9 ms·
Great project, but this seems like a classic example of a programmer naively assuming a technical solution can solve a social problem.
by rootusrootus 8y ago
Great project, but this seems like a classic example of a programmer naively assuming a technical solution can solve a social problem.
- sanbor 8y agoBut it might be worth a try. Wikipedia does pretty well imho but if someone would told me the idea I would never thought that it would work.
- dfgert 8y agoWikipedia has flaws,too. 1. Your account need to have good history or social repo for your edits to be seriously considered by Wikipedia admins. 2. Admin can have their own set of bias and can decide to ignore edits. Remember Wikipedia is a centralized and under control of single entity, fact that they rely on donation doesn't change anything.
- stingraycharles 8y agoJust because something has flaws doesn’t mean it’s not a good idea to do it.
- jtuente 8y agoThere wasn't anything said about Wikipedia being a bad idea, but rather that it shouldn't be your sole source for fact-checking. I've learned that people only trust Wikipedia to the point at which it confirms their biases.
- penagwin 8y agoPart of the problem is that Wikipedia is generally pretty darn accurate. Everybody always talks about funny vandalism stories, but generally it's pretty good. The issue of course is that there's parts of it that definitely aren't correct. This makes it easy to say "Well if it's accurate 99% of the time then it must confirm what I thought!".
- drilldrive 8y agoI have found that Wikipedia is pretty great, with the sole exception for anything that is remotely political. I would look elsewhere for such content.
- stingraycharles 8y agoThe flow of the conversation was: - OP made an open platform - Someone said it could be a good idea because Wikipedia - Someone else said that Wikipedia has flaws Hence my comment.
- metasj 8y agoWikipedia, for a few high-profile current events each week, serves a function similar to the one proposed for sourcedfact; and it regularly results in deeper + more contextualized coverage than even the best outlets. However, WP's commitment to being a tertiary source means that _some_ secondary source has to properly interpret the primary sources, before that interpretation can be included.
- Chris2048 8y agoIsn't that just setting a high bar? It might not solve an issue, but it could help.
- YazIAm 8y agoThis is more a communication standard than a complicated tech solution. A communication standard for fact checks from public primary sources. Coding this wasn't actually that complicated, figuring out a design that enables readers to review the fact checking as easily as possible and enables fact checkers to collaborate easily took a lot of experimentation though. Although even that is still very much a work in progress.
- ghostbrainalpha 8y agoExactly. I would just appreciate footnotes in the articles I read that gave a detailed explanation of how much fact checking was done. That way if a story needs to be expanded upon at a later date, the next journalist can dig deeper easily picking up the trail where the previous journalist left off.
- microcolonel 8y agoI think there is a technical solution to this problem though. A structured graph of supporting facts (including an analog of identity for the sources and corroborators, pointing to the edges) is an excellent datastructure for maintaining a record of reasoning and evidence for a statement of fact. There is, of course, the social issue of convincing people that this is important, but the underlying issue is in part a technical one. I don't think it's fair to disqualify a solution based on the fact that involves technical work.
- rootusrootus 8y agoI'm reminded of the oft-quoted phrase "you cannot reason someone out of a position they did not reason themselves into." I am not trying to disqualify the solution, more like observing that the existence of provable facts has not yet been any sort of antidote for 'fake news' (whether that refers to the real deal, or the position many people take that any news they don't like is fake news).
- abathur 8y agoI don't think this sort of effort has to be ironclad to be meaningful. The margins could be a big deal, here. Some sort of attestation toolchain might enable people who care about evidence to produce more strongly-attested cases, and to get a better handle on what is and isn't sourced from others. It seems likely that using good attestation toolchains could create feedback loops for researchers, journalists, archivists, authors, film-makers, educators, students, and other people involved in knowledge production. These feedback loops might change how they research, where they start, how often they have to re-invent wheels, and raise standards by enabling these people to compete on metrics that might drive more social value than clicks, engagement, shares, or ad revenue. These effects could be important, even if you never budge the kind of person inclined to consume the information equivalent of junk-food.
- snarf21 8y agoAgreed, it is also a question of goals. Journalists can bend "facts" to support the argument they want. Title are 99% click-bait anymore. Sure there are some people who want to present fair and balanced view points but that takes a ton of work and time. Most "journalism" these days is get likes and move on.
- weberc2 8y agoRight. Many prominent newsrooms seem to regard fact checking as an obstacle to avoid. Still, it seems valuable to make it easy for readers to view the supporting or contradictory evidence. That might’ve stymied many notable media hit-pieces. Of course, many newsrooms wouldn’t want this (at least I can’t imagine The Guardian and it’s ilk would want to draw attention to their own impoverished fact:BS ratios), so it would have to be a browser plugin or similar.
- beat 8y agoPeople post contradictory evidence to journalism they don't like all the time. Their "evidence" is usually conspiracy theory crap that can't pass even logic checking, much less fact checking.
- weberc2 8y agoSure, but it's not easy to find all of the debate about a given assertion in a particular article, much less contribute to that debate (given that it's probably distributed across a bunch of social media venues). One can easily imagine hovering over a given assertion (e.g., "Damore posted an anti-diversity screed") and see the fact-checks, perhaps ranked by fact-checker's credibility in order to suppress conspiracy theory crap as well as contribute to the debate. Anyway, that there is lots of noise among the criticism doesn't mean that there isn't a lot of valid criticism. It's only been a few months since nearly the whole American newsmedia willfully mislead the nation, sending an angry mob after innocent kids, after all.
- smacktoward 8y ago> Many prominent newsrooms seem to regard fact checking as an obstacle to avoid. Or they simply can't afford to employ fact checkers anymore, now that people refuse to pay for news.
- tunesmith 8y agoWhy does it seem like that to you? Do you assume that the project should solve the problem entirely in order for it to be of any help or have any value?
- ravenstine 8y agoThis is definitely worth trying, however. I'm a bit jealous because I had nearly the same idea back when I worked in public radio, but didn't have the time to implement it. Basically it was about having facts and quotes exist as embedded units within articles, all with their own individual records of verification and relationships to all the articles in which they were used. I'm really glad someone is taking a shot at this, even though I have my doubts as to whether journalists will take it seriously. YazIAm: If you want any further inspiration, here's my old github issue where I wrote about this concept: https://github.com/SCPR/SCPRv4/issues/718 https://github.com/SCPR/SCPRv4/issues/718 I don't know what all the criteria are, but you should consider applying for a Knight Foundation grant: https://knightfoundation.org/apply/ https://knightfoundation.org/apply/
- YazIAm 8y agoJust read through some of your repo, ravenstine. Very cool! I'll be sending you an email :)
- dclowd9901 8y agoI think to solve the problem, you need to do it in steps, kind of like how chained logic works. You start with something simple: "Can we verify what someone says with public record?" Yes, here's how we do it. As one problem is solved, it starts hinting at solutions to subsequent problems. This is not a problem with a silver bullet. It's going to take a fundamental shift in how we understand and verify truth.
- throwaway284721 8y agoTechnical solutions solve social problems all the time. A lock is a technical solution to the social problem of theft, and much superior to a social solution.