4 ms·
So, your examples are all "reporting about court cases" and you use court documents as your citations for facts. Court cases are as good as we have for determi
by jellicle 8y ago
So, your examples are all "reporting about court cases" and you use court documents as your citations for facts.
Court cases are as good as we have for determining facts, I suppose. (Though the error rate in court cases is quite high!) But 99.9999% of reporting isn't about court cases. Most reporting isn't about issues that will ever be litigated, and even those things that will be litigated, haven't been at the time of the reporting.
"Mitch McConnell had oatmeal for breakfast this morning, according to sources."
There, that's a fact. Now, tell me which court case I can refer to in order to verify that fact?
Fact-checking is an impossible endeavor. The essence of journalism is reporting things no one knows. That's what news is! This is completely at odds with "fact-checking". A good news story CANNOT be fact-checked by the public because if the public knew it, it wouldn't be news. There is an extremely limited genre of "news by trawling public but little-known documents", such as reporting on old court cases. Almost zero news fits into that category.
- jpttsn 8y agoCall me a pedant, but I'd say OP is enabling "consensus checking" I find the present day's fact checking wave is a misnomer. In a world where something is false, but sourced, most of what we call fact-checking would only reinforce mistruths. e.g. The ratio of circumference to diameter is exactly three to one [1][2][3] [1]: the Bible. [2]: pious scholars. [3]: low-tech experiments. Would be cool to see someone think carefully about what "real" "fact checking" would be. First-hand sources? Links to instructions for replicating findings? Consensus checking is of course also an interesting problem, albeit a pretty different one.
- NateEag 8y agoOfftopic, but the Bible does not actually use a value of 3 for pi: https://www.purplemath.com/modules/bibleval.htm https://www.purplemath.com/modules/bibleval.htm