a number of pro esports players who have become full time poker players. Interesting how that drive and dedication transfers to other things.
- asosso 8y agoThere's plenty of transferability; watch any of the top FPS streamers (like Shroud) and they're amazingly competitive at just about any shooter they pick up. Fundamentals like quick camera movement, communication, corner-taking, etc transfer across many games.
- Macross8299 8y ago>eSports at this level reminds me of the old circus/carnival freak shows, I don't think that's really a fair comparison. Most of the appeal of esports is just admiration for someone who's really good at something you enjoy doing. If you played football or hockey competitively growing up, you have more appreciation of the sport than someone who never did and conversely, it's probably harder for someone who never played to really grasp the nuances or even understand the appeal beyond regional tribalism.