5 ms·
Real Estate agents are famous for not representing their customer's interest. In real estate, half the time (buy-side) your agent is being paid their entire inc
by lupire 8y ago
Real Estate agents are famous for not representing their customer's interest. In real estate, half the time (buy-side) your agent is being paid their entire income for the transaction by your adversary. In several states, "your agent" is legally required to disclose the fact that they are not your agent!
- AlexTWithBeard 8y agoAs usually, the disclosure is done as two crimpled pink pieces of paper with light gray print. The text on the paper tries to be legally correct and understandable by non-lawyers at the same time and fails to achieve either of these purposes. Been through that. Still angry.
- dd36 8y agoYour agent, no matter who is paying them, has a fiduciary duty to you. I’ve bought and sold a lot of property and can guarantee you that the fact that commissions are paid by sellers makes zero difference. Really, it’s coming out of the purchase price, which is netted to the seller but technically is being paid by you.
- nkurz 8y agoYour agent, no matter who is paying them, has a fiduciary duty to you. This isn't universally true. In some US states, the frequent problem is that the agent who is showing you homes (and who you tend to think of as "your agent") is not actually your agent (with fiduciary duty to you), but a subagent of the seller (with fiduciary duty to them). Here's an excerpt from recent report on this: --- For many years, a large majority of home buyers and sellers have worked with real estate agents. Most consumers believe that these agents always or almost always are required to represent the interests of the home buyer or seller with whom they are working. ... Yet, real estate agents often are not required by law to represent the interests of the buyer or seller with whom they are working, and many do not. In reality, there are a number of different types of relationships allowed in most states between real estate agents and their clients. • Single agent: The agent works solely for the client and has fiduciary responsibility. A fiduciary agent is “obligated to procure the greatest advantage to his client.” • Designated agent: The agent is recruited by the listing agent to work with a buyer and has fiduciary responsibility to that buyer. • Subagent: The agent works with the buyer but has fiduciary responsibility to the seller. • Dual agent: The agent somehow is expected to represent the interests of both the seller and buyer in a home purchase. • Transactional agent: The agent works with both buyer and seller to facilitate a sale but has no fiduciary responsibility to either party. https://consumerfed.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/the-agency-mess-home-buyer-and-seller-confusion-report.pdf https://consumerfed.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/the-agenc... --- So while it's possible that you live in a state where you are correct, where subagency and dual-agency are forbidden, in the absence of a signed contract for the services of a buyers agent, others should not follow your advice until they are certain the same is true for them.
- ry4nolson 8y agoSo who does a Secret Agent have a fiduciary responsibility to?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- klipt 8y agoDepends, are they a double agent?
- hobbyjogger 8y ago> In many US states, the frequent problem is that the agent who is showing you homes (and who you tend to think of as "your agent") is not actually your agent (with fiduciary duty to you), but a subagent of the seller (with fiduciary duty to them). Subagency was common up until the 90s but is exceedingly rare in today's market (and outright illegal in many states). In 2019, it is not at all a "frequent" problem.
- nkurz 8y agoYou are right, and I probably overstated the frequency of that particular form of agency to point out a worst-case-scenario. I likely should have stuck with the main message that for a variety of reasons, an agent who is showing you a house does not necessarily have your best interests at heart. Do you happen to know how common it is for current buyers to be represented by an agent who does owe them sole fiduciary responsibility?
- Spooky23 8y agoEnd of the day, an attorney represents your interests. A real estate agent may represent you but their actual duties are fairly minimal. Real estate agents fiduciary responsibility is held to a reasonable care standard for matters relating to real estate. That means they need to be competent. Many of the things that buyers seek advice from agents are answered like "In my experience, blah blah blah". Those are usually legal questions, which agents are not able to answer. Often when people get in trouble, its because they don't understand what they are asking and mistake salesy fluff for an answer. End of the day, 99% of what a "buyers" real estate agent does is bullshit that makes you feel better. "Sellers" real estate agents get listings, period. Buyers agents exist because people good at getting listings have a disincentive to talk to buyers. The buyers agent's primary task is getting ahold of keys quickly and pushing sellers to accept offers. Shitty agents who are incompetent or dishonest may slow-roll things to get you to accept offers quickly. They may help you identify the type of home you want, but that isn't a fiduciary duty.
- xondono 8y agoEven with fiduciary duty, most agents undersell property. When the first offers are underpriced, a lot of agents will pressure you into selling, because their income is tighly coupled with the number of transactions per year. There’s a couple of studies from the US that concluded that most sellers close the deals way too early, and that rationally they should have waited for more offers.
- gnopgnip 8y agoThe sale price, and what offer to accept is not the decision of the agent, it is up the seller.
- vkou 8y agoIt is up to the seller, but when an experienced professional who tells you they have your best interests in mind tells you to underprice (because it's better for their bottom line)... Actually, that's the poster child for a conflict of interest.
- pnw_hazor 8y agoReal Estate agents are hopelessly conflicted. I don't use them so the seller's agents ends up working for me too. They tend to slip into a mediator role more than a fiduciary. Lawyers would get disbarred it they operated similarly.
- tomohawk 8y agoIn our state, there is a well known realtor who has grown his practice using unethical methods. As one example, his agents routinely hang on to bids and don't present them to sellers within a reasonable time, using them to get buyers who have contracted with them to put in bids. ("You better put in a bid above asking - other people have put in bids"). This allows him to get the full commission instead of sharing it with other companies.
- gregmac 8y agoThe incentives are also very messed up, because of the way commission is paid. Freakonomics [1] famously covered this: Commission is typically 6%, which is split 4 ways to the buying agent, their agency, the selling agent and their agency. So your agent personally takes home 1.5% of the selling price -- on a $300,000 sale, they are making $4,500. The difference between selling your house for $300,000 and $310,000 after commission is $9,400 in your pocket -- and a paltry $150 for the agent. Are they going to take the risk of leaving it on the market for an extra week (and spending more time showing it, etc) hoping to make an extra $150? Of course not. (Spoiler alert for the book: unless it's their own home, in which case they leave it on the market for an extra 10 days and sell for an extra 3% on average). Another incentive problem exists on the buy-side: your agent gets paid more money the more you pay for the house. It's literally working against their interest to negotiate a lower price, other than when it's above your absolute maximum. [1] http://freakonomics.com/books/#freakonomics http://freakonomics.com/books/#freakonomics
- tomohawk 8y agoThis is why, when selling, its better to use a la cart brokers. You pay a set fee to MLS your place, and set fees for other things. You still need to pay a commission to the buyer broker/agent, otherwise they won't show your place. So, 2.5% or 3%. Traditionally, the commission paid was 5% (split 4 ways), but some markets that got as high as 7%. I once had an agent explain to me (who was bad at math) that this was due to inflation.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoYeah, I’ve had supposedly educated people try to tell me they tip 20%+ for standard waiter service instead of 15% due to inflation. Some work in finance. And sometimes on tip on the tax too. Crazy times we live in.
- lsiebert 8y agoThe real value of wages for waiters has decreased significantly because of inflation. Though that's not really inflation's fault as much as a lack of meaningful wage increases.
- CalChris 8y agoIt's worse that that. First, all of the money comes from the buyer; that's why they're called the buyer. It goes to the seller who pays the closing costs. So the entire BPP = Buyer's Price of House is (Seller's Price of House + Closing Costs). The buyer will then pay sales tax on BPP. Yes, you are paying sales tax on the closing cost. It's worse still. You then pay property taxes on the BPP which means that you pay property taxes on the closing costs. You can and I did negotiate the BPP and then tell the seller that you will be paying the closing costs yourself and deducting them from the BPP. Then you avoid paying sales tax on the closing cost service and paying property tax on the closing cost service. Oh, and don't even get me started on the financial services industry scam of mortgage interest deductions.
- 171243 8y agoplease... tell me more. this is badly needed advice.