4 ms·
I love how he first dismisses real life reactors that publicly failed before he finds an example of how real engineers work. Was TMI not designed by real profe
by btilly 16y ago
I love how he first dismisses real life reactors that publicly failed before he finds an example of how real engineers work. Was TMI not designed by real professional engineers?
But it gets worse. He uses the safety of a large, stationary object as his example of how well engineers design systems. Why not hold up something that moves as his example instead? Like a helicopter? Oops, helicopters have a nasty tendency towards fatal failure modes. You can have redundant engines, but if you lose a helicopter blade, not much can be done other than provide you with an ejection mechanism.
But what about airplanes? Much better than helicopters. They can lose power and be landed safely. Heck, as http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Airlines_Flight_232 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Airlines_Flight_232 documents, one plane was mostly successfully landed with no hydraulics, no control of its flight surfaces, and just 2 operational thruster engines.
But add an interesting constraint, such as desire to make it hard to spot on radar, and the next thing you know you get something like the B-2 stealth bomber. Unstable on all 3 axes, and will fall out of the sky like a rock the second the automatic computer corrections stop going. Do you think that the air force spends $737 million per airplane on something that wasn't designed by engineers? Yet they built something that will literally fall out of the sky if there is a problem with the computer!
While I agree that Star Trek has lots of plot holes that you can drive large trucks through, I don't think that their lack of engineering mindset deserves to be near the top of the list. The warp engines are unstable? Well they need to burn a lot of energy, which means you need an intense energy source. They use matter/antimatter. Doesn't take much going wrong for that to blow, and anything less energy dense won't cut it. Not really a plot hole.
They use force fields everywhere? Well it takes energy, serious energy, to get actual matter up to warp speed. By using force fields preferentially and for structural integrity they save incredibly on weight, and therefore efficiency. Those engineers are to be commended for figuring out how to strip out even more matter, and not criticized for failing to use poorly suited low tech solutions.
A lot of his "problems" just aren't.
- Semiapies 16y agoEh, to go blatantly ad hominem, it's StarDestroyer.net. It's a site devoted to arguing that the technology and militaries of one not-remotely-hard SF setting are "better" than the technology and militaries of another not-remotely-hard SF setting. When I've looked before, there were straight-faced essays on there about the wonders of Imperial stormtrooper armor (augmented reality HUDs, sensors, etc.) that would have ended the Star Wars series about two minutes after the Millenium Falcon got tractor-beamed into the Death Star. There were deadpan articles about the military skills and discipline of those stormtroopers that don't at all fit with their getting slaughtered by Ewoks or a formation of them running in panic from a single charging man in their own base. The wacky justifications for all the "canon" they contradict with their claims make it clear - this stuff is not meant to be taken any more seriously than the puddi puddi meme. It's meant to amuse people and troll Trek fans. ETA: I mean, really, do we want to look at the engineering practices in Star Wars? Huge walking tanks you can trip or take out with one grenade, near-absence of railings, etc... It doesn't bear worrying about. :)